---
title: "Federal Judge Sends New York's Kalshi Enforcement Case Back to State Court"
url: https://altstreet.investments/news/new-york-ag-v-kalshi-remanded-to-state-court-sdny-opinion-2026-11-19
kind: news-article
updated: 2026-11-20
description: "S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-06550, Nov. 19, 2026: New York AG v. KalshiEX remanded to state court. Federal officer removal rejected, the one claim predicated on the Wire Act not a substantial federal question, fees denied, protective-order motion undecided; preemption not reached. Kalshi's separate Second Circuit appeal continues."
publisher: AltStreet (https://altstreet.investments)
license: Public factual pages may be read, quoted and cited with attribution and a link. Bulk redistribution is not permitted.
---

# Federal Judge Sends New York's Kalshi Enforcement Case Back to State Court

On November 19, 2026 Judge Vernon S. Broderick remanded the Attorney General's Executive Law 63(12) proceeding against KalshiEX LLC to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County, rejecting removal under the federal officer statute and the Gunn-Grable test and denying fees. The ruling fixes the forum; it does not decide whether Kalshi's contracts violate New York law or whether federal commodities law preempts the state's claims.

By Michael E., Head of Research, AltStreet Research (https://altstreet.investments/authors/michael-e). Published November 20, 2026. Platform: Kalshi (https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/kalshi). Entity: People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC.

New York's enforcement case against Kalshi is returning to state court after a federal judge rejected the exchange's grounds for removal. The November 19 ruling determines where the case proceeds; it does not decide whether Kalshi's contracts violate New York law or whether federal commodities law preempts the state's claims. Judge Vernon S. Broderick of the Southern District of New York granted the Attorney General's motion to remand People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC, No. 26-CV-6550, to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County, denied the state's request for fees, and left Kalshi's motion for a protective order undecided for want of jurisdiction.

Preemption, the question at the center of Kalshi's cases in the Third, Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits, was not before the court. Footnote 4 records that Kalshi 'specifies that preemption is "not [a] basis for removal here"', so the opinion says nothing about whether the Commodity Exchange Act displaces New York's gambling law. That remains Kalshi's defense, now to be heard in state court.

## What New York filed, and why it stays in state court

The Attorney General filed the petition on July 31, 2026 under Executive Law 63(12), the statute that lets the state's top law officer bring a summary proceeding, on five days' notice, against 'repeated or persistent' illegality. It asks the court to enjoin Kalshi from operating a gambling business in New York without a Gaming Commission license. All eight causes of action are 63(12) claims; they are predicated on the state constitution, the Penal Law, the Racing Law and, in the eighth, an alleged violation of the federal Wire Act. Kalshi removed the case to federal court the same day.

Kalshi's first ground was the federal officer removal statute: that its CFTC designation is 'property' derived from a federal officer and that the suit 'affects the validity of' the Commodity Exchange Act. The court held that the petition does not challenge the CEA at all; the CEA's role 'is limited to Kalshi's defense that it acted under the authority of its CFTC-issued license', and defenses do not supply removal jurisdiction. Kalshi did not claim to act under a federal officer, and its argument that the CFTC was a necessary party failed because the remedy for a missing party is joinder in state court, not removal; the CFTC 'has not sought to intervene in this action', although it did in Kalshi's Rhode Island case.

Kalshi's second ground was that the claims necessarily turn on federal law. Only the eighth claim does, because it is predicated on the Wire Act, and the court found that issue not substantial: the Wire Act turns on whether betting is illegal under state law, and the UIGEA, which Kalshi relied on for a carve-out for CFTC-regulated transactions, states that it does not alter other federal or state gambling laws, as the Ninth Circuit held in KalshiEX v. Assad on August 28, 2026 and the Western District of Wisconsin held in Ho-Chunk Nation v. Kalshi in May. Taking a 63(12) proceeding into federal court would also 'disrupt the State's chosen forum'. Either failure was enough to remand.


## No fees, no protective order, two New York cases

The court refused New York's costs because Kalshi 'raised colorable arguments that removal was proper' and one federal court, the Middle District of Georgia in Georgia Gambling Recovery LLC v. Kalshi Inc. in February 2026, had sided with it, though that plaintiff was a private party rather than a state. Kalshi's motion for a protective order against the Attorney General's investigative subpoena, raised in an October 30 joint letter and renewed November 4, was not decided; a court without jurisdiction cannot rule on discovery, and whether the subpoena dispute resumes in state court is for that court.

Two New York cases are now proceeding on separate tracks. This enforcement case goes back to the Supreme Court of New York. Kalshi's own suit against the Gaming Commission, KalshiEX LLC v. Williams, remains on appeal in the Second Circuit (No. 26-1835) after Judge Torres denied a preliminary injunction on July 7, 2026. The petition's allegations about licensing, users aged 18 to 20 and contracts on New York college teams were recited by the court as background, not as findings. AltStreet's census counts New York among eleven states that have sued Kalshi and Kalshi as plaintiff or appellant in 27 of 86 federal matters.


## What this report does not cover

AltStreet read the 19-page Opinion and Order from the RECAP archive and the docket text it cites, not the petition, Kalshi's opposition brief or the October 30 joint letter, which are described as the opinion describes them. The state-court index number after remand was not available on November 20, 2026.


## Key facts

- Opinion and Order, People of the State of New York, by Letitia James, Attorney General v. KalshiEX LLC, S.D.N.Y. No. 26-CV-6550 (VSB), Doc. 25, November 19, 2026, 19 pages: 'Plaintiff's motion to remand is GRANTED and its request for attorneys' fees and costs is DENIED. Because I lack subject-matter jurisdiction, I cannot decide Kalshi's motion for a protective order.' The Clerk is directed to effect immediate remand to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County.
- The ruling determines where the case proceeds. It does not decide whether Kalshi's contracts violate New York law. Footnote 4: the court did not examine whether removal is justified on the basis that the CEA preempts Executive Law 63(12), 'because Kalshi specifies that preemption is "not [a] basis for removal here"'. Preemption remains Kalshi's defense for the state court.
- The petition, filed July 31, 2026 under Executive Law 63(12), asks the state court to enjoin Kalshi from operating a gambling business in New York without a Gaming Commission license. Its eight causes of action are all 63(12) claims: one predicated on the state constitution, three on the Penal Law, three on the Racing Law and one on an alleged violation of the federal Wire Act, 18 U.S.C. 1084(a). Kalshi removed the case the same day.
- Federal officer removal: the suit does not 'affect the validity of' the Commodity Exchange Act; the CEA's role 'is limited to Kalshi's defense that it acted under the authority of its CFTC-issued license', and defenses do not supply removal jurisdiction. Kalshi did not claim to act under a federal officer, and the CFTC 'has not sought to intervene in this action' (it did in Kalshi's Rhode Island case).
- Federal question: only the Wire Act-predicated claim necessarily raises a federal issue; the other seven rest on state statutes with no carve-out for conduct authorized under the CEA. The Wire Act issue is not substantial because the Act turns on state gambling law and the UIGEA disclaims altering other gambling laws, citing KalshiEX v. Assad (9th Cir. Aug. 28, 2026) and Ho-Chunk Nation v. Kalshi (W.D. Wis. May 11, 2026); federal jurisdiction over a 63(12) summary proceeding would also 'disrupt the State's chosen forum'.
- Fees denied: Kalshi 'raised colorable arguments', and one federal court, in Georgia Gambling Recovery LLC v. Kalshi Inc. (M.D. Ga. Feb. 3, 2026), sided with it, though that plaintiff was a private party; Kentucky, Ohio and Washington remands in 2026 also denied fees.
- Two New York cases are proceeding. This enforcement case returns to state court. Kalshi's own suit against the Gaming Commission, KalshiEX LLC v. Williams (S.D.N.Y. 25-CV-8846), is on appeal in the Second Circuit (No. 26-1835) after Judge Torres denied a preliminary injunction on July 7, 2026. The petition's allegations, recited by the court as background and not as findings: no Gaming Commission license, users aged 18 to 20 permitted, contracts on New York college teams, and a cease-and-desist of October 24, 2025.
- AltStreet's census: New York is one of eleven states that have sued Kalshi; Kalshi is plaintiff or appellant in 27 of the 86 federal matters AltStreet counts. The Fourth Circuit affirmed Maryland's win on November 18, 2026 and New Jersey's Supreme Court petition (No. 26-299) awaits Kalshi's response, due December 7.


## Sources

- Opinion and Order, People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC, No. 26-CV-6550 (VSB) (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 19, 2026), Doc. 25: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.669650/gov.uscourts.nysd.669650.25.0.pdf
- Docket, People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-06550: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73700030/people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-letitia-james-attorney-general-of-the/
- Kalshi litigation tracker: https://altstreet.investments/research/kalshi-litigation
- Kalshi review: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/kalshi

---

Source page: https://altstreet.investments/news/new-york-ag-v-kalshi-remanded-to-state-court-sdny-opinion-2026-11-19
Machine index: https://altstreet.investments/llms.txt
AltStreet reads what platforms, funds and issuers file with the SEC and what they tell investors, and publishes the difference. Figures are as filed or as captured on the date stated; nothing here is investment advice.
