---
title: "Cityfunds Review 2026: The Paused Offering, the Affiliate Transfer, and the 41% Order-Book Discount to a Stale NAV"
url: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/cityfunds
kind: platform-review
updated: 2026-09-26
description: "Cityfunds review 2026: the Regulation A offering is paused, the ten city series contributed their home equity agreements to an affiliate fund in May 2025, the manager is no longer updating valuations, and posted secondary orders sit 37% to 42% below the last mark. Built from fifteen SEC filings."
publisher: AltStreet (https://altstreet.investments)
license: Public factual pages may be read, quoted and cited with attribution and a link. Bulk redistribution is not permitted.
---

# Cityfunds Review 2026: The Paused Offering, the Affiliate Transfer, and the 41% Order-Book Discount to a Stale NAV

Ten city home-equity funds whose Regulation A offering is paused, whose assets were contributed to an affiliate fund in May 2025, and whose interests are quoted on a registered venue at roughly 41% below a net asset value that is no longer being updated.

AltStreet score: 26.3 (F), scored September 27, 2026. Method: https://altstreet.investments/platforms

| Field | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Platform | Cityfunds |
| What it is | Retail Home-Equity Fund Platform (Regulation A Tier 2 series LLC, ten city series, offering paused, secondary trading on the PPEX ATS) |
| Asset class | Home Equity Agreements, which the filings call Homeshares, plus a residual of single-family rentals; since May 2025 held indirectly through limited partnership interests in an affiliate fund |
| Website | cityfunds.com |
| Review first published | September 26, 2026 |
| Last updated | September 26, 2026 |
| AltStreet relationship | None: no affiliate, sponsorship or partnership |

## The short version

A Regulation A program that raised about $5.34 million across ten city series, paused its offering, moved its assets into an affiliate fund, stopped publishing valuations, and left a registered order book quoting the result at roughly 41% below the last mark.

- **May 8, 2025** The date every series contributed its home equity agreements to U.S. Home Equity Fund I, L.P., a related party under common control, receiving limited partnership interests that the Form 1-SA says are substantially all of each series' assets.
- **1 markdown in 48** Across forty-eight published net asset value observations from May 2023 to August 2024, exactly one series was ever marked down: Austin, from $11.09 to $11.03. Every other move was up or flat.
- **7 of 7 fell** After the offering paused, every series with a prior net asset value came back lower at December 31, 2025. Tampa fell 20.6% from $11.78 to $9.35, Austin 14.3%, Dallas 8.1%.
- **37% to 42%** The range of discounts to that December 2025 net asset value across every posted bid and ask on September 26, 2026, clustering near 41% in every city.
- **$5.34M** Total reported capital across all ten series: roughly $4.54 million under Regulation A and $794,250 under Regulation Crowdfunding, both retail, plus $2,500 under Regulation D Rule 506(c), which is accredited-only. Mostly stated net of offering costs, with a few series stated gross.
- **$860 and $0** What Nashville and Las Vegas raised. Both are still listed as classes of Regulation A securities on the cover of the annual report.

Data note: Capital figures are from note 8 of the Form 1-K filed 2026-02-03 and mix net-of-cost and gross bases as the filing states them. Net asset values are the company's own table in the same filing. Secondary prices are posted orders observed on 2026-09-26 and are not executed trades.


## Verdict

The disclosure is better than the product. Cityfunds files audited annual and semiannual reports, tabulates its own valuation history, states its substantial-doubt disclosure, names its related parties and discloses the transaction that changed what every investor owns. The product those documents describe is a paused offering whose city-specific exposure has been pooled into an affiliate fund, whose valuation is no longer being updated by the party that produces it, and whose only observable pricing is an order book quoting roughly half of the last primary price.

**Best for**

- An existing holder who needs to understand what they now own and what the exit actually looks like
- A reader studying how a small Regulation A series program behaves once the primary closes

**Look elsewhere if**

- You want exposure to a named city's housing market, which these series no longer provide directly
- You need a redemption right, a distribution policy or a current valuation
- You would be relying on the displayed net asset value as a price

**Strengths**

- A genuine secondary-market venue: the PPEX ATS operated by North Capital Private Securities, an SEC-registered broker-dealer, with one-day settlement and Dalmore Group as broker-dealer of record. AltStreet has not observed executions, so the venue provides access rather than a demonstrated exit at the displayed quotes
- Audited Regulation A reporting maintained through the pause, with a per-series financial schedule unusually granular for a program this small
- The hard facts are disclosed rather than buried: the contribution transaction, the related-party status of the counterparties, the pause, the substantial-doubt disclosure and the fact that Las Vegas never raised anything
- A stated, checkable fee structure on the retail series: 1.50% annually and a 1.00% acquisition fee

**Limitations**

- Since May 2025 the city series hold limited partnership interests in one affiliate fund rather than city assets
- The manager prepares net asset value and is not currently updating it, while the venue it points holders to keeps displaying the stale figure
- No redemption rights, no established redemption plan, and distributions at the manager's sole discretion
- A substantial-doubt disclosure covering the company and its series, in two consecutive reports
- Drafting quality in the most recent report: unfilled template placeholders, figures that disagree with the accompanying financial statements, and a revenue total that omits one series
- Related-party leverage on both sides of the balance sheet before the transfer, including a $3,338,879 affiliate revolving line and a $1,539,202 note receivable from related parties


## What this means for your decision.

| Topic | Finding |
| --- | --- |
|  | Your city series no longer holds your city |
|  | The offering is paused and the manager has stopped publishing marks |
|  | Every posted order sits about 41% below that stale mark |
|  | Substantial doubt about the company continuing, in two consecutive reports |
|  | Two of the ten city funds barely exist |

Cityfunds sold city-specific home equity exposure priced at a published net asset value. As of this review the offering is paused, the assets sit in an affiliate fund, the net asset value is nine months old and not currently being updated, and the only observable pricing is an order book quoting roughly half of what the last primary investors paid. The filings disclose all of it plainly, which is to the company's credit and is also how this review was written.


## Who it fits

| Investor | Fit | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| retail | poor-fit |  |
| institutional | poor-fit |  |
| investors-seeking-returns | poor-fit |  |
| esg-saas-embedded | poor-fit |  |


## Questions

**Is Cityfunds still open to new investors?**

Not in the primary. The Form 1-K filed February 3, 2026 states that the Regulation A offering of each series "has been paused", and the last pricing supplement was filed September 23, 2024. No Form 1-Z, which would formally terminate the offering, has been filed. You can still buy and sell existing interests on the PPEX ATS, an alternative trading system operated by North Capital Private Securities Corporation, and anyone can open an account there.

**Do Cityfunds still hold homes in the city on the label?**

Not directly. On May 8, 2025 every series entered a contribution agreement with U.S. Home Equity Fund I, L.P. and two affiliated entities, all of which the filing describes as related parties under common control, and contributed its home equity agreements and related assets in exchange for limited partnership interests. The Form 1-SA states that those interests "represents substantially all the assets held by each of the Series". The balance sheet shows home equity investments falling from $9,643,096 to nil with an investment in partnership of $5,957,709 in their place. Each series holds its own partnership interest, so the exposure is to the same fund rather than to one jointly owned asset.

**Why do Cityfunds shares trade so far below net asset value?**

AltStreet observed every posted bid and ask on September 26, 2026 sitting 37% to 42% below the net asset value displayed beside them, clustering within a percentage point of 41% across Austin, Denver, Phoenix and Tampa. Two disclosed facts bear on it. The platform states the displayed net asset value was last finalized as of December 31, 2025 and that the manager "is not providing specific guidance, updated valuations, or 'marks' at this time". And since May 2025 each series holds a partnership interest in the same affiliate fund, so the near-uniform discounts are consistent with participants treating the series as one exposure rather than eight differentiated city portfolios. These are posted orders rather than executed trades, so they show what participants are willing to quote, not what has cleared, and they cannot establish why those prices were chosen.

**Has Cityfunds ever marked a series down?**

Once, in its published history. The Form 1-K tabulates forty-eight net asset value observations across seven series from May 31, 2023 to August 31, 2024, and exactly one is a markdown: Austin, from $11.09 to $11.03 at March 31, 2024, a move of half a percent. Every other change was up or flat, and five series sat at the $10.00 issue price throughout. The first substantial declines appear in the next figure the company published, as of December 31, 2025, after the offering had paused: seven of the seven series with a prior mark were lower, Tampa by 20.6%.

**Can I redeem my Cityfunds investment?**

No. The offering circular states that holders of series interests "have no conversion, exchange, sinking fund, redemption or appraisal rights", and refers to a redemption plan as one "which the Company has yet to establish". The secondary market on the PPEX ATS is the exit, at whatever price the order book supports.

**Does Cityfunds pay distributions?**

There is no distribution policy. The offering circular says net capital event proceeds are "not generally expected to be distributed" and that the manager "may change the timing of distributions or determine that no distributions shall be made in its sole discretion". Only the separate Cityfunds Yield vehicle is described anywhere as distributing, and that description is on the website rather than in these filings. Home equity agreements generate revenue only when a homeowner sells, refinances or buys out, which is why reported revenue fell from $186,662 in 2023 to $90,840 in 2024 and $43,150 in the first half of 2025.

**What does Cityfunds charge?**

Each series pays the manager a quarterly asset management fee of 0.375%, which is 1.50% annually, on series value, plus an acquisition fee of 1.00% of the purchase price of any single-family home the series acquires, plus a property management fee at unspecified market terms, plus reimbursement of operating and offering expenses. The manager and its affiliates incurred $350,139 of offering and general and administrative expenses in 2024 and $307,939 in 2023. The sponsor's separate accredited fund publishes different terms, 1.5% management with a 10% preferred return and 15% carried interest, and the filings do not say how those reach a contributed series.

**Did the SEC take action against Cityfunds?**

No enforcement action. On October 22, 2024 the SEC issued an order declaring an amended offering statement abandoned under Rule 256 because it had been on file for more than nine months without being qualified. That is procedural: it contains no allegation and no finding of misconduct. AltStreet's scan found no enforcement action against any Cityfunds or Nada entity, and the filings state no material legal proceedings. Note that the company's own annual report describes the same order as the Regulation A offering having been "formally classified as closed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on October 22, 2024", while elsewhere describing the offering as paused.

**Is Cityfunds the same as Homeshares?**

They are the same business. "Homeshares" is the name the filings give to the asset: the Form 1-K says the company invests in residential real estate "primarily through home equity investments which we have termed 'Homeshares'". It is also now the consumer-facing brand, and cityfunds.com carries a page headed "Cityfunds is Now Part of Homeshares". Both sit under Nada Holdings, Inc., which does business as Homeshares and manages Cityfunds I, LLC, Cityfunds Portfolio Fund, LLC, Cityfunds Yield, LLC and US Home Equity Fund I, L.P.

**Who audits Cityfunds, and is there a going-concern paragraph?**

Barton CPA of Cypress, Texas, described in the filing as Certified Public Accountants and Advisors and a PCAOB Registered Firm. Its report on fiscal 2024 states that the company and each listed series "have experienced recurring losses, and negative cash flows from operations, and their lack of liquidity raise substantial doubt about their ability to continue as a going concern". The Form 1-SA for the six months to June 30, 2025 restates that doubt. This is a going-concern paragraph, which is a substantial-doubt disclosure rather than a qualified audit opinion, and it covers the company and each listed series, not only the manager.

**How much did Cityfunds actually raise?**

About $5.34 million of total reported capital across all ten series: roughly $4.54 million under Regulation A and $794,250 under Regulation Crowdfunding, both open to retail investors, plus $2,500 under Regulation D Rule 506(c), which was accredited-only. Austin totals $1,111,857 and Dallas $1,237,952. Four series raised under $350,000. Nashville raised $860, and the Form 1-K states that Las Vegas conducted no offerings and sold no interests in either 2024 or 2023. Both are still listed on the cover of the annual report as classes of securities issued under Regulation A. Figures are mostly net of offering costs, with a few stated gross as the filing presents them.

**Is Cityfunds a scam?**

AltStreet located no SEC enforcement action and no public fraud finding against Cityfunds or Nada in the sources reviewed, and the filings state no material legal proceedings. PACER and state dockets were not searched. Cityfunds I, LLC files audited annual and semiannual reports, its secondary market runs on a registered alternative trading system operated by an SEC-registered broker-dealer, and its filings disclose the difficult facts, including the substantial-doubt disclosure, the related-party transaction that changed what each series holds, and the fact that one series never raised anything. Note that qualification under Regulation A is not SEC approval of an offering or of its merits. The concerns here are different from fraud: the offering is paused, the assets sit in an affiliate fund, the manager prepares net asset value and is not currently updating it, there is no redemption right or distribution policy, and posted secondary orders sit far below the last published mark.


## Update history

**September 27, 2026: Correction: fiscal 2023 revenue was $186,662, not $133,851**

The initial review carried $133,851 as Cityfunds' fiscal 2023 revenue in three places. It is wrong. AltStreet's own extraction of Form 1-K 0001493152-24-050480, which balances, reports $186,662, and an independent read of the same filing reports $186,662 as well; $133,851 could not be reconciled to any line in the extracted statements. The correction makes the review's point stronger rather than weaker: revenue fell from 2023 to 2024 by just over half, not by about a third. Every other figure on that filing, total assets of $6,934,655, liabilities of $2,172,010, equity of $4,762,645, cash of $522,928 and net income of $128,435, was already correct and is unchanged.

**September 26, 2026: Initial review: the paused offering, the May 2025 contribution of assets to an affiliate fund, and an order book quoting 41% below a stale mark**

Built from fifteen primary documents and same-day crawls of both company websites. The central finding is the Contribution Transaction of May 8, 2025, under which every city series contributed its home equity agreements to U.S. Home Equity Fund I, L.P., a related party under common control, in exchange for limited partnership interests that the Form 1-SA describes as substantially all the assets held by each series. That single transaction bears on the rest: why the city marks fell after the primary paused, why the manager stopped publishing valuations, why the affiliate fund holds a $16.8 million portfolio while its only Form D reports $100,000 from three investors, and why posted secondary orders are quoted at close to the same 41% discount in every city. Also recorded: a published valuation history of forty-eight observations containing exactly one markdown; seven of seven series lower after the pause; a substantial-doubt disclosure in two consecutive reports; no redemption rights and a redemption plan the circular says has yet to be established; a fee stack of 1.50% annually plus a 1.00% acquisition fee plus an unquantified property management fee; related-party leverage in both directions; and two series, Nashville at $860 and Las Vegas at nil, still listed as classes of qualified securities.


## Evidence appendix

Platform website captured September 26, 2026.

Fifteen primary documents were read in full and held to disk, and both company websites were crawled on the same day. Net asset value history is the company's own table from the Form 1-K, incorporated by reference in that filing, rather than a figure reconstructed from pricing supplements; where the supplements state an offering price that differs from net asset value, as with Phoenix, the net asset value table governs. Secondary prices are posted bids and asks observed on a single day and are treated as quotes throughout.

**Highlights**

- Form 1-SA: "As a result of the transaction described above, the limited partnership interests in the Transferee represents substantially all the assets held by each of the Series."
- Form 1-K: "As of the date of this filing, the offering of each series' interests of the Company pursuant to Regulation A has been paused. The pause of the offerings does not affect the Company's ongoing reporting obligations under Regulation A."
- Form 1-K auditor's report: the company and each listed series "have experienced recurring losses, and negative cash flows from operations, and their lack of liquidity raise substantial doubt about their ability to continue as a going concern."
- Trading screen: "While the secondary market platform facilitates trading, the Manager is not providing specific guidance, updated valuations, or 'marks' at this time."
- Terms of Use: "Secondary trading activity for Cityfunds Series occurs via an electronic alternative trading system, or 'ATS', operated by North Capital Private Securities Corporation ... an SEC-registered broker-dealer and member of FINRA and SIPC in accordance with SEC Regulation ATS."
- Offering circular: "Holders of series interests have no conversion, exchange, sinking fund, redemption or appraisal rights, no pre-emptive rights to subscribe for any interests and no preferential rights to distributions."
- Offering circular on the valuation agent: the independent valuation expert "is not responsible for, nor for preparing, our NAV per interest."
- Form 1-K note 9: "each Series shall pay to the Manager a quarterly asset management fee equal to 0.375% (1.50% annually) of its value ... Each Series will also pay the Manager an acquisition fee equal to 1.00% of the purchase price for any single-family home that the Series may acquire."
- Form 1-K note 8 on Las Vegas: "No offerings were conducted, and no such Series #Las Vegas Interests were sold during the years ended December 31, 2024 and 2023."
- SEC order of 2024-10-22: "The amended offering statement has been on file for more than nine months and has not yet been qualified ... it is ORDERED that the amended offering statement be declared abandoned."

**Primary source pages**

- Form 1-A offering statement filed 2021-12-16 (file 024-11754)
- Form 1-A POS filed 2023-11-20, the latest post-qualification amendment
- All thirty-seven Form 253G pricing supplements, 2023-10-27 to 2024-09-23
- Form 1-K filed 2026-02-03 for fiscal 2024
- Form 1-SA filed 2026-02-09 for the six months to June 30, 2025
- SEC staff order of 2024-10-22 declaring an amended offering statement abandoned under Rule 256
- SEC staff letter of 2021-12-27 and the issuer's qualification request of 2022-09-06
- Nada Holdings, Inc. Form C-AR filings of 2022-09-09 and 2023-12-27
- US Home Equity Fund I, L.P. Form D filed 2025-04-15
- homeshares.co, twelve pages including the invest, portfolio, secondary-trading and terms pages, crawled 2026-09-26
- cityfunds.com, three pages, crawled 2026-09-26


## Related

- Full review (HTML): https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/cityfunds
- Every platform review: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews
- Methodology and scoring: https://altstreet.investments/platforms
- Category hub: https://altstreet.investments/categories/fractional-real-assets

---

Source page: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/cityfunds
Machine index: https://altstreet.investments/llms.txt
AltStreet reads what platforms, funds and issuers file with the SEC and what they tell investors, and publishes the difference. Figures are as filed or as captured on the date stated; nothing here is investment advice.
