---
title: "Courtyard Review 2026: Vaulted Graded Cards, Digital Packs Priced at 96% Expected Value, and an Instant Buyback"
url: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/courtyard
kind: platform-review
updated: 2026-10-04
description: "Is Courtyard legit? Yes, with caveats: vaulted graded cards owned through NFTs and fee-free trading, but packs with a stated expected value of 96% of the price and a buyback with a 6% fee."
publisher: AltStreet (https://altstreet.investments)
license: Public factual pages may be read, quoted and cited with attribution and a link. Bulk redistribution is not permitted.
---

# Courtyard Review 2026: Vaulted Graded Cards, Digital Packs Priced at 96% Expected Value, and an Instant Buyback

Courtyard sells graded trading cards and other collectibles that sit in its own vault and change hands as NFTs on Polygon; under its terms the NFT conveys ownership of the physical item, storage and insurance are free, and peer-to-peer trades carry no fee. A major part of the product is the Vending Machine: paid packs from $10 to $20,000 that each reveal one random item. Courtyard publishes its own expected value for every pack, and on all 107 packs in its catalog that figure is 96% of the price. In 5,285 recent pulls AltStreet sampled (up to the latest 50 per pack, not weighted by sales), 78% of items were valued below the price of the pack they came from. Pulls come with a seven-day buyback offer based on Courtyard's fair-market-value estimate, at a card offer ratio Courtyard does not publish, plus a 6% fee under the NFT terms. 79% of the sampled pull tokens were burned a median 67 seconds after the pull; the timing is consistent with heavy use of that buyback, but Courtyard's documents do not establish that a buyback burns the token.

AltStreet score: 40.2 (C-), scored October 4, 2026. Method: https://altstreet.investments/platforms

| Field | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Platform | Courtyard |
| What it is | Collectibles Marketplace and Vault: Graded Items Represented by NFTs, Paid Randomized Packs With an Instant Buyback |
| Asset class | Graded trading cards (Pokémon, sports, One Piece, Magic), plus coins, comics, sneakers and watches, held in Courtyard's vault |
| Website | courtyard.io |
| Review first published | October 4, 2026 |
| Last updated | October 4, 2026 |
| AltStreet relationship | None: no affiliate, sponsorship or partnership |

## The short version

Courtyard is two products under one roof. The first is a well-built place to own graded collectibles: the item sits in Courtyard's US vault, insured at market value per Courtyard, and the NFT that represents it 'represents and conveys ownership' of the item under Courtyard's terms, so it can be traded on Courtyard's marketplace without fees, held at no cost, or redeemed for delivery anywhere. The second is the Vending Machine: you pay a fixed price, from $10 for a sealed booster to $20,000 for a Rolex, Patek Philippe or Audemars Piguet box, and receive one item drawn at random from a published value distribution. Its economics read in three steps. Stated: Courtyard's catalog gives an expected value for every pack, and on all 107 packs that figure is exactly 96% of the price, so the buyer starts with an expected-value gap equal to 4% of the pack price, at Courtyard's own valuations. Sampled: across 5,285 recent pulls, up to the latest 50 per pack and not weighted by each pack's sales, the items' fair-market-value estimates came to 94.3% of the dollars spent, and 78% of pulls were valued below the price of the pack. Cashed out: each pull comes with a seven-day buyback offer based on Courtyard's FMV, at a card offer ratio Courtyard does not publish, and the NFT terms separately take a 6% fee on buyback consideration. Third parties describe card buybacks at roughly 90% of FMV, and Courtyard's watch documentation states 95%; AltStreet could not establish whether the reported 90% is quoted before or after the 6% fee. If it is before the fee, the sampled pull values imply that a buyer who immediately sells every pull back recovers roughly 80 cents per dollar spent. Most sampled pull tokens leave circulation almost at once: 79% were burned, at a median 67 seconds, timing consistent with heavy use of the buyback, though Courtyard's documents do not establish that buybacks cause those burns. Courtyard is unusually open about its odds, but it supplies the valuations on which those odds and the buyback depend. The rest of the record is that of a private operating company: no financial statements, no vault attestation, no SEC filings, an arbitration clause, user vaulting paused since April 14, 2026, and no legal action located.

- **96%** Courtyard's own expected value as a share of the price, on every one of the 107 packs in its catalog on October 4, 2026, from a $10 sealed booster to a $20,000 watch box. The buyer starts with an expected-value gap of 4% of the price, at Courtyard's own valuations; Courtyard's own margin depends on what it paid for the items and is not disclosed.
- **78%** Share of 5,285 sampled pulls (August 31 to October 4, 2026; up to the latest 50 per pack, not weighted by sales) whose Courtyard fair-market-value estimate was below the price of the pack they came from. The share was 77% to 79% in every price band; about 3% of pulls were valued at twice the pack price or more.
- **94.3%** Aggregate fair-market-value estimate of the sampled pulls as a share of the dollars spent on those packs, AltStreet's calculation from Courtyard's feed. It describes the sampled pack universe, not Courtyard's customer-weighted outcome, and FMV is Courtyard's own proprietary estimate.
- **6%** The Courtyard Fee on buyback consideration when a Vending Machine buyback offer is accepted, per the NFT terms; the card offer ratio itself is not published. There is no fee on peer-to-peer marketplace trades, and storage and insurance are free.
- **79% in ~1 minute** Share of sampled pulls whose token was burned, at a median 67 seconds after the pull (88% within five minutes). A redemption requires identity verification and shipping, so the timing is consistent with the instant buyback, but Courtyard's documents do not establish that a buyback burns the token.
- **Paused** Courtyard's vaulting service for new collector submissions, since April 14, 2026; cards already in the vault remain redeemable. Courtyard moved custody from Brink's to its own vault in 2025.

Data note: Pack prices and expected values are from Courtyard's catalog; pull outcomes are AltStreet's calculations from Courtyard's recent-pulls feed (up to 50 pulls per pack, not sales-weighted) and its fair-market-value estimates, which are Courtyard's own. Fees and ownership terms are from the Terms of Service and the NFT terms (February 24, 2026). Scale figures are third-party or platform-reported. Courtyard, Inc. publishes no financial statements.


## Key figures

| Figure | What it is | Context |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 96% | Courtyard tells you its packs are worth 96 cents on the dollar at its own valuations, and in the pulls AltStreet sampled, 78% came back worth less than the pack. | Courtyard's stated expected value as a share of the price, on all 107 packs. Courtyard pack catalog, captured October 4, 2026 ($480 expected value on the $500 Pokémon Platinum Pack). |
| 78% | Sampled pulls valued below the price of their pack (5,285 pulls, August 31 to October 4, 2026). | AltStreet calculation from Courtyard's recent-pulls feed and FMV estimates; up to 50 pulls per pack, not sales-weighted. |
| 6% | Courtyard Fee on buyback consideration when a Vending Machine buyback offer is accepted. | NFT Terms and Asset Management Services Agreement, February 24, 2026; no fee on marketplace trades. |
| 67 seconds | Median time from pull to token burn, for the 79% of sampled pulls whose token was burned. | Consistent with heavy use of the instant buyback; Courtyard's documents do not establish that a buyback burns the token. |
| 0 located | Lawsuits, regulatory actions or enforcement orders naming Courtyard, Inc. | CourtListener and web search, October 4, 2026; PACER and state dockets not comprehensively searched. |


## Verdict

Courtyard's tokenization model is comparatively straightforward: the NFT represents ownership of a specific vaulted collectible that can be traded without fees or redeemed. The Vending Machine is a different proposition. Every pack in the October 2026 catalog carried a stated expected value equal to 96% of its price, using Courtyard's own FMV estimates. In AltStreet's pack-balanced sample of 5,285 recent pulls, those estimates totaled 94.3% of pack spend and 78% of pulls came in below the pack price. A buyer who immediately sells back faces another layer: an unpublished card offer ratio based on Courtyard FMV, plus a 6% contractual buyback fee. The product is unusually transparent about its odds, but Courtyard itself supplies the valuations on which those odds and the buyback depend. The company discloses little else: no financials, no SEC filings, no vault attestation, and new vault submissions paused since April 2026.

**Best for**

- Collectors who want graded items stored, insured and tradable without fees.
- Buyers who treat packs as entertainment with a stated 4% expected-value gap.

**Look elsewhere if**

- You expect packs to make money.
- You need independent verification of custody or company finances.
- You plan to sell pulls back as a routine exit.

**Strengths**

- NFT terms that convey ownership of the item, with redemption worldwide.
- Free storage and insurance and a 0% marketplace fee.
- Published expected value and odds for every pack, and a public feed of pulls.
- No legal action located.

**Limitations**

- Stated expected value of 96% of the price on every pack; 78% of sampled pulls below the pack price.
- Buyback offer based on Courtyard's FMV at an unpublished card ratio, plus a 6% fee.
- Valuations set by the seller.
- No financial statements, no vault attestation, liability limited to gross negligence.
- Vaulting of new submissions paused since April 14, 2026.


## Who it fits

| Investor | Fit | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Collectors who want graded cards stored, insured and tradable without fees | well-suited |  |
| People buying packs expecting to make money | poor-fit |  |
| Investors seeking an alternative-asset return | poor-fit |  |


## Questions

**Is Courtyard legit?**

Yes, Courtyard is a real company with a real vault and marketplace. Courtyard, Inc., a Delaware company founded in 2021 by Nicolas le Jeune and Paulin Andurand and launched in 2022, runs courtyard.io and its apps. Its NFT terms convey ownership of each graded item, storage and insurance are free, trades carry no fee, and items can be redeemed worldwide. AltStreet located no lawsuit or enforcement action naming Courtyard, Inc. The caveats are that it publishes no financial statements or vault attestation, its packs are priced so its own expected value is 96% of the price, and the buyback offer is based on its own valuation, at an unpublished card ratio, with a 6% fee.

**Is Courtyard safe? What do you rely on when you buy there?**

Ownership is the strong part: under the NFT terms, whoever holds a Courtyard NFT owns the specific graded item it represents, and can redeem it, which burns the NFT and ships the card. What a holder relies on is Courtyard's custody. Items sit in Courtyard's own US vault (Brink's operated the vault until a transition Courtyard announced on February 27, 2025), Courtyard says it insures them at market value, and the Terms of Service limit its liability for loss or damage to gross negligence or willful misconduct. There is no third-party attestation that the vault holds every item represented by an NFT, and Courtyard publishes no financial statements. Vaulting of new collector submissions has been paused since April 14, 2026; cards already in the vault remain redeemable. The money risk for most users is the packs, not the vault: each pack's stated expected value is 96% of its price.

**Do you actually own the card on Courtyard?**

Yes, under Courtyard's terms: 'Each Courtyard NFT represents and conveys ownership of a certain individual Asset ... each Asset is owned by the then-current owner of the corresponding Courtyard NFT.' Courtyard stores the item for you, and you can redeem it, which burns the NFT and ships the card after identity verification and payment of shipping and tax.

**Are Courtyard packs worth it?**

On average, no, by Courtyard's own numbers: every pack's stated expected value is 96% of its price. In 5,285 recent pulls AltStreet sampled (up to the latest 50 per pack), 78% of items were valued below the price of the pack, and about 3% at twice the price or more. Packs carry a stated negative expected value to the buyer; they are not an investment.

**How much does Courtyard pay on a buyback?**

The offer is based on Courtyard's fair-market-value estimate for the item, is open for 7 days, and the NFT terms separately take a 6% Courtyard Fee on buyback consideration. Courtyard does not publish the card offer ratio; third parties describe roughly 90% of fair market value, without establishing whether that is before or after the fee, and Courtyard's watch documentation states 95%. If the 90% is before the fee, a buyer selling every sampled pull straight back would recover roughly 80 cents per dollar spent. You can instead list the item on the marketplace with no fee.

**Does Courtyard charge fees?**

No fee on peer-to-peer marketplace trades and none for storage or insurance. Packs are priced so Courtyard's stated expected value is 96% of the price, and accepted buybacks carry a 6% fee. Redemption costs shipping, sales tax or import duties, and a $2 per card handling fee in high-demand periods.

**Where are Courtyard's cards stored?**

In Courtyard's own vault in the United States since a 2025 transition (Brink's operated the vault before). Courtyard says items are insured at market value; its terms limit its liability for loss or damage to gross negligence or willful misconduct. Vaulting of new collector submissions has been paused since April 14, 2026.


## Evidence appendix

Platform website captured October 4, 2026.

Platform: courtyard.io crawl (154 pages, October 3, 2026), docs.courtyard.io crawl (94 pages) and 25 help-center articles (October 4). Packs: each pack's odds tab rendered in a browser, and Courtyard's pack catalog and recent-pulls feed read in-browser through the interfaces the site uses (107 packs; 5,285 pulls from August 31 to October 4, 2026, up to the latest 50 per pack). Outside: iOS app listing, Fortune (July 24, 2025), CryptoSlam (April 2026), Courtyard's February 27, 2025 vault announcement. Legal: EDGAR company and full-text search, CourtListener dockets and opinions, web search.

**Highlights**

- Pack catalog: '"salePriceUsd":500,"expectedValueUsd":480' (Pokémon Platinum Pack); the same 96% ratio on all 107 packs.
- Pokémon Platinum Pack odds tab: '$358-$430 49% $430-$500 30% $500-$1k 19% $1k-$2k 2% $2k-$8k 0.1% *Average item value is $480.'
- NFT terms: 6% Courtyard Fee only on buyback transfers.
- Help center: 'Vaulting is Currently Paused.'

**Primary source pages**

- NFT Terms and Asset Management Services Agreement (February 24, 2026): 'Each Courtyard NFT represents and conveys ownership of a certain individual Asset'; Courtyard Fee 'equal to 6% (six percent) of the total consideration paid for the corresponding Asset, but only in the event that such transfer results from acceptance of a Vending Machine Buyback Offer. No Courtyard Fee applies to standard marketplace transactions.'
- Terms of Service (February 24, 2026): Courtyard, Inc., Delaware; Asset Management Services by novation; Courtyard Fee defined as 'a percentage of the total purchase price paid'; insurance 'sufficient to cover the fair market value' with liability limited to 'gross negligence or willful misconduct'; JAMS arbitration.
- Courtyard pack catalog (captured October 4, 2026): 107 packs, salePriceUsd and expectedValueUsd, expected value 96% of price on every pack.
- Courtyard recent-pulls feed (captured October 4, 2026): 5,285 pulls with fmv_estimate_usd, burn status and times.
- Help center, Understanding Buyback Offers (March 23, 2026): offer 'based on the card's current Fair Market Value (FMV)' from 'a proprietary pricing algorithm'; 7-day window.
- Help center, Vault Your Cards (April 14, 2026): 'Vaulting is Currently Paused ... Any new shipments sent to the vault will be returned to sender.'
- Help center, A Guide to the Courtyard Marketplace (August 6, 2025): '0% marketplace fees on all peer-to-peer transactions'; mistaken trades are final.
- Help center, Courtyard Rewards FAQ: tiers 'determined by how much you spend on packs each season'.
- PokéBall Raffle official rules (effective May 15, 2026): sweepstakes with a free method of entry, 18+, 'void in New York and Florida'.
- Courtyard blog, Introducing the Courtyard Vault (February 27, 2025): own vault replacing Brink's; redemptions paused from March 6.


## Related

- Full review (HTML): https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/courtyard
- Every platform review: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews
- Methodology and scoring: https://altstreet.investments/platforms
- Category hub: https://altstreet.investments/categories/fine-art-collectibles

---

Source page: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/courtyard
Machine index: https://altstreet.investments/llms.txt
AltStreet reads what platforms, funds and issuers file with the SEC and what they tell investors, and publishes the difference. Figures are as filed or as captured on the date stated; nothing here is investment advice.
