---
title: "Masterworks Review 2026"
url: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/masterworks
kind: platform-review
updated: 2026-11-13
description: "Is Masterworks legit? Independent 2026 Masterworks review from SEC filings: 36 verified exits and their returns, the $500 minimum, the full fee stack including the ~11% sourcing fee, the end of PPEX trading, and the company's finances."
publisher: AltStreet (https://altstreet.investments)
license: Public factual pages may be read, quoted and cited with attribution and a link. Bulk redistribution is not permitted.
---

# Masterworks Review 2026

The largest fractional art platform by capital raised ($1.12B across 290 individual offerings plus 16 Vault entities) — SEC-qualified, $500 minimum, 36 EDGAR-verified exits at a 19.4% average IRR — but PPEX secondary trading ended October 19, 2026, replaced by a Masterworks bulletin board that does not match buy and sell orders.

AltStreet score: 53.6 (B-), scored October 16, 2026. Method: https://altstreet.investments/platforms

| Field | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Platform | Masterworks |
| What it is | Fractional Art Investment Platform (Regulation A, Tier 2) |
| Asset class | Blue-Chip Contemporary Art |
| Website | masterworks.com |
| Review first published | May 16, 2026 |
| Last updated | November 13, 2026 |
| AltStreet relationship | None: no affiliate, sponsorship or partnership |

## The short version

Masterworks is the dominant fractional art platform by capital raised, with a verified exit record and genuine retail access to blue-chip contemporary art — but its fee structure extracts roughly $123M from investors before a single painting appreciates, the administrator's liquidity position has deteriorated materially since 2022, and no new individual painting offerings have launched past MW289.

- **19.4% avg IRR** AltStreet has now harvested the liquidation waterfall Masterworks files as an exhibit to each sale-reporting Form 1-U: 33 documents from November 2022 to October 2026, every one parsed. Across them the multiple on invested capital runs 1.03 to 1.86 with a median of 1.268, and not one is below 1.0. Per-share distributions run $20.63 to $37.19 against the $20.00 offering price, median $25.43. The issuer-stated IRRs run 4.1% to 788.9% with a median of 16.4%; strip the five holdings sold within 90 days of their offering close and the same set reads 4.1% to 77.3% with a 15.3% median. Eight exits received cash in 2026: the seven with a stated IRR have an 11.5% median, and the eight a 1.284 median multiple. These are realized, not projected, and they still cover only a tenth of the 290-painting portfolio.
- **~$123M** Estimated sourcing fees extracted across $1.12B in capital raised. Masterworks purchases artwork at approximately 89% of the capital raised per series — the ~11% gap is the upfront sourcing fee paid before any appreciation. On $1.12B raised, that implies roughly $123M in sourcing fees alone, before annual dilution.
- **−80%** The Masterworks administrator's cash fell from $17.2M (FY2024) to $3.5M (FY2025). The company has operated at a loss since 2022 and in December 2025 entered a $7M revolving loan with the Lynn Family Trust — secured by substantially all platform assets.
- **16 Vaults** Masterworks' new Vault structure pools 30–50 paintings per entity instead of one per LLC. No new individual offerings have launched past MW289. The Vault pivot appears to be the primary go-forward vehicle — with different economics and governance than the individual series model investors originally underwrote.
- **AGD Legal** The five Vault entities with FY2025 annual reports and 130+ individual painting 1-Ks are audited by AGD Legal, S.C. — a law firm based in Cancun, Quintana Roo, Mexico, issuing clean opinions under U.S. GAAP and GAAS. AltStreet has not independently confirmed PCAOB registration status; investors should verify before relying on the audit for material allocation decisions.
- **Oct. 19, 2026** PPEX secondary trading of Masterworks shares ceased on this date, two months before the December 14 date in the July notice. The replacement is a Masterworks bulletin board that, in the filings' words, 'does not match buy and sell orders' with volume 'expected to be extremely low'; participation requires a custodial account at a bank or broker-dealer Masterworks designates.

Data note: Exit data from AltStreet's EDGAR pipeline: 22 Form 1-U verified exits plus 7 platform-disclosed exits. Financial data from FY2025 and FY2024 Form 1-K filings for Masterworks Vault 1–5 and individual painting series. Administrator balance sheet data from unaudited disclosures embedded in each Vault 1-K. All figures independently verified against EDGAR primary documents as of May 2026.


## Key figures

| Figure | What it is | Context |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 19.4% avg IRR | Average IRR across 36 EDGAR-verified or platform-disclosed exits | Median: 16.2% · Range: 4.1%–77.3% · 2026 exits: 11.5% median |
| ~$123M | Estimated sourcing fees extracted across $1.12B in capital raised | ~11% sourcing fee embedded in artwork acquisition — EDGAR-verified across 130 paintings |
| −80% | Administrator cash decline in FY2025 | $17.2M → $3.5M · Operating losses since 2022 · $7M Lynn Family Trust loan secured by platform assets |
| 10% | Fraction of portfolio that has exited | 36 of 290 paintings exited · 254 or so holdings with no fair value marks |
| AGD Legal | Auditor: PCAOB registration status not independently confirmed | AGD Legal, S.C. — Cancun, Quintana Roo, Mexico · Issues clean GAAP opinions · Verify PCAOB registration before relying on audit for material decisions |


## Verdict

Masterworks sells fractional shares in contemporary artworks through Regulation A offerings. Its exit record shows 36 exits at a 19.4% average IRR, taken from SEC filings or Masterworks' own disclosures. The structural concerns are real but not disqualifying for the right investor: the sourcing fee headwind (~11% upfront), 1.5%/yr management fee dilution, 20% carry at exit, and indefinite hold period are all disclosed in offering circulars. The more pressing question for new investors is platform trajectory: no individual offerings past MW289, the administrator's liquidity position under operational pressure, a $7M related-party loan secured by substantially all platform assets, and, since September 1, 2026, the founder and lender holding the CEO and CFO roles at every entity after Nigel Glenday stepped back to an advisory role. Whether the Vault structure delivers comparable investor outcomes to the individual series model is unproven.

**Best for**

- Long-horizon investors (5–10 years) allocating 2–5% of a diversified alternatives portfolio to art
- Investors who have read offering circulars and modeled net-of-fee, after-tax outcomes under conservative appreciation assumptions
- Art enthusiasts for whom non-financial utility (exposure to specific artists) justifies the complexity premium
- Accredited investors who can diversify across multiple works to reduce single-painting outcome dispersion

**Look elsewhere if**

- You need liquidity within 5 years — secondary market is thin and not guaranteed
- You haven't modeled the fee stack: 11% sourcing + 1.5%/yr dilution + 20% carry compounds materially over a 5-year hold
- You're relying on the platform's headline IRR without adjusting for the 88% of portfolio paintings that haven't exited
- You're considering the Vault structure without understanding how it differs from the individual series model

**Strengths**

- 36 EDGAR-verified or platform-disclosed exits, all profitable, 19.4% average IRR (16.2% median; 11.5% median across the seven in 2026)
- $500 minimum — genuine retail access to multi-million dollar artworks
- SEC-qualified under Regulation A; standardized offering circulars with fee and risk disclosure
- 900,000 registered investors — largest fractional art platform by participation
- $256.4M in EDGAR-confirmed Vault artwork at cost across 5 portfolios (FY2025)

**Limitations**

- Only about 12% of paintings (35/290) have exited — the rest of the portfolio is opaque, and 267 single-painting issuers stopped filing separately in June 2026
- Artwork carried at historical cost only — no fair value marks or independent appraisals in financial statements
- Administrator cash: $3.5M vs $17.2M one year prior; operating losses since 2022; $7M Lynn Family Trust loan
- Auditor AGD Legal, S.C. (Cancun, Mexico) issues clean GAAP opinions — PCAOB registration status not independently confirmed; verify before relying on audited statements for material decisions
- No new individual offerings past MW289; Vault pivot introduces unproven governance and economics
- PPEX secondary trading ended October 19, 2026; the replacement is a Masterworks-operated bulletin board that does not match orders, with volume the filings expect to be 'extremely low', costs borne by Masterworks for now, and a stated option for Masterworks to register as a broker-dealer and charge transaction fees
- Vaults 1 to 4 sold 239,160 Class A shares ($4,783,200, 35 series) after each offering statement passed its three-year limit between May 19 and August 23, 2026, stopped selling on October 9 when the lapse was found, and plan no rescission offer; the filings say Masterworks, LLC is anticipated to fund any Section 12(a)(1) claim


## Who it fits

| Investor | Fit | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| High-net-worth long-horizon investors building an alternatives sleeve | well-suited |  |
| Art enthusiasts seeking financial exposure to specific artists | well-suited |  |
| Accredited investors wanting alternative-asset diversification | neutral |  |
| Non-accredited retail investors seeking art exposure | neutral |  |
| Cost-conscious passive investors | poor-fit |  |
| Investors requiring predictable liquidity | poor-fit |  |


## Questions

**Is Masterworks legit?**

Structurally, yes. Masterworks is the largest fractional art platform by capital raised: $1.12 billion across 290 SEC-qualified Regulation A offerings plus five pooled Vault portfolios, with 900,000 registered investors and 36 verified profitable exits. This review is built from those SEC filings. Legitimate does not mean low-risk, and the filings surface material caveats the marketing does not: an ~11% upfront sourcing fee, 1.5%-per-year dilution and a 20% profit carry, indefinite hold periods, administrator cash that fell from $17.2M to $3.5M in FY2025 alongside a $7M related-party loan secured by substantially all platform assets, an audit signed by a non-U.S. firm whose PCAOB registration AltStreet has not confirmed, and secondary trading moved on October 19, 2026 from PPEX to a Masterworks bulletin board that does not match orders. Each is documented from the primary filings in the sections below.

**Is Masterworks going public? Can I buy Masterworks stock?**

Not as a listed stock. The parent company, Masterworks, is privately held, has no ticker and files no annual reports of its own; no filing AltStreet tracks states a plan to list it. What investors buy are shares in the individual painting issuers and the Vault entities, sold under Regulation A from a $500 minimum. Those shares do not trade on an exchange: trading on the PPEX ATS ended on October 19, 2026, and the replacement Masterworks bulletin board does not match buy and sell orders.

**What happened to Masterworks? Is it going bankrupt?**

No bankruptcy or insolvency filing appears in the Masterworks issuers' SEC filings through October 2026. What the filings do show is a business under pressure: the administrator's cash fell from $17.2 million to $3.5 million in FY2025 after operating losses every year since 2022; in December 2025 Masterworks took a $7 million revolving loan from the founder's family trust, secured by substantially all its assets including its equity interests in the investor entities; no individual painting series has been filed past MW289, with new offerings moving to pooled Vault entities; on September 1, 2026 founder Scott W. Lynn replaced Nigel Glenday as CEO and CFO of every Vault entity; and PPEX secondary trading ended on October 19, 2026.

**What happens to my investment if Masterworks shuts down?**

Each painting is owned by its issuer entity, not by Masterworks, and Masterworks' creditors have no direct claim on the artwork. But Masterworks runs everything around it: an affiliate is the administrator (there is no independent administrator), Masterworks arranges storage and insurance, decides when to sell, and holds Class B shares in each issuer. Its $7 million loan from the founder's family trust is secured by those equity interests in the issuing entities, so on a default the lender's claim would run to Masterworks' interests in them. The offering documents do not describe an independent party ready to take over administration, so a wind-down would likely mean delays before paintings were sold and proceeds distributed.

**Who is the CEO of Masterworks?**

Founder Scott W. Lynn. He is CEO of the parent and of the administrator, and since September 1, 2026 he has also been CEO, CFO and a manager of every Vault entity, after Nigel Glenday resigned those posts and became a part-time senior adviser. No separate CFO had been named in the filings at AltStreet's last check.

**How long does Masterworks hold a painting before selling?**

There is no set term: hold periods are indefinite by contract, and Masterworks decides when to sell. Across the 36 exits with a published hold, the average was 17.8 months, but those are the paintings Masterworks chose to sell; roughly 255 of the 290 individual paintings were still held, accruing the 1.5% annual management fee as share dilution. Plan for a hold of several years with no fixed end.

**Masterworks vs Rally vs Vinovest: how do they compare?**

All three sell fractional shares of collectible assets. Masterworks sells blue-chip paintings from $500 with 36 verified exits, an embedded ~11% sourcing fee, 1.5% annual dilution and a 20% carry. Rally (RSE) sells collectibles such as cars, cards and memorabilia from $50, with 111 exits at a 6.8% median IRR, and its auditor has flagged substantial doubt about the company and every listed series in six of its last seven annual reports. Vinovest holds wine and whiskey, was sold to StartEngine, and has faced customer-reported delays in shipments and liquidations. AltStreet reviews each one, and compares Masterworks and Rally head to head.

**What is the minimum investment on Masterworks?**

$500, per the platform's current disclosure; shares are priced at $20 with a 25-share minimum. Older reviews still circulate $15,000 or $5,000 minimums from earlier policies, which is why the figure looks inconsistent across the internet. Some investors report being offered lower minimums during onboarding; verify the current policy on the offering you are considering. The minimum buys access, not favorable economics: every dollar enters roughly 11% behind the artwork's purchase price after the embedded sourcing fee.

**What are Masterworks' average returns?**

On realized sales: 36 verified exits from Form 1-U sale-consummation reports and Form 1-K disclosures with a 19.4% average IRR, a 16.2% median, a range of 4.1% to 77.3%, and a 17.8-month average hold; all profitable, and these are gross IRRs before the platform's 20% carry, annual dilution, and collectibles-rate tax. The essential caveat: those exits cover roughly 12% of the 290-painting portfolio. The other 255 or so paintings are still held, accruing 1.5%-per-year management-fee dilution on indefinite hold periods, with no fair-value marks published in the financials. A track record built only from the paintings the platform chose to sell is a real record, but it is not the expected return on a new investment. Set against a stock index fund, the right comparison is net: after the 20% carry, the dilution and the 28% federal collectibles rate on long-term gains, against 20% for stocks.

**Is Masterworks worth it?**

It depends entirely on whether the art appreciates enough to clear the fee stack. An investor starts ~11% behind the purchase price (sourcing fee), loses ~1.5% per year to management-fee share dilution, and gives up 20% of any profit at exit, with no performance hurdle; hedge-fund economics on an asset with no cash flow and an indefinite, platform-controlled exit date. The verified exits show it can work: 36 sales, all profitable, 19.4% average gross IRR, though the seven in 2026 came in at an 11.5% median. Whether it works for a given painting requires the appreciation math, which is why this page includes a fee calculator. Investors wanting cash yield, a defined hold, or exit control should look elsewhere; the product is a long-hold appreciation bet with genuine access innovation.

**How does Masterworks make money?**

Three ways, all documented in the filings. First, the sourcing spread: Masterworks buys each artwork at roughly 89% of what investors put in; the ~11% difference, roughly $123M implied across $1.12B raised, is collected upfront. Second, a 1.5%-per-year management fee taken as SPC Preferred shares that dilute investors (~$0.30 per $20 share per year). Third, a 20% share of appreciation at exit through its Class B shares, with no hurdle rate. Advised clients can also pay up to 0.50% per year to the affiliated SEC-registered RIA, Masterworks Advisers, LLC. Most reviews list only the 1.5% and the 20%; the sourcing fee is visible only by comparing capital raised to the artwork's purchase price in the SEC filings, which is how AltStreet extracted it across 130 paintings.

**What is Masterworks' actual track record?**

AltStreet verified 36 exits from EDGAR Form 1-U sale-consummation reports and Form 1-K disclosures through November 13, 2026. Average IRR: 19.4%. Median IRR: 16.2%. Range: 4.1% (Andy Warhol MW078) to 77.3% (Cecily Brown MW151). Average hold across the 36, using the filed IRR period where the issuer states one: 21.7 months. All 36 exits were profitable. These are gross IRRs before the platform's 20% carry, annual dilution, and collectibles tax. Nine exits returned below 10% IRR, and the seven consummated in 2026 carry an 11.5% median.

**What is the Masterworks sourcing fee?**

Masterworks does not disclose an explicit sourcing fee line item. AltStreet's EDGAR analysis of 130 individual painting balance sheets found that artwork at cost averages 89.1% of capital raised per offering; implying an embedded ~11% sourcing fee. On a $10,000 investment, approximately $8,900 goes to artwork and $1,100 to platform costs before any appreciation.

**What happened to Masterworks' administrator cash?**

The Masterworks administrator's cash fell from $17.2M (FY2024) to $3.5M (FY2025) per unaudited balance sheet disclosures embedded in the Vault 1-K filings. Masterworks has generated operating losses since 2022. In December 2025, the company entered a $7M revolving loan with the Lynn Family Trust 001 (the founder's family trust), secured by substantially all Masterworks assets including equity interests in investor entities.

**Who audits Masterworks?**

The five Vault entities with FY2025 annual reports and 130+ individual painting annual reports are audited by AGD Legal, S.C.; a law firm based in Cancun, Quintana Roo, Mexico. The firm issues clean audit opinions under U.S. GAAP and GAAS. The Vault 1 audit opinion was signed April 3, 2026; Vault 2 on April 8, 2026. AltStreet has not independently confirmed AGD Legal's PCAOB registration status. Investors who plan to rely on audited financial statements for material allocation decisions should verify the firm's PCAOB registration and inspection history directly before committing capital.

**What is the Masterworks Vault structure?**

Masterworks Vault entities are Regulation A issuers each holding 30 to 50 paintings in a pooled portfolio; the first five were filed in 2024 and 16 Vault entities filed reports on September 2, 2026. EDGAR-confirmed artwork at cost: Vault 1 $53.3M, Vault 2 $54.3M, Vault 3 $45.2M, Vault 4 $55.1M, Vault 5 $48.6M (FY2025). No new individual painting series have been filed past MW289. Two Vault exits occurred in November 2025: Vault 2 Cecily Brown ($745,000, $24.68/share) and Vault 5 Joan Mitchell ($1,115,000, $23.40/share). The Vault structure differs from individual series; investors own a pooled portfolio, not a specific painting.

**What is Masterworks' fee structure?**

Three primary fee components: (1) Sourcing fee; approximately 11% embedded in artwork acquisition price, EDGAR-verified; (2) Management fee; 1.5% per annum via SPC Preferred shares that convert to Class A at 1:1, creating ongoing shareholder dilution (~$0.30/share/year at $20/share); (3) Carried interest; 20% of profit at exit via Class B shares held by Masterworks. No performance hurdle is disclosed. Additional costs: storage, insurance, and offering expenses per artwork.

**How is Masterworks taxed?**

Art gains are treated as collectibles under U.S. federal tax law. Long-term gains: maximum 28% federal rate (vs. 20% for equities). Short-term gains: ordinary income rates. Each painting generates a separate K-1 annually; even in non-exit years, you may have phantom income from management fee accruals. Multiple positions multiply K-1 complexity and professional preparation costs. Consult a tax professional; model after-tax outcomes before investing.

**Can I sell my Masterworks shares before the artwork is sold?**

Not through PPEX: trading of the shares on North Capital's PPEX ATS ceased on October 19, 2026 (Forms 1-U of October 20, 2026). Shares that had been eligible there became eligible to post on the Masterworks bulletin board, which the filings say does not match buy and sell orders, so transaction volume is expected to be extremely low. Masterworks facilitates sales of a series from the three-month anniversary of its offering being fully subscribed; a holder needs a cash custodial account at a bank or broker-dealer Masterworks designates; affiliates and holders of more than 10% of a series are excluded, and some investor categories may be barred for regulatory reasons. Masterworks pays the board's costs for now, may pass third-party expenses to investors, and may register as a broker-dealer to charge transaction fees. The filings give no assurance that any share can be sold or that a posted price reflects fair value, and tell holders to be prepared to hold for an extended and indefinite period.

**What will replace PPEX for Masterworks secondary trading?**

The Masterworks bulletin board, since October 19, 2026. The five Vault entities' Forms 1-U of October 20, 2026 report that PPEX ATS trading ceased that day, about eight weeks before the December 14 date in the July notice, and that the shares became eligible to transact on a bulletin board Masterworks operates. In the filings' words it 'does not match buy and sell orders and, accordingly, transaction volume is expected to be extremely low.' Sales of a series are facilitated from the three-month anniversary of its offering being fully subscribed, a holder needs a cash custodial account at a bank or broker-dealer Masterworks designates, Masterworks pays the costs for now but may pass third-party expenses on and may register as a broker-dealer to charge transaction fees, and the filings give no assurance the board will provide an effective means of selling or that any price on it reflects fair value.

**Is Masterworks still offering new investments?**

No new individual painting series have been filed past MW289. New offerings come through the Vault entities, which pool many paintings in each issuer. Whether new Vault entities will be launched is not publicly disclosed. Investors considering Masterworks today are investing in the Vault structure, not the individual series model that generated the historical exit record.

**How does the MW002 Monet exit explain the fee structure?**

The Monet exit (MW002) achieved a headline 9.2% IRR in EDGAR filings, but Masterworks waived all carried interest to reach that figure. Without the carry waiver, investor IRR would have been approximately 6.3%. The carry waiver is disclosed in the Masterworks 002, LLC Form 1-U exit reporting filing (CIK 0001768469) and the corresponding final Form 1-K. This is one of only two exits where AltStreet identified material adjustments to the headline figure; and it is the only exit where a carry waiver was required to achieve the reported number. Investors should verify the precise carry waiver mechanics directly from the EDGAR filing.


## Update history

**November 13, 2026: Series 402 approves a $2,450,000 net sale of its Yoshitomo Nara 'Untitled' (2002), 1.75x the 2023 purchase price; not closed, buyer has up to 30 days to pay**

A Form 1-U filed November 12, 2026 by Masterworks Vault 2 (accession 0001493152-26-051107) reports that on November 10 Masterworks Gallery, as agent for Series 402 and the 402 Segregated Portfolio of Masterworks Cayman, approved an unaffiliated gallery's sale of the series' only artwork to an undisclosed buyer for $2,450,000 net of fees and commissions. The invoice in Exhibit 6.1 identifies the work as Nara's Untitled, 2002, acrylic on cotton mounted on fiberglass, 94.5 x 94.5 x 12.7 cm. Masterworks bought it for $1,400,000 on October 13, 2023 and Series 402 raised $1,554,000 (77,700 shares at $20), of which $154,000 (9.91%) was the Expense Allocation Payment. The sale had not closed and the series had received nothing at the report date.

**October 28, 2026: Series 391's Peyton sale closes: $1,000,000 net received October 23, about $25.43 a share to Class A holders, 1.271x and 11.6% on Masterworks' definition**

A Form 1-U filed October 26, 2026 by Masterworks Vault 4 (accession 0001493152-26-048580) reports payment in full of the $1,000,000 net sale price on October 23 and a distribution of approximately $25.43 per Class A share. Exhibit 99.1 sets out the waterfall: $1,000,000 gross proceeds plus $120 of cash, less $100 of Class B capital and a $50,668 Class B profit share, $949,352 distributable across 37,334 Class A shares (1,234 of them fee shares); multiple 1.271x on the $20 issue price; net annualized return 11.6% from the August 15, 2024 final offering close to cash receipt. This exit is now in the 36-exit record below.

**October 26, 2026: Two 1995 Yoshitomo Nara paintings, held by series in two different Vaults, consigned to one gallery through November 16**

Forms 1-U filed October 26, 2026 by Masterworks Vault 1 (accession 0001493152-26-048544) and Masterworks Vault 19 (accession 0001493152-26-048551) report that Series 417 ('Dog in the Night', 1995, 60 x 45 cm) and Series 252 ('Dog in Boy', 1995, 63.5 x 48.3 cm) consigned their only artworks to the same unaffiliated gallery under one Consignment Agreement dated October 16, exclusive through November 16, 2026. Each work has its own undisclosed minimum net amount and neither sale depends on the other. If a work sells, its series pays its costs, distributes the rest and dissolves; the filings say such consignments 'very often' do not result in a sale. No score change: a consignment is not a realized outcome.

**October 23, 2026: Vault 3 files a replacement offering statement for 157,113 unsold shares across seven series; its October 5 amendment had been filed to the expired statement; all sixteen Vault semiannual reports confirmed on record**

On October 20, 2026 Masterworks Vault 3, LLC filed a new Form 1-A (accession 0001493152-26-047712) to replace its prior offering statement (File No. 024-12289, qualified July 28, 2023), stating that the three-year limit under Rule 251(d)(3)(i)(F) passed on July 28, 2026 with no new statement on file, that the lapse was discovered on October 9, and that the 157,113 Class A shares of seven series that remained unsold are now covered by the new statement and will not be offered until it is qualified. The filing carries a risk factor headed with the rescission rights of purchasers who bought after the expiration. Fifteen days earlier, on October 5, the same entity had filed a post-qualification amendment adding series to the statement that had already expired. Separately, the June 30, 2026 semiannual balance sheets of all sixteen Vaults are confirmed in AltStreet's performance rows after a re-run of the extractor, which had failed on them under its earlier size cap. The score is unchanged: the October 15 entry already carries the lapse as a prior compliance issue, and the replacement filing is the step those 1-Us said Vault 3 intended to take.

**October 21, 2026: Series 391 approves a $1,000,000 net sale of its Elizabeth Peyton painting; the sale had not closed**

A Form 1-U filed October 21, 2026 by Masterworks Vault 4 (accession 0001493152-26-047869) reports that on October 15 Series 391 approved an unaffiliated gallery's sale of its sole artwork, Elizabeth Peyton's 'Piotr Uklanski' (1996, oil on board), to an undisclosed buyer for $1,000,000 net of fees and commissions. At the report date the sale had not closed and no money had been received; the consignee sells in its own name, the Company cannot enforce the sale and the consignee is not liable if the buyer does not pay. Once paid, the series settles liabilities, costs and the profit share and distributes the rest, then dissolves.

**October 21, 2026: PPEX trading ended October 19, two months early; the Masterworks bulletin board replaces it**

On October 20, 2026 Masterworks Vault 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 each filed a Form 1-U reporting that trading of their Class A shares on North Capital's PPEX ATS ceased on October 19, 2026, ahead of the December 14 date in the July 8 notice, and that the shares became eligible to transact on a Masterworks bulletin board. AltStreet read the five filings (identical Item 9 text) and updated the liquidity section, the risk list, the timeline, the exit options and the watch list. The score is unchanged: the review already treated secondary liquidity as unavailable.

**October 15, 2026: Four Vaults sold $4,783,200 of Class A shares after their offering statements expired; no rescission offers planned; composite 5.7 to 5.36**

On October 15, 2026 Masterworks Vault 1, 2, 3 and 4 each filed a Form 1-U reporting that its Regulation A offering statement had passed the three-year limit (May 19, June 9, July 28 and August 23, 2026), that sales continued afterward through October 8, and that the offerings stopped on October 9 when the lapse was discovered. AltStreet read the four filings and the June 30, 2026 semiannual reports, loaded four offering_terminated signals, published a news report, and folded the finding into the review as a new risk, a verdict limitation, a data insight and two watch-list items. The analyst inputs now carry a prior compliance issue and governance moved from 4 to 3; the composite fell from 5.7 to 5.36 (53.6 of 100, B-).

**September 23, 2026: The filed waterfall behind all 33 exits: the 20% carry is charged at exactly 20.0% of the gain on 32 of them, and at $1 on the $8,000,000 Monet**

Masterworks files a liquidation waterfall as an exhibit to the Form 1-U that reports each sale, and it is the only place the platform states what reached Class A holders after its own cut. AltStreet harvested every one on EDGAR, 33 documents from November 2022 to October 2026, and all 33 parsed. The set holds $97,286,877 of gross proceeds against $92,508,995 distributable to Class A, 95.1% of gross, with the sponsor's Class B profit share totaling $4,756,011, or 4.89% of gross. Tested against the 20% performance fee this review already records, the filed carry is exactly 20.0% of the gain over invested capital on 32 of the 33 exits. The exception is Masterworks 002, the Claude Monet sold for $8,000,000 in 2022: 20% of its $1,127,931 gain would have been $225,586, and the filed Class B profit share is $1. The waterfalls also expose what the headline annualized figures are built on, because the issuer computes its IRR period from the final offering close rather than from acquisition. Five holdings were sold within 90 days of that close, and four of them report annualized returns between 142.8% and 788.9% on multiples of 1.15 to 1.20. The fifth and most recent, Series 507 in March 2026 at 17 days and 1.229x, omits the IRR altogether and states a 22.9% total net return instead. Management-fee shares tell the same story from the other side: 83 of 23,933 shares on the 76-day holding, 492 of 14,108 on the 930-day one. Every figure is now loaded to the exit records and to the new exit_waterfalls table, and the line items render in the terminal.

**September 17, 2026: Six more exits verified and the record re-cut: 35 exits at a 16.4% median, but the five consummated in 2026 came in at 9.6%; 267 single-painting issuers stopped reporting separately in June**

AltStreet rebuilt the exit record from every Masterworks Form 1-U reporting Item 1, the filing in which a sale consummation, its price, the distribution per Class A share and the issuer's own net annualized return are reported. One hundred and thirteen such filings since 2022 yielded six consummated sales this review did not hold: David Hockney (MW067, November 2025, 6.0%), Matthew Wong (MW237, March 2026, 9.0%), Helen Frankenthaler (Vault 18, June 2026, 9.6%), Cecily Brown (Vault 4, June 2026, 17.8%), a second Helen Frankenthaler (Vault 18, June 2026, 11.5%) and Gerhard Richter (Vault 13, September 2026, 6.6%). The count moves from 29 to 35, the average IRR from 21.6 to 19.6 percent and the median from 17.0 to 16.4 percent. The finding that matters is recency rather than the count: five of the six additions fall below the old median, and the five exits consummated in 2026 carry a 9.6 percent median and a 10.9 percent average. Separately, Masterworks rolled its standalone single-painting LLCs into Delaware series structures on or around May 31, 2026, and on June 29 exactly 267 of those issuers filed Form 1-Z suspending Regulation A reporting, each certifying approximately zero holders of record.

**September 16, 2026: Signal sweep since July 17: every flagged filing was already in the review; Vault 1's annual reports exceed the extractor's size cap**

AltStreet triaged the ten signals its monitoring attached to Masterworks between July 17 and September 11, 2026. All of them are covered by this review as updated on September 3 and 7: the July 8 Form 1-U terminating the PPEX ATS agreements effective on or about December 14, 2026; the September 2 filings in which Nigel Glenday resigned as CEO, CFO and manager of every Vault entity and Scott W. Lynn took every post; the August 17 Form D/A on Masterworks Management Fee Collection, LLC ($4,831,500 to $17,523,480 sold, 94 to 205 investors); and the 253G2 supplements of July 17 and September 2. Two further 1-Us, on June 16 and July 17, disclosed estimated NAV per share for 40 series as of March 31, 2026 and 43 series as of June 30, 2026; AltStreet's NAV table has not ingested them, and the Vault 1 annual reports for fiscal 2024 and 2025 are over the statement extractor's document size cap, so the data layer's statements for Vault 1 stop at fiscal 2023. Those are recorded here as data-layer limits, not review gaps. Scores are unchanged.

**September 7, 2026: Search pass: title leads with the legitimacy question; H1 carries the year**

Search Console for the 28 days to September 6 shows the review earning 2,317 impressions at an average position of 4.2 with no clicks. The competing results at positions 1 to 3 all lead with 'Is Masterworks legit?'; this page's title led with 'what SEC filings show'. The title now opens with the legitimacy question and names the two numbers the review proves (29 verified exits, the sourcing fee), the H1 is 'Masterworks Review 2026', and a keyword set is added. No figure in the review changed.

**September 3, 2026: Founder Scott Lynn replaces Nigel Glenday as CEO and CFO of every Vault entity**

Twenty-one SEC filings dated September 2, 2026 across sixteen Masterworks Vault entities (Vault 1 through 5 and 10 through 20) disclose that Nigel Glenday resigned as Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer and a manager of each entity, and from all officer, manager and director positions at other Masterworks affiliates, effective 11:59 p.m. Eastern on September 1, 2026 (Vault 1 Form 1-U, accession 0001493152-26-041095). Founder Scott W. Lynn, CEO of the parent since February 2018, was appointed to every vacated role simultaneously. The filings state the resignation was not the result of any disagreement, that Glenday will continue in a part-time senior advisory capacity, and that no arrangement with any other person lies behind Lynn's appointment. Glenday had been CFO of the parent since April 2019 and had signed the Vault annual reports as principal executive, financial and accounting officer as recently as April 3, 2026. The change sits in the sequence this review already documents without any filing linking the parts: operating losses and negative operating cash flow since 2022, Administrator cash of $3.5M at year-end 2025 against $17.2M a year earlier, a $7M revolving facility from the founder's family trust secured by substantially all platform assets, and PPEX secondary trading scheduled to end on or about December 14, 2026 with no replacement confirmed. The person now certifying each entity's financial statements is the platform's founder, controlling owner and lender of record. AltStreet's news desk covered the filings at /news/masterworks-nigel-glenday-resigns-scott-lynn-ceo-2026-2026-09-02.


## Evidence appendix

Platform website captured July 20, 2026.

Review synthesized from AltStreet's EDGAR data pipeline covering 290 individual Masterworks painting offerings and 16 Vault entities (five with FY2025 annual reports). Exit data: 22 Form 1-U verified exits plus 7 platform-disclosed exits. Artwork at cost data: 130 individual paintings with verifiable 1-K balance sheets plus 5 Vault consolidated balance sheets. Administrator financial data: unaudited balance sheet disclosures embedded in all five Vault 1-Ks (FY2024 and FY2025). All figures independently verified against EDGAR primary documents. Secondary sources: masterworks.com platform disclosures and ARTnews investigative reporting (2023, historical context only).

**Highlights**

- Administrator cash: $3,507,005 (FY2025) vs $17,190,905 (FY2024) — 80% decline in one year per unaudited balance sheet embedded in all five Vault 1-Ks
- Lynn Family Trust 001 revolving loan: $7M outstanding at December 31, 2025, secured by substantially all Masterworks assets including equity interests in issuing entities — per Vault 1-K liquidity disclosures
- Vault 1 FY2025: artwork at cost $53,290,000, total assets $54,242,375, net loss $(666,246), members' equity $53,192,480 — AGD Legal, S.C. audit opinion dated April 3, 2026
- Vault 2 FY2025: artwork at cost $54,262,000, total assets $55,184,207, net loss $(628,180), members' equity $54,211,860 — AGD Legal, S.C. audit opinion dated April 8, 2026
- Vault 3 FY2025: artwork at cost $45,192,000, total assets $45,549,610, net loss $(544,008), members' equity $42,567,350
- Vault 4 FY2025: artwork at cost $55,050,500, total assets $56,021,173, net loss $(747,101), members' equity $54,845,263
- Vault 5 FY2025: artwork at cost $48,567,000, total assets $48,680,570, net loss $(151,322), members' equity $38,892,138
- Vault 5 Series 443 (Joan Mitchell) sold November 7, 2025 for $1,115,000 — $23.40/share distribution to Class A shareholders per Vault 5 1-K Item 6
- Vault 2 Series 307 (Cecily Brown) sold November 24, 2025 for $745,000 — $24.68/share distribution to Class A shareholders per Vault 2 1-K Item 6
- EDGAR-verified sourcing fee: across 130 individual painting 1-Ks with balance sheet data, artwork at cost averages 89.1% of capital raised — implying ~11% sourcing fee embedded in acquisition price
- MW002 Claude Monet: Masterworks waived all carried interest to achieve headline 9.2% IRR — disclosed in Masterworks 002, LLC Form 1-U exit reporting (CIK 0001768469) and corresponding final 1-K; true investor IRR without waiver approximately 6.3%. AltStreet investors should verify the precise carry waiver mechanics directly from the EDGAR filing.
- Board structure: 3 members (CEO/CFO, General Counsel, one Independent Manager); removal requires 2/3 supermajority plus cause — per Vault offering circulars
- Class B lockup: 1 year only — Masterworks may sell its 20% carry position after one year while Class A investors hold indefinitely — per offering circular disclosures
- Auditor: AGD Legal, S.C., Cancun, Quintana Roo — a Mexican law firm; PCAOB registration status not independently confirmed by AltStreet — per audit opinion letterhead on all Vault 1-Ks
- Net loss per Class A share (Vault entities FY2025): consistently approximately $(0.30)/share across all series — matching the 1.5%/yr × $20/share = $0.30/share annual dilution structure
- PPEX termination: written notice delivered to North Capital June 17, 2026; agreements terminate on or about December 14, 2026; no replacement provider, mechanism, or launch date confirmed — per materially identical July 8 Form 1-U filings for Vault 1, Vault 5, Vault 12, and Vault 15
- PPEX trading ceased October 19, 2026 and shares became eligible on the Masterworks bulletin board (does not match orders; custodial account required; Masterworks pays costs for now) per the identical Forms 1-U of October 20, 2026 for Vault 1 to 5

**Primary source pages**

- SEC EDGAR: Masterworks Vault 1, LLC Form 1-K FY2025 (CIK 0001956601, filed April 2026)
- SEC EDGAR: Masterworks Vault 2, LLC Form 1-K FY2025 (CIK 0001979634, filed April 2026)
- SEC EDGAR: Masterworks Vault 3, LLC Form 1-K FY2025 (CIK 0001983146)
- SEC EDGAR: Masterworks Vault 4, LLC Form 1-K FY2025 (CIK 0001989522)
- SEC EDGAR: Masterworks Vault 5, LLC Form 1-K FY2025 (CIK 0001999710)
- SEC EDGAR: Individual painting series 1-K filings (130 verified with balance sheet data, MW001–MW289+)
- SEC EDGAR: Form 1-U current reports (22 verified exit filings plus July 8, 2026 PPEX termination disclosures for Vault 1, Vault 5, Vault 12, and Vault 15)
- masterworks.com (platform disclosures, May 2026)
- ARTnews (2023 investigative reporting — historical operational context only)


## Related

- Full review (HTML): https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/masterworks
- Every platform review: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews
- Methodology and scoring: https://altstreet.investments/platforms
- Category hub: https://altstreet.investments/categories/fine-art-collectibles

---

Source page: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/masterworks
Machine index: https://altstreet.investments/llms.txt
AltStreet reads what platforms, funds and issuers file with the SEC and what they tell investors, and publishes the difference. Figures are as filed or as captured on the date stated; nothing here is investment advice.
