---
title: "NCX Review"
url: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/ncx
kind: platform-review
updated: 2026-08-13
description: "NCX review: the forest carbon program ended in 2022 to 2023 after Verra declined its tonne-year method. What NCX does now, what happened to the credits."
publisher: AltStreet (https://altstreet.investments)
license: Public factual pages may be read, quoted and cited with attribution and a link. Bulk redistribution is not permitted.
---

# NCX Review

NCX no longer sells carbon credits — and AltStreet's earlier coverage, which described its harvest-deferral program in the present tense, was out of date. The company (Natural Capital Exchange, Inc., founded 2010 as SilviaTerra) suspended its one-year forest carbon cycles in November 2022, exited carbon project development entirely by October 2023 after Verra declined its tonne-year methodology, and cut roughly three-quarters of its staff across three rounds. What operates at ncx.com in 2026 is a landowner software and content business: LandBook, a free property-documentation tool, and Sylvia, an AI forest-guide assistant launched March 2026. This review now serves two purposes: documenting what NCX is today, and preserving the record of one of the voluntary carbon market's most instructive failures — a ~$74 million-funded credit developer whose accounting methodology did not survive registry scrutiny.

AltStreet score: 29.2 (D), scored August 14, 2026. Method: https://altstreet.investments/platforms

| Field | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Platform | NCX |
| What it is | Landowner Software & Content Platform (former forest carbon program, discontinued 2022-2023) |
| Asset class | Carbon & Climate |
| Website | ncx.com |
| Review first published | December 27, 2025 |
| Last updated | August 13, 2026 |
| AltStreet relationship | None: no affiliate, sponsorship or partnership |

## The short version

NCX exited the carbon business in 2022-2023 after its tonne-year methodology failed registry scrutiny; the 2026 company is a free landowner-software business. The numbers below are the record of the exit — the most useful thing NCX now offers the market.

- **Nov 2022 → Oct 2023** The wind-down: one-year harvest-deferral cycles suspended and ~40% of staff cut (November 2022); further layoffs (May 2023); carbon project development ended entirely with another ~40% cut (October 2023). Verra had declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022 and put NCX's methodology certification on indefinite hold.
- **4x-100x** CarbonPlan's January 2022 finding: NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated the tonnage needed for permanence-equivalence by ~4x (100-year basis) to ~100x (1,000-year basis). The methodology critique that preceded — and predicted — the registry outcome.
- **~$74.4M** Total venture funding (third-party tallies; approximate) — of which $72.3M is EDGAR-documented across three Form Ds under CIK 1834847: $4.4M (December 2020, 20 investors), $17.9M of a $20M offering (April 2021, 24 investors), and the $50.0M Series B ($49,999,936 fully sold to 10 investors, first sale February 18, 2022) led by Energize Ventures with J.P. Morgan, Intercontinental Exchange, Microsoft, Union Square Ventures, and TIME Ventures — closed roughly eight months before the program was suspended. Marc Benioff appears among the related persons on the 2021 and 2022 filings; no filing has followed.
- **$8-12 / credit** Approximate landowner pricing via NCX's blind auction (per Mississippi State Extension). Buyers included Microsoft, South Pole, Shell, and Cargill; total credits issued and sold were never disclosed, and none were registry-validated. NCX states it paid 'millions of dollars to thousands of American landowners' (2024); the current site's '$20M+ payments to landowners' figure spans timber, carbon, and conservation combined (both company-stated).
- **0 filed actions** AltStreet's August 2026 scan found no lawsuits, regulatory actions, or landowner litigation naming NCX — a web scan, not a docket search. Contracts self-expired; documented landowner harm is confusion (re-enrollment, double-counting), not non-payment.

Data note: Sources: ncx.com and blog captures (August 2026), NCX co-founder wind-down statements, CarbonPlan (January 2022), Verra's June 2022 tonne-year decision coverage, Carbon Market Watch consultation response, Mississippi State University Extension program documentation, Businesswire/CNBC/Crunchbase News funding coverage, Quantum Commodity Intelligence layoff reporting. Funding totals are third-party aggregates and approximate; company-stated figures attributed as such.


## Key figures

| Figure | What it is | Context |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Nov 2022 → Oct 2023 | The carbon program's wind-down window | Harvest-deferral cycles suspended and ~40% of staff cut (November 2022), further layoffs (May 2023), carbon project development ended entirely (October 2023) — after Verra declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022 |
| 4x-100x | How far CarbonPlan found NCX's permanence math understated required tonnage | The January 2022 analysis: NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated permanence-equivalent tonnage by ~4x on a 100-year basis to ~100x on a 1,000-year basis — the critique that preceded, and predicted, the registry outcome |
| ~$74.4M | Venture funding raised before the exit — EDGAR-documented under a former name | Three Form Ds filed as SilviaTerra Inc. (CIK 1834847): $4.4M (Dec 2020), $17.9M of $20.0M (Apr 2021), $50.0M Series B (Mar 2022). Nothing filed since — though a missing notice filing alone would not rule out exempt, debt, or insider financing |
| 0 filed actions | AltStreet's August 2026 scan found no lawsuits or regulatory actions naming NCX | A web scan, not a docket search. Contracts self-expired; the documented landowner harm is confusion (re-enrollment eligibility, double-counting concerns), not non-payment |


## Verdict

There is no longer a carbon product to evaluate, so the verdict splits in two. As a current service: NCX's free landowner tools (LandBook, Sylvia) are low-stakes — no money changes hands, the visible risk is data-sharing with an undisclosed business model behind free software. As a record: NCX is the cleanest available case study in methodology-acceptance risk — well-funded, well-intentioned, analytically sophisticated, and unwound within twenty months of a $50M round because a registry declined its accounting. The company's conduct through the failure was comparatively orderly: short contracts self-expired, no litigation followed, and its founders published explanations rather than disappearing. AltStreet's coverage previously described the carbon program in the present tense; that was wrong, and this rebuild corrects it.

**Best for**

- Forest landowners wanting free property-documentation and forestry-guidance tools, with eyes open about the undisclosed model behind them
- Carbon-market analysts and buyers studying methodology-acceptance risk before purchasing novel-methodology credits
- Sustainability teams assessing historical claims that relied on pre-2023 NCX credits

**Look elsewhere if**

- You are looking to sell carbon from your land — NCX no longer offers that, and hasn't since 2022-2023
- You are looking to buy carbon credits — there is nothing to buy here
- You want investment exposure of any kind — NCX never offered any, and offers none now

**Strengths**

- The wind-down record: one-year contracts self-expired, no verified non-payment disputes, no litigation or regulatory action found — an orderly failure by voluntary-carbon standards
- Founder transparency: public explanations of the program's end, including a 2026 admission that carbon markets 'failed' forest landowners
- Current tools are free — the downside for a landowner trying LandBook is time and data, not money

**Limitations**

- The prior carbon model failed on its core methodological premise: the tonne-year approach was never registry-approved and independent analysis found it overstated equivalence by 4x-100x
- Credits already sold rest on that unapproved accounting — a live problem for any buyer who reported against them
- The current business model is undisclosed: free tools, unknown monetization, no published financials, leadership beyond the co-founders unverified
- No public disclosure of total credits issued/sold or the full disposition of buyer claims after the program ended


## What this means for your decision.

| Topic | Finding |
| --- | --- |
|  | NCX does not sell carbon credits — anything suggesting otherwise is out of date |
|  | The carbon program's failure was methodological, not fraudulent — and the record shows both halves |
|  | The wind-down was orderly for landowners on paper — one-year contracts self-expired |
|  | For the carbon market, NCX is the reference case for methodology-acceptance risk |

NCX is no longer a carbon platform and should not be evaluated as one. What remains is a small landowner-software business with an undisclosed model, a clean legal record, and the most instructive failure in recent voluntary-carbon history behind it: real capital, real buyers, real landowner payments — and an accounting methodology that did not survive independent scrutiny. AltStreet keeps this review published for the searchers still asking whether to enroll land or buy credits with NCX: you cannot, and the reasons why are worth ten minutes of any carbon buyer's time.


## Who it fits

| Investor | Fit | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| forest-landowners | neutral |  |
| corporate-buyers | poor-fit |  |
| investors-seeking-financial-returns | poor-fit |  |


## Questions

**Does NCX still sell carbon credits?**

No. NCX suspended its one-year harvest-deferral program in November 2022 and exited carbon project development entirely by October 2023, after Verra declined to adopt the tonne-year accounting its credits depended on (June 2022). Nothing carbon-related is sold on ncx.com as of August 2026.

**What is NCX now?**

A landowner software and content business. Its flagship is LandBook, a free tool for documenting a property's history, plans, and succession wishes (explicitly 'not a legal document'), joined in March 2026 by Sylvia, an AI forest-guide assistant, plus timber-market editorial content. How the free-tools business makes money is not disclosed.

**What happened to NCX's carbon program?**

Its accounting failed independent and registry scrutiny. NCX converted one-year harvest deferrals into permanent-equivalent claims using ton-year accounting with a 3.3% discount rate; CarbonPlan's January 2022 analysis found that understated the required tonnage by roughly 4x to 100x depending on the time horizon, and Verra declined the approach in June 2022. Without registry validation, buyer demand collapsed, and NCX wound the program down across 2022-2023 with three rounds of layoffs.

**Were landowners or buyers harmed?**

The documented landowner harms are informational — confusion about re-enrolling elsewhere and double-counting exposure — not financial: one-year contracts simply expired, and AltStreet found no verified non-payment disputes and no litigation (August 2026 web scan). Buyers are the open question: credits they retired were never registry-validated, and NCX published no guidance on restatement. NCX states it paid 'millions of dollars to thousands of American landowners' (company-stated).

**Was NCX a scam?**

The record does not support that framing. NCX built real measurement technology, paid landowners real money, published its reasoning, and wound down publicly when the registry process rejected its methodology — no fraud allegation, lawsuit, or regulatory action appears in AltStreet's scan. It is better understood as a well-funded bet on an accounting approach that independent scrutiny rejected: a methodology failure, not a fraud.

**What should carbon buyers learn from NCX?**

Methodology-acceptance risk is real and binary: NCX raised $50 million from sophisticated investors (J.P. Morgan, ICE, Microsoft) months before a registry decision effectively ended the business. For any credit whose methodology is 'pending approval,' price the possibility it is never approved — and note that the decisive analysis came from an independent research group, not from investor diligence.


## Update history

**August 13, 2026: Full rebuild: NCX no longer sells carbon credits — prior review was out of date**

AltStreet's verification sweep found the previous review (December 2025) described NCX's harvest-deferral carbon program in the present tense, though the program was suspended in November 2022 and carbon project development ended entirely by October 2023 after Verra declined tonne-year accounting (June 2022). The review is rebuilt around the current business — free landowner tools (LandBook; Sylvia AI assistant, launched March 2026) with an undisclosed monetization model — and a documented history of the carbon program's failure, preserved as a methodology-acceptance-risk case study. Funding record corrected: ~$74.4M total (approximate), $50M Series B led by Energize Ventures; no Sequoia participation found. Legal scan found no lawsuits, regulatory actions, or landowner litigation (web scan, not docket search).


## Evidence appendix

Platform website captured August 13, 2026.

August 2026 verification sweep: ncx.com and blog captures (current offerings and the company's own carbon-market post-mortem); NCX co-founder wind-down statements; CarbonPlan ton-year research (January 2022); Verra tonne-year decision coverage (June 2022); Carbon Market Watch consultation response; Mississippi State University Extension documentation of program terms and termination; funding coverage from Businesswire, CNBC, and Crunchbase News; layoff reporting from Quantum Commodity Intelligence; legal scan via targeted web searches (no docket search performed).

**Highlights**

- OBSERVED (site capture 8/2026): ncx.com sells no carbon products; flagship is LandBook (free, 'not a legal document') plus Sylvia AI assistant (launched March 2026).
- OBSERVED (company blog, February 2026): 'Carbon markets failed your forest — here's what still works' — NCX's own concession that the market its program inhabited collapsed for forests.
- THIRD-PARTY (CarbonPlan, January 2022): NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated permanence-equivalent tonnage ~4x (100-yr) to ~100x (1,000-yr).
- THIRD-PARTY: Verra declined tonne-year accounting June 2022; NCX methodology certification on indefinite hold — credits sold were never registry-validated.
- THIRD-PARTY (MSU Extension): landowner pricing ~$8-12/credit via blind auction; one-year contracts self-expired at termination; documented landowner harm is confusion, not non-payment.
- EDGAR-VERIFIED (CIK 1834847, three Form Ds): $4,399,992 fully sold/20 investors (12/2020, as SilviaTerra); $17,874,922 sold of $19,999,909/24 investors (4/2021 — filed the day the EDGAR name changed to Natural Capital Exchange Inc.); $49,999,936 fully sold/10 investors, first sale 2/18/2022 (3/2022 Series B) — all Rule 506(b), signed by Zachary Parisa; Marc Benioff among listed related persons on the 2021-2022 filings. Nothing filed since March 2022. Third-party funding tallies (~$74.4M total) remain approximate; no Sequoia participation found (correcting a common misattribution).
- SITE-CONFIRMED (August 13 2026 dossier): current ncx.com states '$20M+ payments to landowners' via timber sales, carbon programs, and conservation combined (company-stated); LandBook described as 'a record, not a legal document'; terms include as-is/no-warranty language, forced arbitration, and an all-caps disclaimer that property/timber/market forecasts may differ materially from actuals.
- COMPANY-STATED: 'millions of dollars paid to thousands of American landowners'; 2019 Microsoft pilot 6,861 tCO2e; total issuance never disclosed.
- LEGAL SCAN (8/2026): no lawsuits, regulatory actions, or landowner litigation found naming NCX — web scan, not a docket search.

**Primary source pages**

- https://ncx.com (August 2026 capture — LandBook flagship; no carbon products)
- https://ncx.com/blog/ (through March 2026, incl. Sylvia launch and 'Carbon markets failed your forest')
- https://ncx.com/blog/why-did-ncx-stop-the-1-year-forest-carbon-program/
- https://carbonplan.org/research/ton-year-ncx
- https://carbonmarketwatch.org/publications/carbon-market-watch-response-to-verra-consultation-on-a-new-methodology-for-harvest-deferral/
- https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/natural-capital-exchanges-former-forest-carbon-credit-programs-mississippi
- https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220302005321/en/ (Series B)
- https://www.qcintel.com/carbon/article/ncx-cuts-staff-by-further-40-steps-back-from-new-projects-13508.html
- EDGAR — Natural Capital Exchange Inc. / SilviaTerra Inc. (CIK 1834847): Form Ds 0001834847-20-000001, -21-000002, -22-000002
- https://ncx.com/terms/ and https://ncx.com/privacy/ (August 2026 dossier capture)


## Related

- Full review (HTML): https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/ncx
- Every platform review: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews
- Methodology and scoring: https://altstreet.investments/platforms
- Category hub: https://altstreet.investments/categories/carbon-climate-finance

---

Source page: https://altstreet.investments/platforms/reviews/ncx
Machine index: https://altstreet.investments/llms.txt
AltStreet reads what platforms, funds and issuers file with the SEC and what they tell investors, and publishes the difference. Figures are as filed or as captured on the date stated; nothing here is investment advice.
