NCX Review 2026
NCX no longer sells carbon credits — and AltStreet's earlier coverage, which described its harvest-deferral program in the present tense, was out of date. The company (Natural Capital Exchange, Inc., founded 2010 as SilviaTerra) suspended its one-year forest carbon cycles in November 2022, exited carbon project development entirely by October 2023 after Verra declined its tonne-year methodology, and cut roughly three-quarters of its staff across three rounds. What operates at ncx.com in 2026 is a landowner software and content business: LandBook, a free property-documentation tool, and Sylvia, an AI forest-guide assistant launched March 2026. This review now serves two purposes: documenting what NCX is today, and preserving the record of one of the voluntary carbon market's most instructive failures — a ~$74 million-funded credit developer whose accounting methodology did not survive registry scrutiny.

No platform response on record for this review. Is this your platform? Respond or claim it.
What the data actually shows - TL;DR
NCX exited the carbon business in 2022-2023 after its tonne-year methodology failed registry scrutiny; the 2026 company is a free landowner-software business. The numbers below are the record of the exit — the most useful thing NCX now offers the market.
The wind-down: one-year harvest-deferral cycles suspended and ~40% of staff cut (November 2022); further layoffs (May 2023); carbon project development ended entirely with another ~40% cut (October 2023). Verra had declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022 and put NCX's methodology certification on indefinite hold.
CarbonPlan's January 2022 finding: NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated the tonnage needed for permanence-equivalence by ~4x (100-year basis) to ~100x (1,000-year basis). The methodology critique that preceded — and predicted — the registry outcome.
Total venture funding (third-party tallies; approximate) — of which $72.3M is EDGAR-documented across three Form Ds under CIK 1834847: $4.4M (December 2020, 20 investors), $17.9M of a $20M offering (April 2021, 24 investors), and the $50.0M Series B ($49,999,936 fully sold to 10 investors, first sale February 18, 2022) led by Energize Ventures with J.P. Morgan, Intercontinental Exchange, Microsoft, Union Square Ventures, and TIME Ventures — closed roughly eight months before the program was suspended. Marc Benioff appears among the related persons on the 2021 and 2022 filings; no filing has followed.
Approximate landowner pricing via NCX's blind auction (per Mississippi State Extension). Buyers included Microsoft, South Pole, Shell, and Cargill; total credits issued and sold were never disclosed, and none were registry-validated. NCX states it paid 'millions of dollars to thousands of American landowners' (2024); the current site's '$20M+ payments to landowners' figure spans timber, carbon, and conservation combined (both company-stated).
AltStreet's August 2026 scan found no lawsuits, regulatory actions, or landowner litigation naming NCX — a web scan, not a docket search. Contracts self-expired; documented landowner harm is confusion (re-enrollment, double-counting), not non-payment.
Sources: ncx.com and blog captures (August 2026), NCX co-founder wind-down statements, CarbonPlan (January 2022), Verra's June 2022 tonne-year decision coverage, Carbon Market Watch consultation response, Mississippi State University Extension program documentation, Businesswire/CNBC/Crunchbase News funding coverage, Quantum Commodity Intelligence layoff reporting. Funding totals are third-party aggregates and approximate; company-stated figures attributed as such.
What's Actually Happening
In plain English, here is what actually happened.
- 1NCX used to pay forest landowners to delay logging for one year, then sold the resulting 'carbon credits' to companies like Microsoft and Shell. It stopped: new enrollment was suspended in late 2022 and the whole carbon business ended by October 2023.
- 2The reason was math, not scandal. Independent analysts (CarbonPlan) showed NCX's formula for converting one year of delayed logging into permanent-equivalent carbon claims was off by somewhere between 4x and 100x, and Verra — the registry NCX needed — refused to bless the approach in June 2022.
- 3The credits NCX did sell were never registry-validated. Nobody has sued, no regulator has acted (per AltStreet's August 2026 scan), and landowner contracts simply expired on their own one-year terms.
- 4About $74 million of venture money — from J.P. Morgan, the owner of the NYSE's parent's rival ICE, Microsoft, and Marc Benioff among others — went into a business that was effectively unwound within two years of its biggest funding round.
- 5Today ncx.com offers free tools for landowners: LandBook (document your property's history and succession wishes) and Sylvia, an AI assistant for forest questions, launched March 2026. How a free-tools business makes money is not disclosed.
- 6NCX's own blog now says it plainly — a February 2026 post is titled 'Carbon markets failed your forest — here's what still works,' and points landowners back to timber value.
Quick Verdict
Is this platform right for you?
There is no longer a carbon product to evaluate, so the verdict splits in two. As a current service: NCX's free landowner tools (LandBook, Sylvia) are low-stakes — no money changes hands, the visible risk is data-sharing with an undisclosed business model behind free software.
Read the full assessmentShow less
As a record: NCX is the cleanest available case study in methodology-acceptance risk — well-funded, well-intentioned, analytically sophisticated, and unwound within twenty months of a $50M round because a registry declined its accounting. The company's conduct through the failure was comparatively orderly: short contracts self-expired, no litigation followed, and its founders published explanations rather than disappearing. AltStreet's coverage previously described the carbon program in the present tense; that was wrong, and this rebuild corrects it.
Best for
- Forest landowners wanting free property-documentation and forestry-guidance tools, with eyes open about the undisclosed model behind them
- Carbon-market analysts and buyers studying methodology-acceptance risk before purchasing novel-methodology credits
- Sustainability teams assessing historical claims that relied on pre-2023 NCX credits
Avoid if
- You are looking to sell carbon from your land — NCX no longer offers that, and hasn't since 2022-2023
- You are looking to buy carbon credits — there is nothing to buy here
- You want investment exposure of any kind — NCX never offered any, and offers none now
Top strengths
- The wind-down record: one-year contracts self-expired, no verified non-payment disputes, no litigation or regulatory action found — an orderly failure by voluntary-carbon standards
- Founder transparency: public explanations of the program's end, including a 2026 admission that carbon markets 'failed' forest landowners
- Current tools are free — the downside for a landowner trying LandBook is time and data, not money
Key limitations
- The prior carbon model failed on its core methodological premise: the tonne-year approach was never registry-approved and independent analysis found it overstated equivalence by 4x-100x
- Credits already sold rest on that unapproved accounting — a live problem for any buyer who reported against them
- The current business model is undisclosed: free tools, unknown monetization, no published financials, leadership beyond the co-founders unverified
- No public disclosure of total credits issued/sold or the full disposition of buyer claims after the program ended
Where It Fits
Where NCX fits now.
Free landowner software and forestry content
If you want
Document a family property, get AI-assisted forestry guidance, follow timber markets
Use
NCX today — LandBook and Sylvia are free; the trade-off is an undisclosed business model behind free tools
Selling forest carbon from your land today
If you want
Actual landowner carbon income
Use
Registry-validated long-term programs (e.g., improved forest management projects under approved methodologies) via established developers — with the NCX lesson applied: confirm the methodology is approved, not pending
Buying credible carbon removal
If you want
Corporate carbon procurement that survives scrutiny
Use
Durable-CDR channels — Puro.earth-certified removals or intermediaries like Carbonfuture (see AltStreet's reviews); the market moved decisively toward durability after the era NCX typified
Compare Before Deciding
Where NCX fits against alternatives
Use these hooks to pressure-test whether this is the right platform, or whether a nearby alternative matches the job better.
How this compares to Puro.earth
Puro.earth
The contrast case: a durable-removal standard whose methodologies went through registry-grade scrutiny — the layer whose absence undid NCX.
How this compares to Carbonfuture
Carbonfuture
Where credible corporate carbon procurement moved after the era NCX typified: durable removals under approved standards with MRV evidence.
Nov 2022 → Oct 2023
The carbon program's wind-down window
Harvest-deferral cycles suspended and ~40% of staff cut (November 2022), further layoffs (May 2023), carbon project development ended entirely (October 2023) — after Verra declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022
4x-100x
How far CarbonPlan found NCX's permanence math understated required tonnage
The January 2022 analysis: NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated permanence-equivalent tonnage by ~4x on a 100-year basis to ~100x on a 1,000-year basis — the critique that preceded, and predicted, the registry outcome
~$74.4M
Venture funding raised before the exit — EDGAR-documented under a former name
Three Form Ds filed as SilviaTerra Inc. (CIK 1834847): $4.4M (Dec 2020), $17.9M of $20.0M (Apr 2021), $50.0M Series B (Mar 2022). Nothing filed since — though a missing notice filing alone would not rule out exempt, debt, or insider financing
0 filed actions
AltStreet's August 2026 scan found no lawsuits or regulatory actions naming NCX
A web scan, not a docket search. Contracts self-expired; the documented landowner harm is confusion (re-enrollment eligibility, double-counting concerns), not non-payment
Overview
Platform Overview
A concise read on what the platform is, how the structure works, and where the practical friction shows up for real investors.
Formerly: a forest carbon program and marketplace paying landowners for one-year harvest deferral, quantified by data-driven baselines and sold to corporate buyers under ton-year accounting — discontinued in stages between November 2022 and October 2023 after Verra declined the methodology. Currently: a landowner software and content platform (Natural Capital Exchange, Inc., San Francisco; founded 2010 as SilviaTerra by Zack Parisa and Max Nova, rebranded NCX in 2021) offering LandBook, a free property-documentation and succession-planning tool, and Sylvia, an AI forest-guide assistant launched March 2026, alongside timber-market editorial content. The current monetization model is not disclosed.
The model attracted ~$74.4 million in total venture funding — $72.3 million of it EDGAR-documented across three Form Ds under CIK 1834847 (whose SilviaTerra-to-Natural Capital Exchange name change in April 2021 corroborates the rebrand) — including a $50 million Series B in March 2022 led by Energize Ventures with J.P. Morgan, Intercontinental Exchange, Microsoft, Union Square Ventures, and TIME Ventures. It did not survive contact with the registry process: CarbonPlan's January 2022 analysis found the accounting understated permanence-equivalence by 4x-100x, Verra declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022, and NCX suspended enrollment that November, exiting carbon project development entirely by October 2023 across three layoff rounds.
Landowner contracts self-expired; no litigation or regulatory action followed (per AltStreet's August 2026 scan). The 2026 company offers free landowner tools — LandBook for property documentation and succession planning, Sylvia (an AI forest assistant, March 2026) — plus timber-market content, with an undisclosed monetization model. This review documents both the current state and the carbon program's record, which remains the voluntary market's clearest case study in methodology-acceptance risk.
Current Model
Free landowner software (LandBook, Sylvia AI) and forestry content; monetization undisclosed
Former Model
One-year harvest-deferral carbon program (suspended November 2022; carbon exit completed October 2023)
Corporate
Natural Capital Exchange, Inc., San Francisco; founded 2010 as SilviaTerra; rebranded NCX 2021; co-founders Zack Parisa and Max Nova
Funding
~$74.4M total (approximate, third-party tallies); $72.3M EDGAR-documented via three Form Ds (CIK 1834847): $4.4M 12/2020, $17.9M sold of $20M 4/2021, $50.0M Series B 3/2022 (Energize-led, with J.P. Morgan, ICE, Microsoft, USV, TIME Ventures; Benioff a listed related person). No filing since March 2022
Methodology Outcome
Verra declined tonne-year accounting June 2022; NCX certification on indefinite hold; credits sold were never registry-validated
Program Scale
Company-stated: 'millions of dollars paid to thousands of American landowners'; ~$8-12/credit landowner pricing via blind auction (MSU Extension); totals never disclosed
Legal Record
No lawsuits, regulatory actions, or landowner litigation found (August 2026 web scan, not a docket search)
ASWhat the carbon program was — and why it ended
- Landowners enrolled parcels in one-year harvest-deferral commitments via a blind auction; NCX quantified deferred carbon against modeled baselines and sold resulting claims to corporate buyers.
- Ton-year accounting converted one year of temporary storage into a permanent-equivalent claim using a discount rate — the load-bearing assumption CarbonPlan showed understated required tonnage by 4x-100x.
- Buyer acceptance collapsed when Verra declined the approach (June 2022): without registry validation, the credits had no independent standard behind them, and demand did not survive.
- The one-year cycle design — the program's most criticized feature analytically — was its most protective feature operationally: when the program died, obligations simply expired.
Key Gaps & Non-Disclosures
- Total issuance/sales figures and buyer-claim disposition were never published.
- The current free-tools business model and runway are undisclosed.
Platform Intelligence
NCX timeline
Key platform events, regulatory turns, liquidity stress points, and product launches that shape how the review should be read.
Founded as SilviaTerra
Zack Parisa and Max Nova launch SilviaTerra, a forest-analytics company using satellite and field data to map U.S. forests; early support includes Microsoft's AI for Earth.
Rebrand to NCX; first large program
SilviaTerra becomes NCX (Natural Capital Exchange) around the one-year harvest-deferral carbon marketplace; company describes its enrollment as the largest U.S. forest carbon project to date (company-stated).
CarbonPlan publishes the ton-year critique
Independent analysis finds NCX's 3.3% discount rate understates permanence-equivalent tonnage by ~4x (100-year) to ~100x (1,000-year) and flags additionality risk in one-year enrollment.
$50M Series B — EDGAR-documented
Energize Ventures leads, with J.P. Morgan, Intercontinental Exchange, Microsoft, Union Square Ventures, and TIME Ventures. The Form D (filed March 4, 2022) shows $49,999,936 fully sold to 10 investors, first sale February 18; Marc Benioff appears among the listed related persons. Closed roughly three months before the registry decision that undid the model — and it is the CIK's last filing.
Verra declines tonne-year accounting
Verra decides against adopting tonne-year accounting for forestry credits; NCX's methodology certification goes on indefinite hold. The credits NCX sold remain outside registry validation.
Program suspended; ~40% layoffs
NCX suspends one-year harvest-deferral cycles and cuts roughly 40% of staff.
Full exit from carbon
After further layoffs in May, NCX cuts another ~40% and stops developing carbon projects entirely, pivoting to a landowner-services marketplace. Landowner contracts self-expire on their one-year terms; no litigation follows.
Sylvia launches; candor about the market
NCX ships Sylvia, an AI forest-guide assistant, alongside flagship LandBook; a February 2026 post — 'Carbon markets failed your forest' — concedes the voluntary market's collapse for forests and redirects landowners to timber value. AltStreet's rebuilt review follows in August.
Investment Structures
NCX sells nothing to investors and, since 2022-2023, nothing to carbon buyers either. Its former credits were retirement claims, not investments; its current tools are free landowner software.
- No carbon credits have been offered since the program wound down (November 2022 suspension; October 2023 full exit).
- Current products (LandBook, Sylvia) are free; no financial product of any kind is offered.
- The historical record matters to buyers who previously purchased NCX credits, not to prospective participants — there is nothing to participate in.
Risk
Risk Structure
This is where the marketplace pitch gives way to the actual operating reality: delayed exits, limited disclosure, fee drag, and path-dependent outcomes.
Discontinued product risk (historical buyers)
Credits sold 2020-2022 rest on ton-year accounting that was never registry-approved and was quantitatively challenged (4x-100x) by independent analysis. Buyers who reported against them carry restatement exposure with no published company guidance.
Continuity risk (current users)
Free tools from a company with no disclosed revenue model, no funding events found since March 2022, and three historical layoff rounds. LandBook data and Sylvia guidance could become unavailable; nothing financial is at stake.
Data and reliance risk (current users)
LandBook solicits detailed property, family, and succession information into a free tool with an undisclosed monetization model, making data-use and retention terms material diligence items. The terms also carry 'as is'/no-warranty language, a forced-arbitration clause, and an explicit disclaimer that property, timber, and market forecasts 'may differ materially' from actuals — meaning Sylvia's guidance and LandBook's records come with the liability expressly disclaimed.
Double-counting risk (former participants)
Land previously credited under NCX that re-enrolls in other programs needs disclosure of the prior enrollment — successor programs' additionality and double-counting screens depend on it.
Restatement exposure for historical credit buyers
Organizations that retired NCX credits against climate claims hold claims backed by an unapproved methodology that independent analysis found materially over-generous.
Why it matters
Under tightening integrity standards and auditor scrutiny, pre-2023 claims built on never-validated credits are the kind most likely to be challenged.
Mitigation / verification
Inventory any NCX-backed claims, quantify their share of reported offsets, and assess with assurance or claims counsel whether supplementation, restatement, or replacement with registry-validated credits is warranted.
Tool discontinuity for current landowner users
LandBook and Sylvia are free products of a company whose post-carbon business model and runway are undisclosed.
Why it matters
Succession documentation entrusted to a free tool is only as durable as the company behind it — and LandBook is explicitly not a legal document.
Mitigation / verification
Export or duplicate anything important; treat LandBook as a structured note-taking aid feeding a real estate-planning process with an attorney, not a substitute for one.
Biggest Misconceptions & What Actually Happens
- What is the monetization model behind the free landowner tools?
- What guidance, if any, did NCX give credit buyers after the methodology was shelved?
- What are LandBook's data-use and retention terms in plain language?
Regulatory & Legal Posture
Security Status
Not a Security
NCX's former carbon credits were voluntary procurement claims retired by buyers, not securities, and its current products are free software and content — no securities have ever been offered to platform users. The company's own venture fundraising, however, IS on EDGAR: CIK 1834847 (SilviaTerra Inc., renamed Natural Capital Exchange Inc. in April 2021) carries three Rule 506(b) Form Ds — December 2020 ($4,399,992 fully sold, 20 investors), April 2021 ($19,999,909 offered, $17,874,922 sold at filing, 24 investors), and March 2022 ($49,999,936 fully sold, 10 investors — the Series B, first sale February 18, 2022), all signed by Zachary Parisa, with Marc Benioff among the listed related persons on the 2021 and 2022 filings. No later Form D appears under the company's CIK, and no subsequent financing round was identified in the sources reviewed — though a missing notice filing alone would not rule out exempt, debt, or insider financing.
Disclosure Quality
Historical program disclosure was the central weakness: methodology mathematics were contested externally (CarbonPlan) rather than resolved by company disclosure, and issuance totals were never published. Current-state disclosure is minimal but proportionate to free products.
Custody Model
No custody — free software currently; retirement-on-purchase claims historically
Regulatory Backing
None applicable. The former program operated outside registry validation after Verra declined the methodology; the current business is unregulated consumer software.
Tax Treatment
Reporting
Not Applicable
No current transactions. Historical landowner payments were ordinary income per contract terms; historical buyer purchases were procurement expenses.
Income Character
Not applicable (no current product)
Former landowner participants should have treated NCX payments as income in the year received; former buyers treated purchases as sustainability program expenses.
Limitation
Confirm historical treatment with tax advisors if unresolved; nothing current generates tax consequences.
Before You Invest
Get AltStreet's weekly briefing on NCX and its peers
Changes to fees, liquidity and investment terms across alternative platforms, including NCX, read against the filings. One email a week.
- Weekly platform research focused on tax timing and liquidity reality.
- Signals on distributions, risks, and structural tradeoffs before capital is locked up.
- Coverage of adjacent platforms so you can compare better options faster.
Get weekly platform signals
Track fee changes, liquidity updates, risk flags, and adjacent platforms before you invest.
Independent intelligence from AltStreet. No hype. No sponsor spin.
Nov 2022 → Oct 2023
The carbon program's wind-down window
Harvest-deferral cycles suspended and ~40% of staff cut (November 2022), further layoffs (May 2023), carbon project development ended entirely (October 2023) — after Verra declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022
4x-100x
How far CarbonPlan found NCX's permanence math understated required tonnage
The January 2022 analysis: NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated permanence-equivalent tonnage by ~4x on a 100-year basis to ~100x on a 1,000-year basis — the critique that preceded, and predicted, the registry outcome
~$74.4M
Venture funding raised before the exit — EDGAR-documented under a former name
Three Form Ds filed as SilviaTerra Inc. (CIK 1834847): $4.4M (Dec 2020), $17.9M of $20.0M (Apr 2021), $50.0M Series B (Mar 2022). Nothing filed since — though a missing notice filing alone would not rule out exempt, debt, or insider financing
0 filed actions
AltStreet's August 2026 scan found no lawsuits or regulatory actions naming NCX
A web scan, not a docket search. Contracts self-expired; the documented landowner harm is confusion (re-enrollment eligibility, double-counting concerns), not non-payment
Decision Fit
Investor Fit
Who this works for, who it does not, and what level of patience and complexity tolerance the platform really demands.
forest-landowners
The free tools may be genuinely useful for documentation and market awareness, with data-sharing and continuity as the only costs. Landowners seeking carbon income must look elsewhere — and apply the NCX lesson (approved methodologies only) when they do.
corporate-buyers
There is nothing to procure. Buyers holding legacy NCX credits have a diligence task, not a purchasing decision.
investors-seeking-financial-returns
NCX never offered investment products and offers no products for sale at all today.
Tradeoffs
Key Tradeoffs
The attraction of pre-IPO access is real, but every benefit comes bundled with a corresponding liquidity, transparency, or pricing cost.
Free tools vs. undisclosed model
LandBook and Sylvia cost nothing; the unknown is what business model eventually funds them and what happens to user data and tool continuity.
Instructive history vs. current relevance
The carbon program's record is highly instructive for market participants, but none of it bears on the low-stakes software the company ships today.
Avoid
Who This Is Not For
This section should be read as a filter, not an afterthought. If you need income, simplicity, or near-term access to capital, the structure is working against you.
Landowners seeking carbon revenue
NCX exited carbon in 2022-2023 and its own content now points landowners toward timber value instead.
Carbon credit buyers
No credits are offered; legacy credits were never registry-validated.
Investors
No investment product exists or ever existed here.
Editorial View
AltStreet Perspective
The compressed version of the review: what matters, what marketing tends to obscure, and how we would frame the platform for a serious allocator.
Verdict
NCX today is a low-stakes free-software business; NCX the carbon platform is a closed chapter whose record is the product. The failure was analytical, publicly sequenced, and — unusually for this market — handled without litigation, stranded contracts, or disappearance. That makes it the reference case study in methodology-acceptance risk, and makes AltStreet's job here mostly corrective: our earlier coverage described the program in the present tense years after it ended, and this rebuild fixes that.
Positioning
For landowners: free, possibly useful, low-risk tools from a company that has earned both skepticism (its accounting failed) and a measure of respect (its wind-down was orderly and its current content is candid). For carbon buyers and analysts: required reading. For investors: nothing, and there never was.
The Bottom Line
The voluntary carbon market's clearest methodology-failure case study, now operating as a free landowner-software business — nothing to buy, plenty to learn.
Action
Next Steps
If you still want to engage after reading the review, these are the practical next moves that reduce avoidable mistakes.
Former credit buyers: inventory NCX-backed claims and assess, with assurance or claims counsel, whether historical disclosures should be supplemented, restated, or replaced — the methodology behind them was never registry-approved.
Former landowner participants: disclose prior NCX enrollment when joining any successor carbon program to avoid double-counting findings against your land.
Current landowners considering LandBook/Sylvia: read the privacy policy, export anything important, and treat LandBook as input to a real estate-planning process, not a legal instrument.
Carbon buyers generally: apply the NCX test to any novel-methodology credit — is the methodology approved, or pending? Price 'pending' as 'possibly never.'
Final Answer
What this means for your decision.
Finding
NCX does not sell carbon credits — anything suggesting otherwise is out of date
Meaning
The one-year harvest-deferral program was suspended in November 2022 and carbon project development ended entirely by October 2023, after Verra declined to adopt tonne-year accounting (June 2022) and put NCX's methodology certification on indefinite hold. The 2026 website sells nothing carbon-related: its flagship is LandBook, a free tool for documenting a property's history and succession plans ('not a legal document,' per the site), plus the Sylvia AI assistant and timber-market content. NCX's own February 2026 blog post — 'Carbon markets failed your forest' — concedes the market it was built on collapsed for forests.
Action
Landowners: evaluate today's NCX as free software and editorial content, nothing more — and note the business model behind free tools is not disclosed. Carbon buyers: NCX is not a procurement channel; treat any residual NCX credits encountered in older portfolios as non-registry-validated (see below).
Finding
The carbon program's failure was methodological, not fraudulent — and the record shows both halves
Meaning
NCX sold credits based on ton-year accounting: paying landowners (~$8-12/credit via blind auction, per Mississippi State Extension) to defer harvests one year, converting temporary storage into retireable claims. CarbonPlan's January 2022 analysis showed NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated the tonnage required for genuine equivalence by roughly 4x on a 100-year basis and up to ~100x on a 1,000-year basis; Carbon Market Watch objected in Verra's consultation; Verra declined the approach in June 2022. The credits NCX sold — to buyers including Microsoft, South Pole, Shell, and Cargill — were sold outside registry validation. No fraud was alleged; AltStreet's scan found no lawsuits or regulatory actions. The registry process rejected the accounting approach, and the business did not survive without registry validation.
Action
If your organization holds or reported against NCX credits, treat them as unsupported by an approved registry methodology and assess, with appropriate assurance or claims counsel, whether any historical disclosures should be supplemented, restated, or replaced — the methodology was never approved, which is different from (and better than) revoked, but leaves claims resting on NCX's own math.
Finding
The wind-down was orderly for landowners on paper — one-year contracts self-expired
Meaning
Because contracts ran one year, program termination did not strand landowners in long obligations: commitments simply expired. Mississippi State Extension documents landowner confusion about re-enrollment elsewhere and double-counting risk, but AltStreet found no verified non-payment disputes and no landowner litigation. NCX stated it 'paid millions of dollars to thousands of American landowners' (2024), and its current site states '$20M+ payments to landowners' through timber sales, carbon programs, and conservation combined (both company-stated; the carbon-only share and total credits issued were never disclosed).
Action
Former participants re-enrolling land in other carbon programs should disclose the prior NCX enrollment — double-counting screens are the successor program's problem, and yours.
Finding
For the carbon market, NCX is the reference case for methodology-acceptance risk
Meaning
A company that raised ~$74.4 million (including a $50M Series B in March 2022 led by Energize Ventures, with J.P. Morgan, Intercontinental Exchange, Microsoft, Union Square Ventures, and Marc Benioff's TIME Ventures) was effectively unwound within 20 months of its largest round — not by scandal, but by a registry declining its accounting. Three layoff rounds (November 2022 ~40%, May 2023, October 2023 a further 40%) traced the collapse. Every buyer diligencing novel-methodology credits today is pricing the risk NCX realized.
Action
Apply the lesson forward: for any credit whose methodology is 'pending approval,' price the possibility it is never approved — and prefer credits certified under standards that already survived scrutiny.
If you read nothing else
NCX is no longer a carbon platform and should not be evaluated as one. What remains is a small landowner-software business with an undisclosed model, a clean legal record, and the most instructive failure in recent voluntary-carbon history behind it: real capital, real buyers, real landowner payments — and an accounting methodology that did not survive independent scrutiny. AltStreet keeps this review published for the searchers still asking whether to enroll land or buy credits with NCX: you cannot, and the reasons why are worth ten minutes of any carbon buyer's time.
AltStreet Research Desk
About to invest in NCX, or in an offering we haven't covered?
Commission an independent diligence report: the same filing-based analysis behind this review, applied to the specific investment in front of you before you wire the money.
- Built from primary sources: SEC filings, court records, capital structure, and marketing-versus-filings comparison.
- From $750; full reports from $1,495. Fixed price confirmed up front, delivery in 3-5 business days.
- Independent by design: we work for investors and accept no compensation from the companies we cover.
Want this on every new deal, not one? Deal Intelligence sends the alert the day a new offering appears on a covered platform and follows with an analyst-approved investment committee memo.
Deal Intelligence →Appendix
Sources, Disclosures, and Supporting Context
The lower section is structured like a report appendix: relationship context first, adjacent reading second, and evidence last.
Report Appendix
Disclosure
Relationship and compensation context
+
Report Appendix
Disclosure
Relationship and compensation context
Report Appendix
Related Resources
Adjacent platform comparisons, frameworks, and category links
+
Report Appendix
Related Resources
Adjacent platform comparisons, frameworks, and category links
Further Reading
Related Resources
Adjacent frameworks and reviews that help place the platform in a broader allocation or due-diligence context.
Explore Asset Class
Carbon & ClimateFrameworks
Similar Platform Reviews
- Puro.earth
The contrast case: a durable-removal standard whose methodologies went through registry-grade scrutiny — the layer whose absence undid NCX.
- Carbonfuture
Where credible corporate carbon procurement moved after the era NCX typified: durable removals under approved standards with MRV evidence.
Report Appendix
SEC Filers Behind NCX
The largest issuers linked to NCX on EDGAR, by total reported sold; each page carries the filing record and the related persons
+
Report Appendix
SEC Filers Behind NCX
The largest issuers linked to NCX on EDGAR, by total reported sold; each page carries the filing record and the related persons
- NATURAL CAPITAL EXCHANGE INC.$50.0M · 10 investors
Report Appendix
Evidence & Methodology
Sources, scope, and how the review was assembled
+
Report Appendix
Evidence & Methodology
Sources, scope, and how the review was assembled
ASReview Evidence
Methodology
August 2026 verification sweep: ncx.com and blog captures (current offerings and the company's own carbon-market post-mortem); NCX co-founder wind-down statements; CarbonPlan ton-year research (January 2022); Verra tonne-year decision coverage (June 2022); Carbon Market Watch consultation response; Mississippi State University Extension documentation of program terms and termination; funding coverage from Businesswire, CNBC, and Crunchbase News; layoff reporting from Quantum Commodity Intelligence; legal scan via targeted web searches (no docket search performed).
Scope
Current-state profile (LandBook, Sylvia, content business), corporate history and funding, the carbon program's full lifecycle including methodology criticism and registry outcome, wind-down mechanics and landowner impact, and legal/regulatory record.
Key Findings
- *OBSERVED (site capture 8/2026): ncx.com sells no carbon products; flagship is LandBook (free, 'not a legal document') plus Sylvia AI assistant (launched March 2026).
- *OBSERVED (company blog, February 2026): 'Carbon markets failed your forest — here's what still works' — NCX's own concession that the market its program inhabited collapsed for forests.
- *THIRD-PARTY (CarbonPlan, January 2022): NCX's 3.3% discount rate understated permanence-equivalent tonnage ~4x (100-yr) to ~100x (1,000-yr).
- *THIRD-PARTY: Verra declined tonne-year accounting June 2022; NCX methodology certification on indefinite hold — credits sold were never registry-validated.
- *THIRD-PARTY (MSU Extension): landowner pricing ~$8-12/credit via blind auction; one-year contracts self-expired at termination; documented landowner harm is confusion, not non-payment.
- *EDGAR-VERIFIED (CIK 1834847, three Form Ds): $4,399,992 fully sold/20 investors (12/2020, as SilviaTerra); $17,874,922 sold of $19,999,909/24 investors (4/2021 — filed the day the EDGAR name changed to Natural Capital Exchange Inc.); $49,999,936 fully sold/10 investors, first sale 2/18/2022 (3/2022 Series B) — all Rule 506(b), signed by Zachary Parisa; Marc Benioff among listed related persons on the 2021-2022 filings. Nothing filed since March 2022. Third-party funding tallies (~$74.4M total) remain approximate; no Sequoia participation found (correcting a common misattribution).
- *SITE-CONFIRMED (August 13 2026 dossier): current ncx.com states '$20M+ payments to landowners' via timber sales, carbon programs, and conservation combined (company-stated); LandBook described as 'a record, not a legal document'; terms include as-is/no-warranty language, forced arbitration, and an all-caps disclaimer that property/timber/market forecasts may differ materially from actuals.
- *COMPANY-STATED: 'millions of dollars paid to thousands of American landowners'; 2019 Microsoft pilot 6,861 tCO2e; total issuance never disclosed.
- *LEGAL SCAN (8/2026): no lawsuits, regulatory actions, or landowner litigation found naming NCX — web scan, not a docket search.
Primary Source Pages
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
High-intent search questions answered directly, without making users hunt through the full review.
Does NCX still sell carbon credits?
No. NCX suspended its one-year harvest-deferral program in November 2022 and exited carbon project development entirely by October 2023, after Verra declined to adopt the tonne-year accounting its credits depended on (June 2022). Nothing carbon-related is sold on ncx.com as of August 2026.
What is NCX now?
A landowner software and content business. Its flagship is LandBook, a free tool for documenting a property's history, plans, and succession wishes (explicitly 'not a legal document'), joined in March 2026 by Sylvia, an AI forest-guide assistant, plus timber-market editorial content. How the free-tools business makes money is not disclosed.
What happened to NCX's carbon program?
Its accounting failed independent and registry scrutiny. NCX converted one-year harvest deferrals into permanent-equivalent claims using ton-year accounting with a 3.3% discount rate; CarbonPlan's January 2022 analysis found that understated the required tonnage by roughly 4x to 100x depending on the time horizon, and Verra declined the approach in June 2022. Without registry validation, buyer demand collapsed, and NCX wound the program down across 2022-2023 with three rounds of layoffs.
Were landowners or buyers harmed?
The documented landowner harms are informational — confusion about re-enrolling elsewhere and double-counting exposure — not financial: one-year contracts simply expired, and AltStreet found no verified non-payment disputes and no litigation (August 2026 web scan). Buyers are the open question: credits they retired were never registry-validated, and NCX published no guidance on restatement. NCX states it paid 'millions of dollars to thousands of American landowners' (company-stated).
Was NCX a scam?
The record does not support that framing. NCX built real measurement technology, paid landowners real money, published its reasoning, and wound down publicly when the registry process rejected its methodology — no fraud allegation, lawsuit, or regulatory action appears in AltStreet's scan. It is better understood as a well-funded bet on an accounting approach that independent scrutiny rejected: a methodology failure, not a fraud.
What should carbon buyers learn from NCX?
Methodology-acceptance risk is real and binary: NCX raised $50 million from sophisticated investors (J.P. Morgan, ICE, Microsoft) months before a registry decision effectively ended the business. For any credit whose methodology is 'pending approval,' price the possibility it is never approved — and note that the decisive analysis came from an independent research group, not from investor diligence.
Update History
What's changed in this NCX review
New data, new findings, corrections, and confirmations as they emerge. Most recent updates appear first.
- Correction
PROGRAM STATUS: The harvest-deferral carbon program described as operating in the prior review was discontinued in stages between November 2022 (enrollment suspended, ~40% layoffs) and October 2023 (full exit from carbon project development, further ~40% layoffs). All present-tense program descriptions replaced with the documented timeline; current offerings (LandBook, Sylvia) now described.
- New finding
METHODOLOGY RECORD: Verra declined tonne-year accounting in June 2022 and NCX's certification went on indefinite hold — credits sold (buyers included Microsoft, South Pole, Shell, Cargill) were never registry-validated. CarbonPlan's January 2022 analysis quantified the accounting gap at ~4x-100x. Landowner pricing ~$8-12/credit via blind auction (MSU Extension); one-year contracts self-expired; no litigation found.
- New finding
CURRENT STATE (August 2026): ncx.com offers LandBook (free property-documentation/succession tool, 'not a legal document') and Sylvia (AI forest assistant, March 2026); a February 2026 company post concedes carbon markets 'failed' forest landowners. Monetization model undisclosed; no funding events found since March 2022.
- Correction
EDGAR FOOTPRINT (same-day correction, 2026-08-13): This rebuild initially stated no SEC filings exist for the operating business — wrong. CIK 1834847 (SilviaTerra Inc., renamed Natural Capital Exchange Inc. April 2021, corroborating the rebrand) carries three Rule 506(b) Form Ds documenting $72.3M of the venture history: $4,399,992/20 investors (12/2020), $17,874,922 sold of $19,999,909/24 investors (4/2021), $49,999,936 fully sold/10 investors, first sale 2/18/2022 (3/2022 Series B) — all signed by Zachary Parisa, Marc Benioff among listed related persons on the 2021-2022 filings. Nothing filed since March 2022 — consistent with, though not proof of, no subsequent priced round (exempt, debt, or insider financing would leave no Form D). (Unrelated same-name 'NCX Corp,' CIK 1867512, is a different company.)
- New data
SAME-DAY DOSSIER (2026-08-13, 20 pages): current site states '$20M+ payments to landowners' via timber sales, carbon programs, and conservation combined (company-stated — quantifies and broadens the earlier 'millions to thousands' claim); LandBook mechanics confirmed ('a record, not a legal document'; guided conversation producing a first-person letter plus organized property records); terms carry as-is/no-warranty language, forced arbitration, and an explicit disclaimer that property/timber/market forecasts may differ materially from actuals — added to the data-and-reliance risk.
