NYCERS Reports Lower IRR on Ardian's ASF IX B as Its Benchmark Gap Turns Positive
New York City's employees' pension fund reported a 16.7% since-inception net IRR on Ardian's 2023-vintage secondary fund as of March 31, 2026, against 22.5% at December 31, 2025. Measured against the plan's Russell 3000 public-market equivalent, the fund moved from 0.7 points behind to 1.9 points ahead.
Key facts
5- NYCERS, as of March 31, 2026: ASF IX B (vintage 2023, first drawdown April 26, 2023), $69.2 million committed, $31,795,102 contributed, $4,497,148 distributed, $33,125,707 market value, 1.18x, since-inception net IRR 16.7%, PME return 14.8%, PME spread 1.9 points.
- NYCERS, as of December 31, 2025: ASF IX B $29,767,806 contributed, $3,068,587 distributed, $32,977,806 market value, 1.21x, net IRR 22.5%, PME return 23.2%, PME spread (0.7) points.
- NYCERS's PME is the Russell 3000 PME+ (Long-Nickels PME where no capital has been distributed); the spread is the IRR minus the PME return.
- Ardian Access LLC's application to the SEC (Form 40-APP/A, filed June 24, 2025) lists ASF IX B L.P. as advised by Ardian Investment UK Limited.
- NYCERS, as of March 31, 2026: ASF VIII B 1.37x, 10.8% (from 1.40x, 11.9%); ASF VII B 1.53x, 12.8% (from 1.55x, 13.2%); ASF VI B 1.41x, 11.1% (unchanged). CalPERS: ASF VIII B L.P. 1.4x, 10.8%.
The New York City Employees' Retirement System (NYCERS) reported its investment in ASF IX B, a 2023-vintage secondary fund advised by Ardian, at a 16.7% net IRR and a 1.18x multiple as of March 31, 2026. As of December 31, 2025 the same schedules showed 22.5% and 1.21x. Both IRRs are since-inception annualized returns, measured at two consecutive quarter-ends. Against the plan's public-market benchmark, the fund moved the other way: from 0.7 points behind to 1.9 points ahead.
What the two schedules show
Over the quarter NYCERS contributed about $2.0 million more and received about $1.4 million in distributions, while the reported market value was nearly flat. The fund has returned 14% of contributed capital, so most of its value is still the manager's mark, and an IRR at that stage moves sharply with the timing of cash flows. NYCERS's benchmark is the Russell 3000 PME+, which runs the same cash flows through the public index; its return fell further over the quarter than the fund's, which is why the spread turned positive while the IRR fell.
- —March 31, 2026: $69.2M committed, $31.8M contributed, $4.5M distributed, $33.1M market value, 1.18x, net IRR 16.7%, Russell 3000 PME 14.8%, spread +1.9 points
- —December 31, 2025: $29.8M contributed, $3.1M distributed, $33.0M market value, 1.21x, net IRR 22.5%, Russell 3000 PME 23.2%, spread -0.7 points
The other ASF funds in the schedules
Ardian Access LLC's 2025 application to the SEC lists ASF IX B L.P. among funds advised by Ardian Investment UK Limited. NYCERS also reported ASF VIII B at 1.37x and 10.8% (from 1.40x and 11.9%), ASF VII B at 1.53x and 12.8% (from 1.55x and 13.2%) and ASF VI B unchanged at 1.41x and 11.1%. CalPERS reported its ASF VIII B L.P. position at 1.4x and 10.8% as of March 31, 2026; it labels the fund vintage 2020 where NYCERS uses 2018, and the two plans' figures are reported side by side, not combined.
See the opportunity. Understand the risk.
Get the latest on ASF IX B L.P.
Follow the latest on ASF IX B L.P., discover new deals, and keep an eye on the risks. Get market news, platform updates, and independent research that helps you see beyond the pitch, delivered to your inbox.
Make your next move an informed one
Get the latest on ASF IX B L.P. and the wider alternative markets. Join free.
Independent intelligence from AltStreet. No hype. No sponsor spin.
What the filings do not show
These are the plans' reported marks as of each date, published one to two quarters later; they are not the manager's figures. The schedules do not say why a mark moved or how the underlying portfolio was valued. A single quarter's change in a since-inception IRR on a fund that has returned 14% of contributed capital says little about its eventual result.
Sources
- NYCERS Monthly Performance Review Material, September 2026 (private equity portfolio as of March 31, 2026) — New York City Comptroller
- NYCERS Monthly Performance Review Material, June 2026 (private equity portfolio as of December 31, 2025) — New York City Comptroller
- PEP Fund Performance (as of March 31, 2026) — California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS)
- Ardian Access LLC et al., Form 40-APP/A, Appendix A (filed 2025-06-24) — SEC EDGAR
