Judge Asks Whether to Pause South Carolina Gambling Suit Against DraftKings and Polymarket Until the Kalshi Appeals Are Decided

A November 10 text order in Hughes v. DraftKings directs the parties to report within 10 days whether they support a stay pending the Fourth Circuit's KalshiEX v. Martin and the Supreme Court petition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX (No. 26-299), with a fully briefed motion to remand still undecided.

By , Head of Research· AltStreet Research
Headline card for Judge Asks Whether to Pause South Carolina Gambling Suit Against DraftKings and Polymarket Until the Kalshi Appeals Are Decided

Key facts

7
  1. Text order of November 10, 2026 (entry 65): the court is considering a stay pending the Fourth Circuit's decision in KalshiEX v. Martin (No. 25-1892) and the Supreme Court cert petition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX, and directs the parties to confer and advise within 10 days whether they support or oppose a stay.
  2. The Supreme Court petition is No. 26-299, docketed September 8, 2026, from the Third Circuit's April 6, 2026 decision (No. 25-1922); the district court's order cites 25A1465, which is the linked application that extended New Jersey's time to file the petition. The response is due December 7, 2026 after two extensions.
  3. The motion to remand (entry 40) was fully briefed on November 5, 2026 with the plaintiff's reply (entry 64); no ruling has issued.
  4. The DraftKings entities removed the case on September 2, 2026 (entry 1) from the Charleston County Court of Common Pleas (2026-CP-10-04063), where James M. Hughes had filed on July 29, 2026 a single cause of action under South Carolina's Statute of Anne.
  5. Under S.C. Code 32-1-10 a person who loses $50 or more at a sitting may sue the winner within three months; under 32-1-20, if the loser does not, any other person may sue for the sum lost and treble its value, half to the person suing and half to the county. The removal notice describes the complaint as alleging that sports-related event contracts traded on the defendants' exchanges are illegal gambling, that thousands of South Carolina residents have lost more than $50 at a sitting, and as seeking four times the losses, an accounting and an injunction.
  6. The four Polymarket entities, Blockratize Inc., QCL Quad Code USA Corp., QCX LLC (d/b/a Polymarket US) and QC Clearing LLC (d/b/a Polymarket Clearing), joined the removal on September 8, 2026 (entry 5) and added federal-officer removal under 28 U.S.C. 1442(a)(1), on the ground that Polymarket US, a CFTC-designated contract market since July 9, 2025, acts as a self-regulatory organization exercising delegated federal authority.
  7. No defendant has answered; the September 28 order (entry 16) ties the answer deadline to 30 days after the remand ruling.

A federal judge in South Carolina has asked the parties to a gambling-law suit against DraftKings' prediction-market units, Polymarket's U.S. entities and a group of exchange and trading-firm defendants to say within 10 days whether the case should be paused. The text order, entered November 10, 2026 as entry 65 in Hughes v. DraftKings Inc. (D.S.C. 2:26-cv-03838) at the direction of Judge Richard M. Gergel, cites the Fourth Circuit's pending decision in KalshiEX v. Martin (No. 25-1892) and the pending Supreme Court petition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX as raising some of the same legal issues.

The order came five days after the plaintiff's reply brief (entry 64, November 5) completed briefing on his motion to remand the case to state court (entry 40). The court has not ruled on that motion.

What the complaint alleges

According to the removal notice (entry 1), James M. Hughes, a South Carolina resident, sued in the Court of Common Pleas for Charleston County on July 29, 2026 (case 2026-CP-10-04063) under the state's Statute of Anne. The statute has two steps. Section 32-1-10 lets a person who loses $50 or more "at any time or sitting" at "cards, dice table or any other game whatsoever" sue the winner within three months to recover the loss. Section 32-1-20 provides that if the loser does not bring that suit in time, "any other person" may sue the winner for the sum lost and treble its value, four times the loss in all, with half going to the person who sues and half to the county where the offense occurred. Hughes sues as that other person. The notice describes the complaint as alleging that sports-related event contracts traded on the defendants' exchanges are illegal gambling, that thousands of South Carolina residents have lost, and continue to lose, more than $50 at a sitting, and as seeking four times the value of the losses, an accounting and an injunction against the defendants' continued operation in the state.

The defendants named in the caption are DraftKings Inc., GUS III LLC (d/b/a DraftKings Predictions) and Railbird Exchange LLC (d/b/a DKeX); Blockratize Inc., QCL Quad Code USA Corp., QCX LLC (d/b/a Polymarket US) and QC Clearing LLC (d/b/a Polymarket Clearing); Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and North American Derivatives Exchange Inc.; Bitnomial Clearinghouse LLC; the trading firms Wintermute Trading Ltd., Jump Trading LLC, DRW Holdings LLC, IMC-Chicago LLC, Galaxy Digital Trading LLC and Virtu Financial Inc.; and John Does 1 to 10. Several have since been dismissed, as set out below. These are the plaintiff's allegations as the defendants summarize them; no court has ruled on them.

What the docket shows

The DraftKings entities removed the case on September 2, 2026, asserting diversity and federal-question jurisdiction. On September 8 the four Polymarket entities filed a notice of joinder (entry 5) adopting those grounds and adding a third, removal under the federal-officer statute, 28 U.S.C. 1442(a)(1): the notice states that the CFTC approved Polymarket US as a designated contract market on July 9, 2025, and argues that in operating that market Polymarket US functions as a self-regulatory organization exercising authority delegated by the CFTC.

Since removal the docket has been procedural. The plaintiff voluntarily dismissed Galaxy Digital Trading on September 25 (entry 14) and Wintermute Trading on September 28 (entries 18 and 19); the removal notice states that DRW Holdings and IMC-Chicago had been dismissed before removal. Judge Gergel's September 28 order (entry 16) moved the remand-motion deadline to October 15 and set the defendants' answer deadline at 30 days after a remand ruling. Oppositions to the remand motion were filed October 29 by the DraftKings entities (entry 55) and the Polymarket entities (entry 56), the reply followed on November 5, and the stay order came on November 10. A string of pro hac vice admissions for counsel to CME, NADEX, Bitnomial, DraftKings, Jump and Virtu was entered November 3 and 4.

One number in the order needs a gloss. It refers to the Supreme Court matter as 25A1465, which is the application New Jersey's gaming regulators filed in June 2026 to extend their time to seek review; Justice Alito granted it twice, to September 3. The petition itself, filed September 2 and docketed September 8, 2026, is No. 26-299, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, from the Third Circuit's April 6, 2026 decision in No. 25-1922. Kalshi's response, twice extended, is due December 7, 2026. Amicus briefs supporting the petition were filed in September and October by, among others, Ohio and other states, 145 Indian tribes, the National Football League, the American Gaming Association and former CFTC chairman Gary Gensler.

Background

The two matters the order names are the appellate tests of whether state gambling law reaches event contracts traded on CFTC-designated exchanges. The removal notice itself places this case in that line: it cites the CFTC's amicus brief in KalshiEX v. Schuler (6th Cir. No. 26-3196, May 12, 2026) and the United States' own suit, United States v. Arizona (D. Ariz., filed April 2, 2026), and states that two courts had already granted CFTC requests to enjoin state enforcement.

AltStreet's review of Polymarket, updated November 12, 2026, treats Polymarket US (QCX LLC, the designated contract market, with QC Clearing LLC as its clearinghouse) as distinct from the international venue, and records the 2022 CFTC settlement under which Blockratize paid a $1.4 million civil penalty over an unregistered event-binary facility. The South Carolina complaint names the domestic entities and Blockratize, not the offshore operator.

The pattern in AltStreet's data

Hughes is one of several federal dockets naming Polymarket entities with recent activity in AltStreet's court watch: Lee v. Blockratize, Inc. logged an entry on November 4, 2026, and a case against Adventure One QSS, Inc., the entity associated with the offshore platform, logged one on November 6. The Kalshi matters the order relies on are tracked in AltStreet's Kalshi litigation tracker.

Why it matters

The posture is procedural. No court has decided whether DKeX's or Polymarket US's event contracts are gambling under South Carolina law, and the presiding judge has signaled he may wait for the Fourth Circuit and possibly the Supreme Court before deciding even which court should hear the case. A stay, if entered, would leave both the forum question and the merits open. The federal-officer theory the Polymarket entities added is a jurisdictional argument no ruling in this docket has yet tested.

What the record does not show

The docket holds no ruling on remand, no finding on the legality of the contracts, no answer from any defendant, and no stay; the November 10 order only asks the parties to state a position within 10 days. This account is limited to the federal docket and the Supreme Court docket; the original Charleston County proceeding is outside it.

See the opportunity. Understand the risk.

Get the latest on Polymarket

Follow the latest on Polymarket, discover new deals, and keep an eye on the risks. Get market news, platform updates, and independent research that helps you see beyond the pitch, delivered to your inbox.

New dealsMarket newsPlatform updates

Make your next move an informed one

Get the latest on Polymarket and the wider alternative markets. Join free.

Independent intelligence from AltStreet. No hype. No sponsor spin.

Sources

  1. Hughes v. DraftKings Inc., No. 2:26-cv-03838 (D.S.C.), docket — CourtListener (RECAP)
  2. Notice of Removal, entry 1, September 2, 2026 — U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina
  3. Notice of Joinder and Additional Grounds for Removal, entry 5, September 8, 2026 — U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina
  4. Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, No. 26-299, Supreme Court docket — Supreme Court of the United States
  5. S.C. Code of Laws, Title 32, Chapter 1 (Sections 32-1-10 and 32-1-20) — South Carolina Legislature
  6. AltStreet review: Polymarket — AltStreet

This article was produced by AltStreet's filing-monitoring systems and reviewed by a human editor before publication. Figures sourced from SEC EDGAR filings are cited by accession number; platform-reported figures are unaudited. See our editorial policy and verification policy. Nothing here is investment advice.

Questions about this article, corrections, or additional information — including from the entities covered: [email protected]. Substantive responses from covered entities are added to articles per our editorial policy.

Related: AltStreet's Polymarket review · Comparison terminal