Kalshi Khamenei-Market Class Actions Stayed After Arbitration Briefing
Two putative class actions over Kalshi's settlement of its 'Ali Khamenei out as Supreme Leader?' market, Risch (filed in California, now in New York) and Golan (New York), are related cases before Judge Edgardo Ramos. Kalshi's motion to send both to arbitration under its rulebook was fully briefed by August 26. On November 13 each docket records a stipulation and order staying the case; the document is not public.
Key facts
5- Risch v. KalshiEX LLC was filed first, in the Central District of California on March 5, 2026 (2:26-cv-02390); it was transferred June 3 and docketed in the Southern District of New York June 4 as 1:26-cv-04734. Golan v. KalshiEX LLC was filed in the Southern District of New York on March 24, 2026 (1:26-cv-02394). Risch was accepted as related to Golan and reassigned to Judge Edgardo Ramos on June 9; no consolidation order appears on either docket.
- Both are putative class actions over the settlement of Kalshi's 'Ali Khamenei out as Supreme Leader?' market at the last traded price after Khamenei's death on February 28, 2026. Golan's complaint says his 1,436 'Yes' contracts settled at $0.29 for $416.44 against a cost of $574.75 per Kalshi's statement; Risch and Gliksman's complaint describes purchases of 'Yes' contracts at $0.06 to $0.28 on February 18 and 28.
- Kalshi filed a single motion to compel arbitration in both cases on July 15, 2026, resting on Member Agreement section VII.A and Rulebook Rule 11.3(d) ('any action' against a Kalshi party 'will be resolved by binding arbitration') and the sign-up notice 'By continuing, you acknowledge and agree to Kalshi's legal terms'; the plaintiffs opposed on August 12 and Kalshi replied on August 26. The motion was fully briefed before the stay.
- On November 13, 2026 both dockets record an entry labeled 'Stipulation and Order', after which each case is marked stayed and its pending motions terminated (Golan entry 31, Risch entry 82); the documents are not in the public mirror and their terms are not established.
- No answer to either complaint, no ruling on arbitration and no decision on the merits appears on either docket. The Risch complaint's figure of about $54 million traded on the market is alleged volume, not a measure of losses or of any amount recoverable.
Two putative class actions over how Kalshi settled its 'Ali Khamenei out as Supreme Leader?' market are stayed by agreement of the parties. Risch v. KalshiEX LLC (S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-04734) and Golan v. KalshiEX LLC (S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-02394), related cases before Judge Edgardo Ramos, each record a November 13, 2026 entry that the docket labels a stipulation and order, after which the case is marked stayed and its pending motions terminated. The document is not in the public mirror, so what the parties agreed, and whether the stay is tied to arbitration, settlement talks or something else, is not established.
The motion terminated with the stay was Kalshi's motion to compel arbitration, filed in both cases on July 15, 2026 and fully briefed by August 26. It argues that every Kalshi user agrees at sign-up to a rulebook rule under which 'any action' against a Kalshi party 'will be resolved by binding arbitration'. The court did not rule on it, Kalshi has not answered either complaint, and nothing on either docket addresses the merits.
What the complaints allege
Adam Risch and Yonatan Gliksman, California citizens, sued first, in the Central District of California on March 5, 2026, through Novian & Novian. Their complaint says the market opened around January 8, 2026 with contracts on several deadlines, including March 1 and April 1, 2026, under a rules summary reading 'if Ali Khamenei leaves office before March 1, 2026, then the market resolves to yes.' They say they bought 'Yes' contracts at prices from $0.06 to $0.28 on February 18 and on February 28, the day of the U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran, in trades of about $35 to $75 each; that Kalshi paused trading that afternoon, closed the market that night and settled at the last traded price; and they quote a Kalshi email of that evening saying 'many users did not have a full understanding of the rules for this market' and announcing fee refunds, payment of pre-death positions at the last traded price and reimbursement of post-death purchases up to cost. The complaint pleads California consumer-protection, unfair-competition and contract counts and alleges about $54 million of trading volume across the contract dates. That figure is volume, not a measure of what holders lost or could recover.
Itay Golan, a New York citizen, sued in the Southern District of New York on March 24, 2026, through Leeds Brown Law and Levi Law. His complaint says he held 1,436 'Yes' contracts on the April 1 deadline and that Kalshi settled them at $0.29 per contract rather than as a binary 'Yes', paying him $416.44 against a cost that Kalshi's own statement to him put at $574.75. It pleads contract, fraud, negligent misrepresentation, General Business Law and unjust enrichment counts under New York law and seeks a declaration that the settlement methodology was not properly disclosed. Both complaints are allegations. Kalshi's only filed account of the facts is the background section of its arbitration motion, which says it settled the contracts 'pursuant to the contract terms' at the last traded price after Khamenei's death.
The arbitration motion
Kalshi's counsel, Milbank LLP, told Judge Ramos in May that Risch was 'essentially identical' to Golan and would be transferred; Judge Stanley Blumenfeld Jr. ordered the transfer on June 3 and the New York court accepted Risch as related to Golan on June 9. A June 30 stipulation set one schedule for both cases: a single motion to compel arbitration by July 15, a response within 28 days, a reply within 14 days, and Kalshi's deadlines to answer the complaints stayed until the court ruled. The motion rests on section VII.A of the KalshiEX Member Agreement, in which the member agrees to 'abide by and be subject to the Kalshi Rulebook ... including the obligation to submit to arbitration', and on Rulebook Rule 11.3(d), under which each participant agrees that any action it brings against a Kalshi party will be resolved by binding arbitration. A declaration from Xavier Sottile, Head of Markets at KalshiEX, describes the sign-up screen: beneath the Google, Apple and email buttons, 'By continuing, you acknowledge and agree to Kalshi's legal terms, which we recommend reviewing,' with the sentence linking to the Member Agreement, the Rulebook and other documents, repeated at each login. Kalshi argues the clause covers every claim arising from trading and that affiliated defendants that did not sign the agreements can invoke it by equitable estoppel.
The plaintiffs' consolidated opposition of August 12 is not in the public mirror; the docket shows declarations from the three plaintiffs and counsel with screen captures of the sign-up flow, a copy of the Kalshi Klear rulebook and a request for oral argument. Kalshi's August 26 reply says the plaintiffs' own declarants 'recorded the mobile sign-up screen displaying the Notice Sentence beneath the enrollment buttons, and no Plaintiff denies encountering it', and answers their reading of the rulebook by saying that Chapter 10's elective mechanism governs participant-to-participant claims, not actions against Kalshi. The motion was fully briefed before the stay; the next entries after the reply are a November 11 entry labeled 'Stay' and the November 13 stipulation and order.
- —March 5, 2026: Risch and Gliksman file in the Central District of California (2:26-cv-02390)
- —March 24, 2026: Golan files in the Southern District of New York (1:26-cv-02394)
- —May 26, 2026: 30-day stay in Golan pending the California transfer motion (Golan entry 19)
- —June 3 to 9, 2026: Risch transferred to New York (Risch entry 46), docketed as 1:26-cv-04734, accepted as related to Golan and reassigned to Judge Ramos
- —June 30, 2026: stipulated schedule for a single motion to compel arbitration in both cases (Golan entry 22; Risch entry 59)
- —July 15 to August 26, 2026: motion, opposition and reply filed in both cases (Golan entries 23 to 27; Risch entries 62 to 77)
- —November 13, 2026: entry labeled 'Stipulation and Order'; each case stayed, pending motions terminated (Golan entry 31; Risch entry 82)
Why it matters
For anyone holding event contracts on Kalshi, the live question in these cases is not yet whether the Khamenei settlement was right but whether customers can pursue these claims in court. If the rulebook's arbitration rule binds account holders, the dispute moves to arbitration; if it does not, the court would reach the disclosure and contract questions the complaints raise. Whether arbitration under Kalshi's terms would proceed on a class or an individual basis is not addressed in the motion papers AltStreet read, and the Member Agreement and Rulebook exhibits that would show it are not in the public mirror. The stipulated stay leaves all of that undecided. The same arbitration question has been pending since October 29 in Pernas v. KalshiEX LLC (S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-07419), a single-trader suit over a Trump-Trudeau contract that AltStreet reported on October 8.
The amounts at stake for the named plaintiffs are small: the complaints put Golan's shortfall at a few hundred dollars and each of Risch's and Gliksman's trades at about $35 to $75. The class allegations are what give the cases their size. The record also fixes what Kalshi said at the time, through the complaints' quotations of its February 28 email: that the market settled at the last traded price, that fees were refunded, that post-death buyers were reimbursed to cost, and that 'many users did not have a full understanding of the rules.' Whether that disclosure was adequate is the contested question, and no court has addressed it.
See the opportunity. Understand the risk.
Get the latest on Kalshi
Follow the latest on Kalshi, discover new deals, and keep an eye on the risks. Get market news, platform updates, and independent research that helps you see beyond the pitch, delivered to your inbox.
Make your next move an informed one
Get the latest on Kalshi and the wider alternative markets. Join free.
Independent intelligence from AltStreet. No hype. No sponsor spin.
Sourcing
AltStreet read both complaints, the May 26 stay order, the motion to compel arbitration with its memorandum and the Sottile declaration, and Kalshi's reply, all from the federal dockets via CourtListener. Not read, because they are not in the public mirror: the Member Agreement and Rulebook exhibits, the plaintiffs' August 12 opposition, the June 30 stipulation beyond its docket text, and the November 11 and 13 entries. The terms and duration of the November 13 stay, and the reason the arbitration motion was terminated, are therefore not established. AltStreet has not asked Kalshi or plaintiffs' counsel to comment.
Sources
- Golan v. KalshiEX LLC, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-02394, docket — CourtListener (RECAP)
- Adam Risch v. KalshiEX LLC, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-04734, docket — CourtListener (RECAP)
- Class action complaint, Risch v. KalshiEX LLC (entry 1, March 5, 2026) — U.S. District Court, C.D. Cal., transferred to S.D.N.Y.
- Class action complaint, Golan v. KalshiEX LLC (entry 1, March 24, 2026) — U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y.
- Order granting 30-day stay, Golan v. KalshiEX LLC (entry 19, May 26, 2026) — U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y.
- Memorandum of law in support of defendants' motion to compel arbitration (Risch entry 63, July 15, 2026) — U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y.
- Declaration of Xavier Sottile (Risch entry 64, July 15, 2026) — U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y.
- Reply memorandum in support of the motion to compel arbitration (Risch entry 77, August 26, 2026) — U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y.
- Kalshi review: litigation census — AltStreet Research
