Kalshi Loses Maryland Appeal as Fourth Circuit Judges Split on Reasoning
A divided panel affirmed the denial of Kalshi's preliminary injunction on November 18, 2026. One judge found no clear federal preemption of state gambling law even if the contracts are swaps, one found the contracts are not swaps, and the dissent would have ruled for Kalshi on both points. Maryland had agreed to forgo enforcement pending the appeal.
Key facts
8- Kalshiex LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892 (4th Cir.), argued May 7, 2026 and decided November 18, 2026: the District of Maryland's August 1, 2025 denial of Kalshi's preliminary injunction (Judge Adam B. Abelson, 1:25-cv-01283) is affirmed by a one-sentence published per curiam opinion joined by Judges Gregory and Thacker, each of whom wrote separately; Judge Benjamin dissented.
- Judge Gregory, concurring, assumed without deciding that the sports event contracts are swaps and held that the Commodity Exchange Act's exclusive-jurisdiction clause, read with the 'Special Rule' for event contracts involving gaming (7 U.S.C. 7a-2(c)(5)(C)) and CFTC Rule 40.11, does not clearly displace Maryland's authority over gambling, and that Kalshi 'may comply with both sovereigns by satisfying Maryland's licensing requirements or declining to offer the individual contracts within the state.'
- Judge Thacker, concurring in the judgment, would hold that the contracts are not swaps because they pay on the outcome of a sporting event rather than on 'the occurrence, nonoccurrence, or the extent of the occurrence' of an event; she wrote 'What is happening here is sports betting' and quoted Kalshi's counsel at argument: 'I don't dispute that a year ago we did advertise as sports betting.'
- Judge Benjamin, dissenting, would hold that the contracts are swaps, that the CEA field-preempts Maryland's law as applied to a CFTC-designated contract market, and would vacate and remand for the remaining injunction factors.
- Maryland agreed to forgo enforcement pending the appeal: Kalshi's August 13, 2025 notice (D. Md. ECF 83) says that on August 12 it 'received written assurances from counsel for Defendants that Defendants would forgo enforcement of the relevant Maryland laws against Kalshi pending the outcome of Kalshi's pending appeal in the Fourth Circuit,' and withdrew its motion for an injunction pending appeal on that basis. The appellate opinion sets no enforcement deadline.
- Appellate record on Kalshi's preemption position: for Kalshi, the Third Circuit (Flaherty, April 6, 2026); against, the Ninth Circuit (Assad, August 28, 2026, contracts likely not swaps), the Sixth Circuit (Schuler and Orgel, September 25, 2026, not swaps and, alternatively, no preemption even if they were; a motions panel had denied an injunction pending appeal on April 24) and now the Fourth. New Jersey's petition for Supreme Court review of the Third Circuit ruling (No. 26-299) is pending, Kalshi's response due December 7, 2026.
- Kalshi's statement, as reported by InGame: 'Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong. This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.' Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown: 'Today's ruling means Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents.'
- The ruling is on a preliminary injunction, not a final merits judgment; the district case remains open. On October 9, 2026 the CFTC proposed to define 'swap' to include event contracts, including those based on sports (91 FR 66022, comments due 30 days after publication), and issued an interim final rule excluding 'casino-style gambling products, including wagers placed on sportsbooks and casino games' from the definition (91 FR 65969, effective on publication); both postdate the briefing and neither is addressed in the opinion.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on November 18, 2026 affirmed the denial of KalshiEX LLC's request for a preliminary injunction against Maryland's gaming regulators, which had ordered it to stop offering sports event contracts to Marylanders without a state sports wagering license. The published per curiam opinion is one sentence. The reasoning is spread across three separate opinions, and no two judges agreed on it.
Judge Roger Gregory found that federal commodities law does not clearly displace Maryland's authority over gambling even if Kalshi's contracts are swaps. Judge Stephanie Thacker found that the contracts are not swaps and that 'What is happening here is sports betting.' Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented on both points. Maryland had agreed in August 2025 to forgo enforcement pending the appeal, according to Kalshi's filing withdrawing its request for an injunction while the appeal was heard. The ruling makes the Fourth Circuit the third court of appeals to rule against Kalshi's preemption position, after the Sixth and Ninth, against one, the Third, in its favor.
Three opinions, one judgment
Judge Gregory's concurrence treats the appeal as 'a narrow question of federal preemption' and declines to decide whether sports event contracts are swaps. The Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC 'exclusive jurisdiction' over swaps traded on a designated contract market, but the same Act's 'Special Rule' lets the CFTC find event contracts that involve gaming contrary to the public interest and bar them from any registered entity, and the CFTC's only final rule implementing it, Rule 40.11, says a contract market 'shall not list for trading' a contract that 'involves, relates to, or references' gaming. Congress and the CFTC, he writes, have never said what jurisdictional significance a self-certified gaming contract has while it keeps trading, and the agency's March and June 2026 proposals to amend Rule 40.11 'expressly acknowledged uncertainty' and remain pending. Because gambling regulation is a traditional state police power and the framework 'reasonably admits competing interpretations,' he applies the presumption against preemption. On conflict preemption he writes that Maryland's licensing and advertising rules 'leave Kalshi free to operate its federally regulated exchange' and that Kalshi 'cannot manufacture a conflict by choosing not to comply with one sovereign's otherwise valid regulatory requirements.'
Judge Thacker's concurrence in the judgment reaches the question Judge Gregory avoided. The CEA defines a swap by reference to payment 'dependent on the occurrence, nonoccurrence, or the extent of the occurrence of an event or contingency.' Reading 2010 dictionaries, she distinguishes an event from its outcome: a contract paying if a boxing match is cancelled turns on occurrence; a contract paying on who wins turns on outcome, and the dictionaries that define 'event' to include an outcome label that sense 'archaic.' Because the CEA makes it unlawful for a retail participant to enter a swap off an exchange, she adds, Kalshi's reading would mean 'nearly every off-market sports bet that has been placed over the better part of the past two decades' was illegal under federal law. She quotes Kalshi's past advertising, 'the first app for legal sports betting in all 50 states,' and counsel's statement at the May 7 argument: 'I don't dispute that a year ago we did advertise as sports betting.'
Judge Benjamin's dissent would hold that the contracts are swaps, because an outcome 'can be, and in fact often is, an event of its own' and because sporting outcomes have economic consequences for sponsors, broadcasters and hospitality businesses that could use the contracts to hedge. On that footing she reads the exclusive-jurisdiction clause as occupying the field of trading on a designated contract market, consistent with the Third Circuit. She would vacate the district court's order and remand for the remaining injunction factors, and proposes limits on the swap definition that would exclude parlays and proposition bets as 'pure speculation' that cannot reasonably be used to hedge.
How the case got here
The Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission and Agency sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on April 7, 2025, giving it fifteen days to stop offering sports wagering without the license Maryland requires. Kalshi sued the agencies, their officials and Attorney General Brown on April 21, 2025 and moved for a preliminary injunction. Judge Abelson denied the motion on August 1, 2025, assuming without deciding that the contracts are swaps and holding that Congress had not 'clearly and manifestly intended to strip states of their authority to regulate gambling.' Kalshi appealed the same day and asked for an injunction pending appeal. Its August 13, 2025 notice withdrawing that motion states that on August 12 it 'received written assurances from counsel for Defendants that Defendants would forgo enforcement of the relevant Maryland laws against Kalshi pending the outcome of Kalshi's pending appeal in the Fourth Circuit,' which 'rendered an injunction pending appeal unnecessary.' The district court denied the motion as moot the next day. Argument in the Fourth Circuit was held May 7, 2026. Nevada, Ohio, 36 other states and the District of Columbia, the American Gaming Association, tribal gaming associations and tribes and Better Markets filed as amici for Maryland; Paradigm Operations LP and Underdog Sports Holding, Inc. filed for Kalshi.
Where the circuits stand
Four courts of appeals have now ruled on Kalshi's preemption claim at the preliminary-injunction stage. The Sixth Circuit's September 25, 2026 opinion, which decided the Ohio and Tennessee appeals together, held that the contracts are not swaps and, in the alternative, that even if they were, the CEA 'neither expressly nor impliedly preempts' Ohio's or Tennessee's gambling laws; a motions panel of that court had denied Kalshi an injunction pending appeal on April 24. New Jersey's petition asking the Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit's ruling (No. 26-299) is pending, with Kalshi's response due December 7, 2026.
The CFTC has moved since the Fourth Circuit briefing closed. On October 9, 2026 it proposed to define 'swap' expressly to include event contracts, 'including those based on sports, politics, cultural, and weather-related events,' with comments due 30 days after Federal Register publication, and separately issued an interim final rule, effective on publication, excluding 'casino-style gambling products, including wagers placed on sportsbooks and casino games' from the definition. The proposal and the interim rule are separate actions with different statuses; neither is addressed in the opinion, which cites only the agency's March and June 2026 Rule 40.11 proposals.
| Circuit | Case | Decided | Result | Ground |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Third | Kalshiex LLC v. Flaherty (New Jersey) | Apr. 6, 2026 | For Kalshi | Sports event contracts are swaps; CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction preempts state gambling law. Supreme Court petition No. 26-299 pending. |
| Ninth | KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad (Nevada) | Aug. 28, 2026 | For the state | Contracts likely not swaps, so no preemption. Rehearing en banc denied Nov. 4, 2026. |
| Sixth | KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler; v. Orgel (Ohio, Tennessee) | Sept. 25, 2026 | For the states | Not swaps; alternatively, no express, field or conflict preemption even if swaps. Motions panel denied injunction pending appeal Apr. 24, 2026. |
| Fourth | Kalshiex LLC v. Martin (Maryland) | Nov. 18, 2026 | For the state | Per curiam. Gregory: no clear preemption even if swaps. Thacker: not swaps. Benjamin, dissenting: swaps and field preemption. |
Appellate rulings on Kalshi's claim that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state sports wagering law, all at the preliminary-injunction stage. Sources: the Fourth and Sixth Circuit opinions read by AltStreet; the Third and Ninth Circuit entries as described in those opinions and on the dockets.
Why it matters
For a Kalshi user in Maryland, the change is in posture rather than in any order. Maryland had agreed to forgo enforcement pending the outcome of the appeal, according to Kalshi's August 2025 filing. The appellate opinion does not specify an enforcement deadline, and AltStreet has not verified whether that assurance has been extended or whether further relief has been requested. The Attorney General's statement describes the outcome as Kalshi having to 'meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook' and announces no action. Kalshi's options include a petition for rehearing en banc, a petition to the Supreme Court or litigating the merits in the district court, where the case remains open. The CFTC's August 11, 2026 emergency order directing Kalshi to keep operating addressed New York, not Maryland.
The division involves two distinct questions: whether sports event contracts qualify as swaps, and whether federal law displaces state gambling regulation even when they do. The Fourth Circuit's separate opinions expose that distinction, while the Sixth Circuit has rejected Kalshi's position on both grounds. Kalshi reads the same division the other way. 'Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong,' a spokesperson told InGame. 'This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.' The CFTC's October 9 proposal, if adopted, would answer the first question by rule and leave the second to the courts.
See the opportunity. Understand the risk.
Get the latest on Kalshi
Follow the latest on Kalshi, discover new deals, and keep an eye on the risks. Get market news, platform updates, and independent research that helps you see beyond the pitch, delivered to your inbox.
Make your next move an informed one
Get the latest on Kalshi and the wider alternative markets. Join free.
Independent intelligence from AltStreet. No hype. No sponsor spin.
What this report does not cover
AltStreet read the Fourth Circuit's 59-page opinion, the Sixth Circuit's September 25 opinion, Kalshi's August 13, 2025 notice in the Maryland docket, the Attorney General's statement and the CFTC's two October 9 releases. It has not read the parties' briefs, the amicus briefs, the oral argument recording, the Third and Ninth Circuit opinions or the district court decisions the opinion cites, and it has not read docket entries filed after November 8, 2026 in either Maryland docket. Kalshi's statement is as reported by InGame; AltStreet did not obtain it directly and has not asked Kalshi or the Maryland Attorney General's office to comment.
Sources
- Kalshiex LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892 (4th Cir. Nov. 18, 2026), published opinion (per curiam; Gregory, J., concurring; Thacker, J., concurring in the judgment; Benjamin, J., dissenting) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
- Statement from Attorney General Brown on Fourth Circuit Decision in Kalshi Case, November 18, 2026 — Office of the Attorney General of Maryland
- Notice of Withdrawal of Motion for Injunction Pending Appeal, Kalshiex LLC v. Martin, No. 1:25-cv-01283 (D. Md.), ECF No. 83, filed August 13, 2025 (copy hosted by InGame) — U.S. District Court, District of Maryland
- KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler; KalshiEX LLC v. Orgel, Nos. 26-3196/5235 (6th Cir. Sept. 25, 2026), published opinion — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, via GovInfo
- CFTC Seeks Public Comment on Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Concerning the Inclusion of Certain Event Contracts in the Definition of Swap (Release 9310-26, October 9, 2026) — Commodity Futures Trading Commission
- CFTC Issues Interim Final Rule Excluding Certain Activity from the Definition of Swap (Release 9309-26, October 9, 2026) — Commodity Futures Trading Commission
- Fourth Circuit Sides With Maryland Over Kalshi, But All Three Judges Differ On Key Questions (November 18, 2026; Kalshi spokesperson's statement) — InGame
- Kalshiex LLC v. John Martin, No. 25-1892 (4th Cir.), docket — CourtListener (RECAP)
- Kalshiex LLC v. Martin, No. 1:25-cv-01283 (D. Md.), docket — CourtListener (RECAP)
- Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, No. 26-299, Supreme Court docket — Supreme Court of the United States
- Kalshi litigation tracker — AltStreet Research
- Kalshi review — AltStreet Research
