tZERO
tZERO is the oldest regulated tokenized-securities venue in the United States: a FINRA broker-dealer running an SEC-regulated alternative trading system since 2019, a special purpose broker-dealer custodian approved in 2024, a transfer agent, and a placement agent for Reg D, Reg A+ and Reg CF token offerings. AltStreet read the FINRA trade data for its ATS, the audited FOCUS reports of both broker-dealers, the April 2026 consent solicitation that converted its own TZROP token, the parent's Beyond, Inc. filings, and the offering documents behind all sixteen deals on its offerings page. Three findings frame the review. The ATS traded $28.9 million of notional in 2022 and $1.6 million in the first seven months of 2026, and after the TZROP conversion in May 2026 the whole venue trades tens to a few thousand shares a week. The TZROP token carried a contingent dividend of 10% of adjusted gross revenue, subject to a profitability condition, and a $10 redemption floor; no dividend was ever declared in eight years, and holders voted in April 2026 to exchange both rights, and continuous trading, for 3 Series B preferred plus 8 common shares per token. And the two broker-dealers that carry customer money ended 2025 with $521,737 and $635,723 of net capital, above their regulatory minimums but small in absolute terms, 40% and 74% of their revenue respectively coming from the parent's own token, and a stated economic dependence on a parent whose last public audit carried a going-concern note.

No platform response on record for this review. Is this your platform? Respond or claim it.
What the data actually shows - TL;DR
tZERO is the most completely licensed tokenized-securities venue AltStreet has reviewed and among the least used. Founded inside Overstock.com in 2014, deconsolidated in 2021, and part-owned by Intercontinental Exchange since 2022, it holds a FINRA broker-dealer that operates an SEC-regulated ATS, a special purpose broker-dealer custodian approved in September 2024, a transfer agent, an exempt reporting adviser and a CFTC introducing broker.
Read the full assessmentShow less
FINRA's weekly data for the ATS, which tzero.com does not publish, shows notional volume falling from $28.9 million in 2022 to $5.9 million in 2025, 96% of it tZERO's own TZROP token, and $1.6 million in 2026 through early August, with the venue reporting tens to a few thousand shares a week after TZROP converted in May 2026. That conversion is the governance record: a token sold to 920 investors for $75.9 million with a contingent 10% revenue dividend and a $10 redemption floor, the dividend never declared, exchanged in April 2026 for 3 preferred plus 8 common shares per token, with Dahn Consulting separately estimating one token as equivalent to 1.13 preferred or 2.76 common. The offerings shelf tZERO fills as placement agent is sixteen cards; the filed outcomes run from $466,520 raised down to zero sold, six of the sixteen (five prior, one current) have no EDGAR filing under their card names, and every deal's financials tab says 'coming soon'. Both customer-facing broker-dealers hold under $650,000 of net capital, above their regulatory minimums but small in absolute terms, earn 40% and 74% of their revenue respectively from the parent's own token, and disclose economic dependence on a parent whose last public audit carried a going-concern note.
tZERO ATS notional traded per FINRA weekly data (MPID PROS): $28.9M in 2022, $9.5M in 2023, $6.0M in 2024, $5.9M in 2025, $1.6M in 2026 through the week of August 3. TZROP was 96% of 2025 notional and last traded the week of May 4, 2026.
TZROP's contingent 10% adjusted-gross-revenue dividend was never declared, per the April 2026 consent statement. Holders approved (84.6% of votes cast, 72.2% turnout) converting each TZROP into 3 Series B preferred plus 8 common (Dahn Consulting separately estimated one TZROP as 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common), and gave up the $10 redemption floor and continuous trading.
Net capital of tZERO Securities and tZERO Digital Asset Securities at December 31, 2025, on revenue of $418,088 and $204,121; TZROP supplied 40% and 74% of that revenue. Both audits state economic dependence on the parent for funding.
Offerings on tzero.com/trade: four current (CarbonEnfo BRYTR, Kondoo Digital, KNOWPIA, C3 Bullion) and twelve prior. Six of the sixteen cards (five prior, plus current Kondoo) have no SEC filing under their names. Filed outcomes: Overstock IP token $466,520, buybuy BABY token $395,920, Aurox $327,356, Spirits Capital $0 of a $35M qualified Reg A+.
The only regulatory action on record: the SEC's January 2022 order finding tZERO ATS willfully violated Regulation ATS by sharing order-book data with two third parties without timely Form ATS disclosure and lacking written fair-access standards. Cease-and-desist, censure, penalty paid; the sole BrokerCheck disclosure on CRD 123421.
FINRA OTC Transparency weekly ATS data (MPID PROS, 2022 to August 2026), X-17A-5 statements of financial condition FY2024 and FY2025 for CIK 1193821 and CIK 1909301, the TZROP Consent Solicitation Statement (April 7, 2026) and results release (April 29, 2026), Beyond, Inc. 10-K FY2022/FY2024/FY2025 and Q2 2026 10-Q with tZERO Group's Rule 3-09 audited statements, SEC File 3-20699, EDGAR filings for all sixteen listed issuers, seven offering documents ingested, a 122-page tzero.com capture and platform screenshots. September 2026.
AltStreet Weekly
Track the filings behind the tokens
AltStreet ingested every offering document, Form D, Form C-U and broker-dealer FOCUS report behind tZERO's sixteen listed deals, plus the FINRA volume series for its ATS. Get notified as new filings, amendments and trading prints land.
Free during beta. Filing-grounded data, no platform marketing.
What's Actually Happening
In plain English, here is what is actually happening.
- 1tZERO is a Salt Lake City and Jersey City company, born inside Overstock.com in 2014, that runs the plumbing for tokenized securities: a licensed brokerage, a licensed trading venue (the ATS), a licensed custodian for digital securities, and a transfer agent that keeps the shareholder register on a blockchain.
- 2Companies pay tZERO to sell their tokens to investors (the primary market) and can later list those tokens on the ATS so investors can trade them with each other (the secondary market). Investors pay 1% per trade and up to 7% on a primary subscription.
- 3The secondary market is very small. In 2025 it traded $5.9 million all year, 96% of it tZERO's own TZROP token. TZROP converted into ordinary stock in May 2026 and stopped trading. In the weeks since, the whole venue has traded a few hundred to a few thousand shares a week.
- 4TZROP was sold in 2017 and 2018 with a dividend of 10% of adjusted gross revenue that applied only if the company was profitable enough, plus a $10 buyback floor. No dividend was ever declared. In April 2026 holders voted to swap each token for 3 preferred and 8 common shares of tZERO (the company's consultant had separately put one token at 1.13 preferred or 2.76 common) and to give up the floor and daily trading.
- 5The offerings page lists sixteen deals. The ones with SEC filings raised between nothing (Spirits Capital, $35 million qualified, zero sold) and $466,520 (an Overstock brand token). Six of the sixteen deals, five prior and the current Kondoo offering, have no SEC filing under their names. Every deal's financials tab on the platform says 'coming soon'.
- 6The two licensed subsidiaries that hold customer cash and tokens are small: about $520,000 and $640,000 of regulatory net capital, above their minimums but small in absolute terms, with 40% and 74% of their revenue respectively from the parent's own token, and both say they depend on the parent, which lost $29.5 million in its last public year and carried a going-concern note.
Quick Verdict
Is this platform right for you?
tZERO is genuine regulated infrastructure with a decade of licenses and no market to speak of. The ATS is real and has traded since 2019; it has also lost 95% of its notional volume since 2022 and was, until May 2026, mostly a venue for tZERO's own token.
Read the full assessmentShow less
The custodian is a special purpose broker-dealer approved to hold digital asset securities (one of two, by the company's account); it holds $635,723 of net capital and earns three quarters of its revenue from the parent. The placement business fills a shelf of sixteen small offerings whose filed outcomes are weak and whose platform financials read 'coming soon'. The parent has raised about $200 million, lost $29.5 million in its last public year with a going-concern note, converted its retail token into Series B preferred and common in April 2026, and is now courting ICE and a 2026 IPO. Investors should treat tZERO as plumbing: use it if an issuer you have underwritten from the filing requires it, expect no liquidity, and hold what you can outside the affiliate custodian.
Best for
- Accredited investors who have underwritten a specific token issuer from its own PPM and Form D and need a licensed US venue to subscribe and custody through
- Holders of tokens already on the ATS (Aspen Digital, Curzio, EnergyFunders, the Overstock and buybuy BABY brand tokens) who want the only regulated venue where those securities can trade
- Issuers weighing a compliant token raise who want a bundled placement agent, escrow, custodian, transfer agent and ATS, and can afford the fee stack
- Analysts of tokenized-securities market structure: tZERO's FINRA data and FOCUS reports are the most complete public record of a US security-token ATS
Avoid if
- You expect to be able to sell: the venue traded $1.6 million of notional in seven months of 2026 and prints zero volume on most listings most days
- You are buying a tZERO-placed token for its contingent revenue share without reading the issuer's financials; the shelf's filed history runs from zero sold to going-concern warnings
- You assume the licenses imply balance-sheet strength; the broker-dealers hold under $650,000 of net capital each and depend on a parent that has never been profitable
- You treat the platform's deal page, its 'valuation cap' field or its 'leading ATS' language as disclosure; the filings, where they exist, are the disclosure
Top strengths
- The regulatory stack is complete and verifiable: SEC-regulated ATS operated by a FINRA member since 2019, special purpose broker-dealer custody approved September 2024, SEC-registered transfer agent, FINRA approval for corporate debt (September 2025), CFTC introducing broker, and a documented patent portfolio licensed to ICE in August 2026
- Unusually good public financial evidence for a private infrastructure company: two audited broker-dealer FOCUS reports a year with revenue and concentration notes, FINRA weekly trade data by symbol, a 163-page consent statement, and Rule 3-09 audited parent statements through FY2023
- Fee schedules are published in full on both sides: investors pay 1% per trade (or $0.03 a share under $3), up to 7% on primary subscriptions and no account or custody fees; issuer fees appear verbatim in the PPMs and Form Cs AltStreet read
- Offering documents for closed deals stay available on the platform, which many venues do not provide, and the two Beyond, Inc. brand tokens and Aurox filed their Form C-Us with the amount raised
Key limitations
- Secondary liquidity has collapsed: $28.9M (2022) to $5.9M (2025, 96% TZROP) to tens or hundreds of shares a week after May 2026; the screen on September 12, 2026 showed zero volume on all six visible listings with bid-ask gaps such as $1.10 against $2.40
- The TZROP record: a contingent 10% revenue dividend never declared in eight years, a $10 redemption floor and continuous trading exchanged in April 2026 for 3 Series B plus 8 common per token (Dahn: 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common equivalence), with the largest shareholder (Beyond) holding 3 million TZROP and offering the follow-on financing
- Small, dependent broker-dealers: net capital $521,737 and $635,723 at end-2025 (excess $271,737 and $385,723 over their minimums), revenue $418,088 and $204,121 with 40% and 74% from TZROP, economic dependence on the parent disclosed, a material-weakness flag on the FY2023 FOCUS filing, and a willful Regulation ATS violation settled for $800,000 in 2022
- The placement shelf is small and its filed outcomes weak: Spirits Capital's $35M qualified Reg A+ sold nothing; KNOWPIA's Form D has reported zero sold since 2023 while its PPM carries going-concern language; six of sixteen cards (five prior, one current) have no EDGAR filing under their names; every deal's Financials tab reads 'coming soon'
Where It Fits
Where tZERO fits relative to the alternatives.
Regulated tokenized-securities venue
If you want
Buy or trade a security token that lives on a US broker-dealer's ATS with a licensed custodian
Use
tZERO: primary placement plus the tZERO Securities ATS and tZERO Digital Asset Securities custody
Tokenized fund infrastructure
If you want
Hold tokenized shares of institutional funds (Treasury funds, private credit feeders)
Use
Securitize: transfer agent, broker-dealer and ATS behind BUIDL, Hamilton Lane and Apollo feeders
Conventional alt-platform plumbing
If you want
Escrow, custody and a secondary bulletin board behind a crowdfunding or real-estate platform
Use
North Capital: carrying broker-dealer, escrow and the PPEX ATS
Compare Before Deciding
How tZERO compares
tZERO's comparables are the other regulated plumbing behind tokenized and private securities: a fund tokenizer, a carrying broker-dealer and an issuer-side raise stack.
The tokenized-fund counterpart
Securitize
Transfer agent, broker-dealer and ATS behind BlackRock's BUIDL and the Hamilton Lane, Apollo and KKR feeders: institutional product on a clean record, where tZERO has licenses and a thin shelf.
The carrying broker-dealer benchmark
North Capital
Escrow, custody and the PPEX ATS for conventional alt platforms, with customer-money capital an order of magnitude above tZERO's affiliates.
The placement-agent comparison
DealMaker
Issuer-side raise technology and broker of record, no venue: the benchmark for tZERO's placement fees and the raise volumes its shelf does not reach.
Quick Answers
What most investors want to know first
The highest-signal facts first: minimums, liquidity reality, K-1 timing, and whether distributions are actually part of the experience.
Liquidity
Six listings on September 12, 2026, zero volume on every visible row, quoted gaps of 5% to 118% of the bid, and a 'last' price that may be an issuer-struck NAV rather than a trade. The regulated venue is genuine; the market is not.
K-1 Timing
Issuer-dependent; the BRYTR PPM promises annual reports within 120 days of fiscal year end but sets no K-1 deadline; corporate tokens issue no K-1.
Distributions
BRYTR: within 10 business days of the first day of the quarter after CarbonEnfo receives the revenue, in stablecoin to staked tokens. KNOWPIA: declared at the board's discretion on the last day of the second month after each quarter, paid within five days. TZROP: quarterly if declared; never declared.
Overview
Platform Overview
A concise read on what the platform is, how the structure works, and where the practical friction shows up for real investors.
Regulated infrastructure for tokenized securities. tZERO Group, Inc. (Delaware; formerly t0.com, Inc.; founded 2014 inside Overstock.com, deconsolidated April 23, 2021; offices at 10 West Broadway, Salt Lake City and 525 Washington Blvd, Jersey City; CEO and chairman Alan Konevsky since September 2025; more than 50 employees and about $200 million raised per Bloomberg, October 2025) owns tZERO Securities, LLC (FINRA CRD 123421, SEC 8-65585; formerly tZERO ATS, LLC and PRO Securities), a self-clearing broker-dealer that operates the tZERO Securities ATS for digital asset securities, acts as placement agent, broker of record and escrow agent on token offerings under Reg D, Reg A+ and Reg CF, and was approved in September 2025 to trade corporate debt; tZERO Digital Asset Securities, LLC (CRD 316189), a special purpose broker-dealer approved September 2024 to custody, clear and settle digital asset securities; tZERO Technologies, LLC, which runs the issuance and tokenization platform; an SEC-registered transfer agent; tZERO Capital Partners, LLC (exempt reporting adviser, Utah); and tZERO Introducing Broker, LLC (CFTC introducing broker). Investors pay 1% per ATS trade, or $0.03 a share on securities under $3, up to 7% on primary subscriptions, and no account, custody or maintenance fees at retail. Issuers pay a placement stack documented in their PPMs (4% plus 1% of gross, fixed advisory, escrow, setup, monthly, per-investor, custody and smart-contract fees). tZERO holds no investor product of its own since the TZROP conversion; its listed securities are issued by third parties and two Beyond, Inc. subsidiaries.
tZERO is a licensed brokerage, custodian, transfer agent and ATS operator for tokenized securities, born inside Overstock.com in 2014 and now 22% directly owned by Beyond (38.7% with Beyond's indirect stake) with ICE as a significant minority shareholder. Its ATS is the longest-running regulated venue for security tokens in the United States and, per FINRA, one of the least traded: $5.9 million of notional in 2025, almost all of it tZERO's own TZROP, and tens to thousands of shares a week since TZROP converted in May 2026. That conversion ended an eight-year token in which the contingent dividend was never declared and the $10 floor and continuous trading were voted away for 3 Series B plus 8 common per token; the company's consultant separately estimated one token as 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common.
The placement shelf is sixteen offerings whose filed outcomes range from $466,520 to zero and whose current issuers describe themselves as pre-revenue, going-concern or utility-token businesses. The two broker-dealers investors deal with are small in absolute terms, above their regulatory minimums, TZROP-dependent and reliant on a loss-making parent. The investor's defense is the same as everywhere in tokenized markets: the issuer's filing and the FINRA print, not the venue's brochure.
What tZERO Is
Regulated tokenized-securities infrastructure: FINRA broker-dealer + SEC-regulated ATS (since 2019) + special purpose broker-dealer custodian (Sept 2024) + SEC transfer agent + issuance platform + exempt adviser + CFTC introducing broker
Corporate Structure
tZERO Group, Inc. (DE; formerly t0.com; Salt Lake City and Jersey City) owns tZERO Securities, LLC (CRD 123421), tZERO Digital Asset Securities, LLC (CRD 316189), tZERO Technologies, LLC, tZERO Capital Partners, LLC, tZERO Introducing Broker, LLC; tZERO Markets, LLC (CRD 304537) terminated December 2024
Ownership
Beyond, Inc. 22% direct at June 30, 2026 (38.7% with its indirect stake via Medici Ventures), equity-method mark $15.5M at FY2025; Intercontinental Exchange significant minority since the February 2022 Series B; 140.9M Series B shares; former TZROP holders 30.6% fully diluted post-conversion
Leadership
Alan Konevsky, CEO since Sept 4, 2025 (styled chairman and CEO Aug 2026); David Goone CEO Feb 2022 to Sept 2025; Saum Noursalehi CEO 2018 to Aug 2021; Matt Mosman chairman (Sept 2025); Vanessa Savino chief legal officer
Regulatory Record
SEC File 3-20699 (Jan 10, 2022): willful Reg ATS violations, $800,000 penalty, censure (sole BrokerCheck disclosure); SEC investigations of the TZROP offering and Overstock's 2019 dividend disclosed 2018 to 2023, no order, no closing letter; FY2023 FOCUS material-weakness flag; Securitize v. tZERO patent case (D. Del. 1:26-cv-00722, June 2026) pending
ATS Volume (FINRA, MPID PROS)
2022: 4.76M shares / $28.9M · 2023: 3.31M / $9.5M · 2024: 2.53M / $6.0M · 2025: 1.89M / $5.9M (TZROP 96%) · 2026 to Aug 3: 0.92M / $1.6M · post-TZROP weeks: 32 to 3,917 shares
Broker-Dealer Capital (Dec 31, 2025)
tZERO Securities: net capital $521,737 (excess $271,737), revenue $418,088 + $202,666 interest, TZROP 40% / DASN 21%, equity $671,418 · tZERO DAS: net capital $635,723 (excess $385,723), revenue $204,121, TZROP 74%, equity $745,505 · both: economic dependence on parent
Parent Financials (last public, FY2023)
Revenue $1.63M (FY2022 $2.49M) · employee compensation $11.8M · net loss $29.5M (FY2022 $38.6M) · cash $43.2M · going-concern note (FY2022 and FY2023 audits) · Bloomberg Oct 2025: 50+ staff, unprofitable, ~$200M raised, 2026 IPO plan
TZROP
506(c) 2017 to 2018: $250M offered, $75.9M sold to 920 investors; contingent 10% adjusted-gross-revenue dividend never declared; $10 redemption floor; converted May 2026 at 3 Series B + 8 common per token (Dahn separately: 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common equivalence) with 84.6% of votes cast in favor; semi-annual auctions replace continuous trading
Investor Fees (Sept 4, 2026 schedule)
1% per trade, or $0.03 a share under $3.00 · up to 7% processing fee on primary subscriptions · no account, maintenance, inactivity or retail custody fees · $25 domestic / $50 international wire · debit balances Fed Funds + 125 bps · ACH held 15 business days
Issuer Fees (BRYTR PPM, April 2026)
4% placement + 1% broker of record on gross · $25,000 advisory · $1,000 escrow · $10,000 setup + $2,000/month + $20 per investor (tZERO Technologies) · 35 bps custody with $1,500/month minimum + $7,500 smart-contract assessment (tZERO DAS) · expenses capped $50,000 · KNOWPIA: 2% + $25,000; Reg CF: 1% + $25,000 + $1,000
Offerings Shelf (Sept 12, 2026)
Current: CarbonEnfo BRYTR ($4.5M, 506c, $10k min), Kondoo Digital (506c, $100k min, no Form D), KNOWPIA ($3M, 506c, $10k min), C3 Bullion ($40M Reg A+, inactive) · Prior: Quarter Homes, Spirits Capital, Aurox, TZROP, Overstock IP token, Digital Prime, Park Street/Tuscany, RSRV Aspen, FINTECH.TV, McNeill, Invest Inc., Emmis Capital
Secondary Listings (Sept 12, 2026 screen)
ASPD Aspen Digital ($2.50 last, $1.10/$2.40), OTKNP Overstock IP token ($6.50, $5.50/$7.49), CURZ Curzio ($0.75, $0.01/$0.75), ENFD EnergyFunders ($1.75, $1.30/$1.75), GLDX Streamex, NXHBP buybuy BABY ($9.15, $7.00/$9.15); volume 0 on every row
Visual Summary
tZERO vs. Key Alternatives
How tZERO compares with the other regulated infrastructure behind tokenized and private securities in AltStreet's coverage.
Model
tZERO: BD + ATS + SPBD custodian + transfer agent + placement agent for third-party tokens · Securitize: transfer agent + BD + ATS behind institutional tokenized funds · North Capital: carrying BD, escrow, PPEX ATS for alt platforms · DealMaker: issuer-side raise technology + broker of record
Secondary venue
tZERO: SEC-regulated ATS since 2019, $5.9M notional 2025, tens to thousands of shares/week since May 2026 · Securitize: Securitize Markets ATS, thin · North Capital: PPEX ATS, thin · DealMaker: none
Custody
tZERO: affiliate SPBD (one of two approved, by the company's account), $635,723 net capital, SIPC caveat · Securitize: transfer-agent registry, funds hold assets · North Capital: carrying BD with segregated customer cash · DealMaker: issuer-side, none
Investor fees
tZERO: 1% per trade, up to 7% primary processing, no account fees · Securitize: none at retail on most funds · North Capital: platform-dependent · DealMaker: none to investors
Own-token history
tZERO: TZROP, dividend never paid, converted April 2026 · Securitize: none · North Capital: none · DealMaker: none
Regulatory record
tZERO: SEC 2022 $800K willful Reg ATS order · Securitize: clean · North Capital: one resolved $40K AWC (2024) · DealMaker: zero disclosures
ASEconomic Positioning
- tZERO earns from issuers (placement, setup, monthly, per-investor, custody and smart-contract fees) and from investors (1% commissions, 7% processing fees) on a shelf whose filed raises total well under $2 million outside the parent's own token and Beyond's brand tokens. The FY2025 FOCUS notes make the dependence explicit: 61% of tZERO Securities' revenue and 100% of the custodian's came from two clients, the parent's TZROP and an entity coded DASN.
- The TZROP conversion removed the venue's only liquid listing and the revenue it generated (custody, transfer-agent and trading fees on a 21-million-token float), replacing continuous trading with semi-annual auctions. FY2026 will be the first year in which both broker-dealers must earn from third-party issuers or the parent's subsidies alone.
- The strategic bet is institutional: the ICE memorandum (August 2026), the Siebert and Sui integrations, corporate-debt approval, the CFTC applications and a 2026 IPO plan all point at infrastructure sold to banks and exchanges rather than at the retail shelf on tzero.com/trade. If that bet pays, the retail venue is a showroom; if it does not, the parent's funding history (going-concern notes, a $10 million insider note, undisclosed ICE money) is the constraint.
- Against Securitize, tZERO has more licenses and less product: Securitize's shelf is BlackRock, Hamilton Lane, Apollo and KKR feeders with billions in tokenized assets; tZERO's is a solar-credit SPV, a Swiss gaming token and two Overstock brand tokens. Against North Capital and DealMaker, tZERO's disclosure is better (public FOCUS revenue notes, FINRA symbol data) and its record worse (a willful SEC order, a restructured own token).
Key Gaps & Non-Disclosures
- No ATS volume or listing statistics on tzero.com; FINRA data only, under a legacy MPID.
- No tZERO Group financials after FY2023; no broker-dealer income statements.
- No investor-outcome data for any placed offering; the platform's Financials tabs read 'coming soon'.
- ICE's ownership and investment amounts, and the funding status of the Beyond convertible note, undisclosed.
Platform Intelligence
tZERO Milestones (AltStreet filing-tracked)
Key platform events, regulatory turns, liquidity stress points, and product launches that shape how the review should be read.
Formed inside Overstock.com
Overstock's Medici / t0 unit begins building blockchain trading infrastructure; the broker-dealer that becomes tZERO Securities (PRO Securities, CRD 123421) is acquired for the purpose.
TZROP token raise closes at $75.9M from 920 investors
The Series A preferred token sold under Rule 506(c) ($250M offered) with a contingent 10% adjusted-gross-revenue dividend and a $10 redemption floor; the SEC's Division of Enforcement had opened an investigation of the offering in February 2018.
ATS opens to security tokens; Overstock dividend draws subpoenas
The tZERO ATS begins trading TZROP and Overstock's Series A-1 digital dividend; the SEC subpoenas Overstock in October and December 2019. Securities class actions against Overstock over the dividend are later dismissed and affirmed (Tenth Circuit, October 2024).
Overstock deconsolidates tZERO
Control passes to Medici Ventures, L.P. (Pelion) on April 23, 2021; Overstock books a $243.5M gain and carries its direct stake at fair value. The ATS ceases NMS-stock operations in June 2021 and continues as a tokenized venue.
SEC order: $800,000 for willful Regulation ATS violations
File 3-20699: order-book information shared with two third parties without timely Form ATS disclosure and no written fair-access standards; cease-and-desist, censure, penalty. The sole BrokerCheck disclosure on CRD 123421. A month later ICE leads the Series B ($70.6M net raised in 2022).
Retrenchment: crypto app shut, BSTX written off, going-concern audits
tZERO Crypto closes March 2023; the Boston Security Token Exchange venture is written off ($8.1M); tZERO Markets' banking business folds into the broker-dealer. FY2022 and FY2023 audits carry going-concern language; FY2023 revenue $1.63M, net loss $29.5M.
Special purpose broker-dealer custody approved
tZERO Digital Asset Securities is approved by the SEC and FINRA to custody digital asset securities, one of two such firms by the company's account. tZERO Markets' registration is terminated in December 2024. ATS notional for the year: $6.0M.
New CEO, corporate-debt approval, CFTC applications, IPO talk
Alan Konevsky succeeds David Goone; FINRA approves corporate-debt trading; DCO and DCM applications go to the CFTC; Bloomberg reports a 2026 IPO plan, 50+ employees and about $200M raised. ATS notional for the year: $5.9M, 96% TZROP.
TZROP holders approve conversion into Series B and common
Consent solicitation of April 7, enhanced April 16 to 3 Series B plus 8 common per TZROP (Dahn separately: 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common equivalence); approved April 29 with 84.6% of votes cast; the $10 floor, the never-declared dividend and continuous trading are surrendered. TZROP's last trading week is May 4; the venue's volume collapses to tens of shares.
ICE memorandum; AltStreet data layer built
ICE signs a design-partner and patent-license memorandum (August 31) with an undisclosed investment; Securitize's patent suit (June) is pending. AltStreet ingests all sixteen offering cards, eight offering documents, the FOCUS reports and the FINRA series in September 2026.
Mental Model
How tZERO actually works, simplified.
An issuer hires tZERO to tokenize and sell a security
tZERO Securities acts as placement agent, broker of record and escrow agent; tZERO Technologies runs the issuance platform; tZERO Digital Asset Securities assesses the smart contract and custodies the token; the transfer agent keeps the register. The BRYTR PPM prices the stack: 4% placement plus 1% broker-of-record on gross proceeds, $25,000 advisory, $1,000 escrow, $10,000 setup, $2,000 a month, $20 per investor, 35 basis points a year of custody with a $1,500 monthly minimum, and $7,500 per smart contract.
Investors subscribe on platform.tzero.com
Accredited investors (Reg D) or anyone (Reg A+, Reg CF) open a brokerage account with tZERO Securities, verify status, and subscribe. Funds sit in a segregated escrow account until closing. tZERO may charge a non-refundable processing fee of up to 7% per commitment. The deal page shows regulation, structure, a 'valuation cap', minimum and maximum, and a closing date; the Financials tab reads 'coming soon' on every deal AltStreet checked.
Tokens settle to the custodian and may list on the ATS
Digital asset securities are carried by tZERO Digital Asset Securities, which controls the wallets and private keys; some tokens can move to a third-party custodian or a self-hosted wallet. After holding periods the issuer may list on the tZERO Securities ATS, where orders are entered 23.5 hours a day and settle on trade. Listing is at tZERO's discretion, and no PPM AltStreet read guarantees it.
Trading happens if there is a counterparty, which usually there is not
FINRA's weekly data is the only volume record. In 2025 the ATS traded 1.9 million shares for $5.9 million; TZROP alone was 1.6 million shares and $5.6 million. Since TZROP's last week (May 4, 2026) the venue has reported 32 to 3,917 shares a week across Aspen Digital, Curzio, EnergyFunders and the Overstock token, with wide quoted gaps and zero volume on the screen most days.
Investor Operations
The practical questions investors actually care about: when tax documents arrive, how cash distributions work, and whether capital can be exited before the underlying asset is sold.
Tax Documents
K-1 Timing
What to expect
Issuer-dependent; the BRYTR PPM promises annual reports within 120 days of fiscal year end but sets no K-1 deadline; corporate tokens issue no K-1.
Confidence: Medium
Cash Flow
Distributions
Frequency
issuer-dependent; quarterly where provided for
Timing
BRYTR: within 10 business days of the first day of the quarter after CarbonEnfo receives the revenue, in stablecoin to staked tokens. KNOWPIA: declared at the board's discretion on the last day of the second month after each quarter, paid within five days. TZROP: quarterly if declared; never declared.
Consistency
No tZERO-placed token in AltStreet's data layer has a public record of cash distributions. TZROP's eight-year record is zero; BRYTR and KNOWPIA have not yet closed.
Liquidity
Exit Reality
Holding period
Contractual and practical: Reg D tokens carry one-year Rule 144 restrictions plus issuer whitelists; the ATS provides a venue with almost no trading.
Exit options
- Sell on the tZERO Securities ATS, 23.5 hours a day on business days, T+0 settlement, 1% commission; FINRA data shows tens to a few thousand shares a week across the whole venue since May 2026.
- Semi-annual liquidity auctions on the ATS for the former TZROP (now Series B preferred) and, per the platform's description, for other issuers that choose the format.
- Issuer events: BRYTR's company call option to mature tokens at 3x less distributions paid; KNOWPIA's redemption provisions; corporate sale or dissolution.
- Transfer to a self-hosted wallet or third-party custodian where the issuer permits, for private sale to a whitelisted accredited buyer.
Secondary market
Six listings on September 12, 2026, zero volume on every visible row, quoted gaps of 5% to 118% of the bid, and a 'last' price that may be an issuer-struck NAV rather than a trade. The regulated venue is genuine; the market is not.
Confidence: High
Investment Structures
Revenue-Participation Tokens in an LLC (BRYTR, LLC / CarbonEnfo)
The most developed current offering: 4,500,000 tokens at $1.00, each an LLC unit in a Delaware SPV holding a contractual right to 12% of CarbonEnfo's Net Platform Revenue from solar renewable energy certificate sales, paid quarterly in a USD stablecoin to staked tokens on Cardano, capped at $3.00 per token cumulative, non-voting, no inspection rights, taxed as a partnership (K-1). Rule 506(c), $10,000 minimum, no minimum raise, continuous offering. CarbonEnfo at December 31, 2025 (SSARS review, not an audit): about $49,000 of cash, $693,617 of assets, $2.12 million of liabilities, a $1.42 million deficit, a $598,534 net loss and no material revenue; a $1.5 million 10% convertible note to Cox Investment Holdings due September 2027; related-party balances with the CEO's other company and bookkeeping by a firm whose principal is the CEO's spouse.
Management projects net platform revenue of $1.0 million in 2026 rising to $55.7 million in 2031. The Form D of April 17, 2026 reports nothing sold.
Tokenized Preferred Stock of Early-Stage Companies (KNOWPIA, the Beyond brand tokens, TZROP)
KNOWPIA Inc. offers up to 300 million preferred shares at $0.01 (maximum $3 million, $1 million part-or-none minimum) with a discretionary, non-cumulative dividend intended at 10% of gross profit only if quarterly GAAP net income exceeds it, a $0.01 liquidation preference, no votes, and the company as its own transfer agent; the PPM says liabilities are past due and the company may fail without the raise. Commercial Strategies, Inc. (Overstock IP token, OTKNP) and Zion Peaks, Inc. (buybuy BABY token, NXHBP) sold Reg CF preferred at $5.00 to Beyond stockholders and $10.00 to others, raising $466,520 and $395,920 in 2025; both trade on the ATS with zero volume on September 12, 2026. TZROP, the precedent, carried a contingent 10% of adjusted gross revenue and never declared it.
Utility-Style Tokens Sold as Securities (Kondoo Digital GmbH Amana token)
400 million Amana tokens of 1 billion authorized, on Solana, at $1.44 to $1.56 by subscription tier, $100,000 minimum, no minimum raise, sold by a Swiss GmbH in Zug under Rule 506(c). The token is a payment unit inside a gaming ecosystem that does not yet operate; staking rewards begin only if the company later concludes the token is no longer a security; holders have no equity, debt, dividend, information or corporate voting rights; 70 million tokens were pre-issued to founders and developers; 5% of gross proceeds is distributed to the owners; about EUR 200,000 of founder advances is repaid from proceeds. No Form D on EDGAR under Kondoo.
Reg A+ and Reg CF Common Stock (C3 Bullion, Spirits Capital, Aurox, FINTECH.TV, Invest Inc.)
Conventional retail equity raises run through tZERO as placement agent, broker of record or escrow agent. C3 Bullion: $40 million at $5.00, $500 minimum, going-concern paragraph, FY2024 net loss $821,257 on no revenue, CEO resigned October 2025, a July 2026 settlement canceled 4.95 million shares, listing inactive. Spirits Capital: $35 million qualified November 2023, zero sold per the 2024 Form 1-Z.
Aurox: $327,356 of Reg CF commitments in March 2023 for a crypto trading terminal that had lost $3.07 million since inception. FINTECH.TV: a $10,000 Reg CF target with no Form C-U. Invest Inc.: Reg A+ qualified May 2023, officers resigned October 2023, no 1-K since.
Real-Asset Perk Equity and Unfiled Prior Offerings (RSRV Aspen, Quarter Homes, Park Street, McNeill, Emmis)
Prior cards with platform screen terms and no SEC filing under the card name: RSRV Aspen, LLC (common stock, $16 million 'valuation cap', $25,000 minimum, closed November 21, 2024, discounted St. Regis Aspen room rates in perpetuity as the investor benefit; distinct from Aspen Digital, Inc., whose ASPD token trades on the ATS), Quarter Homes (co-ownership home financing, $147.2 million shown as both valuation cap and 100%-funded goal, $50,000 minimum, closed April 20, 2026), Park Street Development Group's Tuscany National Resort & Club in Cortona, Italy, McNeill Investment Group (hospitality real estate) and Emmis Capital (bridge financing for exchange listings). Issuer legal names, raise sizes and outcomes for these five are not established from any public record.
Risk
Risk Structure
This is where the marketplace pitch gives way to the actual operating reality: delayed exits, limited disclosure, fee drag, and path-dependent outcomes.
A Regulated Venue Without a Market
The ATS is real, licensed and, per FINRA, nearly empty. Notional fell from $28.9 million (2022) to $5.9 million (2025), of which 96% was the operator's own token; since that token converted in May 2026 the venue reports 32 to 3,917 shares a week across five listings. Quoted spreads on the September 12, 2026 screen ran from 5% to 118% of the bid.
Every liquidity claim in tZERO's marketing ('continuous liquidity', 'Trade is Settlement') describes a mechanism, not a market. Investors should assume any tZERO-listed token is illiquid and that exit, if any, will come through the semi-annual auction format tZERO now uses for its own preferred.
The Own-Token Precedent
TZROP was sold to retail in 2017 and 2018 on a 10% revenue dividend and a $10 redemption floor. The dividend was conditioned on profitability the company never achieved and was never declared. In April 2026 the company solicited consent to convert each token into 3 Series B preferred plus 8 common (its consultant, Dahn, separately estimated one token as equivalent to 1.13 preferred or 2.76 common), and holders, most of whom had held for eight years with no income and a thinning market, approved it.
The structure was lawful and disclosed at length. It is also the clearest available case study of how a contingent revenue-linked token resolves when the issuer does not earn; it speaks to tZERO's governance of its own security, not to how third-party issuers on the venue will treat theirs.
Two Small, Dependent Broker-Dealers Between the Investor and the Asset
tZERO Securities ($521,737 net capital, $3.4 million due to customers, 40% of revenue from TZROP) and tZERO Digital Asset Securities ($635,723 net capital, 74% of revenue from TZROP) are the entities that hold subscription cash and carry tokens. Both audits disclose economic dependence on a parent whose last public statements carried a going-concern note. The custodian's Form CRS states that SIPA protections may not apply to digital asset securities. The regulatory framework (net capital, 15c3-3, the SPBD conditions) is the protection, and both firms were above their minimums at year end; the cushion behind it is small in absolute terms, and the parent's ability to fund it depends on financings that were non-binding or undisclosed at the review date.
Vertical Integration Across Every Role
Placement agent, broker of record, escrow agent, issuance platform, smart-contract assessor, custodian, transfer agent, accreditation verifier and sole trading venue are affiliates of one group, and until May 2026 the venue's dominant listing was the group's own security. Two of the three Reg CF raises tZERO Securities placed in 2025 were subsidiaries of Beyond, its largest shareholder, at Beyond's own address. The customer agreement and Forms CRS disclose the roles and the conflict that 'our ATS may be the only trading venue'. Disclosure does not remove the fact that the investor's every counterparty is the same firm.
A Placement Shelf of Pre-Revenue and Going-Concern Issuers
The current offerings describe, in their own documents, a marketplace with no material revenue (BRYTR), a company that may go out of business without the raise (KNOWPIA), a gaming ecosystem that does not yet operate (Kondoo) and a consulting business with a going-concern paragraph and a control change (C3 Bullion). The prior shelf's filed outcomes are $0 to $466,520. tZERO's placement fee (4% plus 1%, plus fixed charges) is earned on gross proceeds whatever happens next; none of the offering documents gives tZERO any duty to the investor beyond execution, escrow and the KYC and accreditation work its broker-dealer status requires.
Liquidity Risk on Every Listed Token
FINRA data shows the venue trading tens to a few thousand shares a week since May 2026; the screen shows zero volume and bid-ask gaps of up to 118% of the bid.
Why it matters
A regulated ATS with T+0 settlement still requires a buyer. Tokens issued through tZERO carry contractual transfer restrictions on top (BRYTR: whitelisted wallets; Kondoo: restricted securities with no listing commitment; KNOWPIA: one-year holding period), and the platform itself moved its own preferred to semi-annual auctions because continuous trading had no depth.
Mitigation / verification
Look up MPID PROS in FINRA's OTC transparency weekly ATS data before buying; note the weekly shares and notional for the symbol. Read the PPM's transfer section for whitelist and lock-up terms. Size the position as permanently illiquid and treat the quoted last price, which may be an issuer-struck NAV rather than a trade, as unreliable.
Issuer Performance Risk Dressed as Platform Legitimacy
The shelf's issuers are pre-revenue, going-concern or utility-token businesses; tZERO's licenses say nothing about their quality.
Why it matters
Investors who confuse a licensed venue with a curated one will price the issuer off tZERO's regulatory footprint. The venue's own filed history (Spirits Capital zero sold, KNOWPIA 33 months with nothing sold, Aurox $327,356) and the TZROP outcome (no dividend, converted on the issuer's terms) show the placement layer does not select for investor outcomes.
Mitigation / verification
Underwrite from the issuer's PPM financial statements and EDGAR record only. For revenue-share tokens (BRYTR, KNOWPIA), ask for the trailing distributions actually paid, in cash, per token. If the answer is none or the offering has no operating history, price it as venture equity with a cap on the upside (BRYTR: 3x) and no floor.
Custody and Counterparty Risk at Small, Parent-Dependent Affiliates
Subscription cash and carried tokens sit with two broker-dealers holding under $650,000 of net capital each (above their regulatory minimums, small in absolute terms), both economically dependent on a loss-making parent, with an explicit SIPC caveat on digital asset securities.
Why it matters
The special purpose broker-dealer framework is untested in a failure. tZERO Securities is self-clearing for conventional securities and relies on its affiliate for digital ones; the parent's funding since 2022 has been a non-binding $10 million insider note and an undisclosed ICE commitment. A parent liquidity event would reach the subsidiaries that hold customer positions.
Mitigation / verification
Where the issuer permits, hold tokens in a self-hosted wallet or third-party custodian rather than at tZERO Digital Asset Securities (the customer agreement describes a self-custody model). Keep subscription cash in escrow only as long as the closing schedule requires. Read each March's X-17A-5 for both CIKs (1193821 and 1909301) for net capital and the concentration note.
Conflict Risk from Affiliate Placements
Beyond, Inc., tZERO's largest shareholder, used tZERO Securities to place its subsidiaries' brand tokens, and tZERO's own TZROP dominated the ATS until 2026.
Why it matters
When the placement agent, the venue and the issuer share an owner, the usual arms-length checks on pricing ($5 per share to Beyond stockholders, $10 to others), listing and disclosure are absent, and the broker-dealer's revenue concentration (TZROP 40% and 74%) gives it every incentive to accommodate the parent's needs.
Mitigation / verification
Identify the issuer's owner on the Form C or PPM. For Beyond-affiliated tokens (OTKNP, NXHBP), read Beyond's own 10-K for the brand's economics. Treat any tZERO statement about an affiliate's token as issuer marketing.
Platform Continuity Risk
The parent has lost money every public year, carried going-concern notes in its last two audits, shut three ventures since 2022 and is financing itself with insider notes and an undisclosed ICE round while planning an IPO.
Why it matters
Tokens issued through tZERO depend on its transfer agent for the register, its custodian for carrying, its ATS for any trading and its issuance platform for distributions. A wind-down would leave holders with on-chain positions and no venue; Aurox investors already have no live intermediary of record after tZERO Markets' termination.
Mitigation / verification
Record the token contract address, your wallet or account position, the transfer agent of record and the issuer's contact details independently of tZERO. Watch Beyond's 10-Qs (the only public window on tZERO's carrying value and financing), the annual FOCUS reports, and any Form D from tZERO Group for the ICE round.
Biggest Misconceptions & What Actually Happens
- tZERO is the venue and placement agent; the issuer's PPM, Form D, Form C or offering circular is the governing disclosure and the issuer, not tZERO, owes you the economics.
- The 'valuation cap', 'goal' and 'funded' fields on platform.tzero.com are display values; on Quarter Homes the cap and the goal are the same $147.2 million. Confirm any raise figure from EDGAR.
- Every deal's Financials tab read 'coming soon' at the review date; the numbers are in the PPMs and, for filed issuers, on EDGAR.
- FINRA's weekly ATS data under MPID PROS is the only public volume record; tzero.com publishes none.
- TZROP holders received Series B preferred and common stock in May 2026; the token no longer trades and its dividend was never declared.
- The 1% commission and up to 7% processing fee are investor-side; the issuer separately pays 4% plus 1% and fixed fees, which come out of the proceeds funding the business you are buying.
- The SEC's 2022 order is the only regulatory disclosure on the broker-dealer; the FY2018 to FY2023 SEC investigations of the TZROP offering and Overstock's dividend produced no order and no public closing letter.
Regulatory & Legal Posture
Security Status
FINRA Broker-Dealer Operating an SEC-Regulated ATS + Special Purpose Broker-Dealer Custodian + SEC Transfer Agent, With One Resolved SEC Order (2022) and No Investor Product of Its Own Since May 2026
tZERO Securities, LLC is a FINRA member broker-dealer (CRD 123421; SEC 8-65585) registered as the operator of the tZERO Securities ATS, which filed Forms ATS-N for NMS stock from 2019 to 2021 and continues as a non-NMS venue for digital asset securities under Form ATS; it is self-clearing for conventional securities and was approved by FINRA in September 2025 to sell and trade corporate debt. tZERO Digital Asset Securities, LLC (CRD 316189; SEC 8-70879) was approved in September 2024 as a special purpose broker-dealer under the SEC's December 23, 2020 statement, permitting it to custody digital asset securities subject to that statement's conditions; its Form CRS states that SIPA protections may not apply to those securities. The group also holds an SEC transfer-agent registration, an exempt reporting adviser (tZERO Capital Partners, Utah) and a CFTC introducing broker (tZERO Introducing Broker, NFA member); DCO and DCM applications filed in September 2025 are undecided. Offerings placed through the stack are the issuers' securities under Reg D 506(c), Reg A+ Tier 2 or Reg CF, with the corresponding Form D, 1-A and Form C obligations resting on the issuer.
The regulatory record: SEC Administrative Proceeding File 3-20699 (January 10, 2022), in which tZERO ATS, LLC was found to have willfully violated Rules 301(b)(2) and (5) of Regulation ATS by sharing order-book information with two third parties without timely Form ATS disclosure and by lacking written fair-access standards; cease-and-desist, censure, $800,000 penalty, resolved. SEC Division of Enforcement investigations of the TZROP offering (from February 2018) and Overstock's 2019 digital dividend (subpoenas October 2019, December 2019 and January 2021) were disclosed in Overstock's 10-Ks through FY2023 and absent from FY2024 onward with no closing letter on record. Pending: Securitize, Inc. v. tZERO Group, Inc. and tZERO IP, LLC (D.
Del. 1:26-cv-00722, filed June 22, 2026), a declaratory-judgment action over tZERO's tokenization patents with counterclaims; a commercial dispute, not an investor matter. Closed: In re Overstock Securities Litigation (D. Utah 2:19-cv-00709), dismissed and affirmed by the Tenth Circuit on October 15, 2024.
Disclosure Quality
Above average for private infrastructure where regulation compels, and thin where it does not. Both broker-dealers' audited statements of financial condition are public each March with notes that, for FY2025, include revenue, client concentration and the economic-dependence statement; FINRA's weekly ATS data is available by symbol; the TZROP consent solicitation ran to 163 pages with an independent fair-value summary and a pro forma capitalization table; and Beyond's filings carried tZERO Group's audited statements through FY2023. Against that: tzero.com publishes no volume, the parent's financials stopped being public after FY2023, broker-dealer income statements are withheld, the platform's deal pages show 'coming soon' under Financials on every offering, and the marketing describes a 'leading' venue that FINRA's data does not support.
Custody Model
Affiliate Special Purpose Broker-Dealer Custody + Segregated Offering Escrow + Optional Self-Custody
Regulatory Backing
Conventional securities are carried by tZERO Securities as a self-clearing broker-dealer with cash at BMO Harris Bank; digital asset securities are carried by tZERO Digital Asset Securities, which controls the wallets and private keys under the SPBD conditions; the customer agreement also describes a customer self-custody model allowing a third-party custodian or self-hosted wallet for certain securities. Primary-offering subscriptions sit in a segregated escrow account at tZERO Securities until closing, with interest for the escrow agent's benefit. Net capital at December 31, 2025 was $521,737 (tZERO Securities) and $635,723 (tZERO DAS); both entities disclose economic dependence on tZERO Group.
The custodian's Form CRS warns that SIPA protections may not apply to digital asset securities. Platform failure would not extinguish issuer securities recorded on-chain and at the transfer agent, but every service around them (trading, custody, transfer agency, distributions) runs on group rails with no disclosed continuity arrangement.
Tax Treatment
Reporting
Varies by issuer and instrument; tZERO Securities issues brokerage tax forms
LLC revenue-participation tokens (BRYTR) are partnership interests issuing Schedule K-1 (the PPM budgets K-1 preparation as a shared platform cost and relies on tZERO's matching service as a qualified matching service safe harbor against publicly-traded-partnership status). Corporate preferred and common (KNOWPIA, TZROP successors, the Beyond brand tokens, C3 Bullion, Aurox) generate 1099-DIV or 1099-B only on dividends or sales. The Kondoo token, issued by a Swiss GmbH, carries no US reporting from the issuer. tZERO Securities reports trades and interest on its own 1099s.
Income Character
Mixed: Partnership Income (LLC tokens), Dividend or Capital Gain (corporate tokens), Speculative Gain or Loss (utility-style tokens)
BRYTR holders are allocated the SPV's share of CarbonEnfo's payments, which the PPM expects to be treated as dividend income to the extent of CarbonEnfo's earnings and profits, then return of capital, then gain; holders are taxed on allocated income whether or not distributed and may face the 3.8% net investment income tax. Corporate tokens produce qualified or ordinary dividends if any are declared (none were on TZROP in eight years) and capital gain or loss on sale, with a one-year holding period governing rate. The TZROP conversion in May 2026 was structured as an amendment and automatic conversion of the certificate of designation; holders should confirm its tax treatment from tZERO's notices. Utility-style tokens sold as securities have no income until sale.
Limitation
Loss realization is the practical issue: tokens with no market cannot be sold to trigger a loss, and dissolution of an issuer may never generate a clean worthlessness event. Keep the PPM, subscription documents, K-1s and any transfer-agent statements. Confirm all treatment with a tax adviser; this review does not establish individual tax conclusions.
Special Considerations
- K-1s from LLC tokens depend on the issuer's accounting; BRYTR's are prepared by an outside firm charged as a shared platform cost that reduces net platform revenue.
- Publicly-traded-partnership risk: if an LLC token trades outside a qualified matching service, the issuer could be taxed as a corporation; the BRYTR PPM says no ruling will be sought.
- The KNOWPIA dividend may be paid in USD, Bitcoin, Ether or additional tokens at the company's choice; PIK dividends are taxable at value.
- Stablecoin distributions (BRYTR) are received in USDC-type tokens to a Cardano wallet; conversion to dollars is a separate taxable disposition of the stablecoin at whatever difference exists.
- Non-US issuers (Kondoo Digital GmbH) may implicate PFIC or foreign-reporting rules for US holders depending on the token's classification.
- State treatment follows residence; nothing here is state-specific advice.
Account Suitability
Taxable
The default. Most listed tokens produce no current income, so the planning problem is documenting losses on positions that cannot be sold and handling K-1s from the LLC tokens.
Roth IRA
Possible only through a self-directed custodian willing to hold tokens at tZERO Digital Asset Securities or on-chain; valuations are the investor's problem and a total loss wastes contribution room. Not practical for most.
Traditional IRA
Same custodian friction, worse asymmetry: any gain becomes ordinary income at distribution and losses inside the account are never deductible.
HSA
Not supported by mainstream HSA custodians.
Before You Invest
Get tZERO investor insights before you invest
K-1 timing, distribution updates, yield insights, and risk signals for tZERO and similar platforms.
- Weekly platform research focused on tax timing and liquidity reality.
- Signals on distributions, risks, and structural tradeoffs before capital is locked up.
- Coverage of adjacent platforms so you can compare better options faster.
Get weekly platform signals
Track fee changes, liquidity updates, risk flags, and adjacent platforms before you invest.
Independent intelligence from AltStreet. No hype. No sponsor spin.
AltStreet Data Layer
What the data actually shows
AltStreet read FINRA's trade data for the tZERO ATS, both broker-dealers' audited filings, the TZROP consent solicitation, the parent's Beyond filings and every offering document behind the sixteen listed deals. These are the findings that matter most.
The ATS traded $5.9 million in 2025, 96% of it tZERO's own token, and tens of shares a week since that token stopped
FINRA's weekly data under MPID PROS shows notional of $28.9M (2022), $9.5M (2023), $6.0M (2024), $5.9M (2025) and $1.6M in 2026 through August 3. TZROP was $5.6M of the 2025 total and last traded the week of May 4, 2026. The following week the venue reported 32 shares and $20.40; subsequent weeks range from 63 to 3,917 shares across Aspen Digital, Curzio, EnergyFunders and the Overstock token. The September 12, 2026 screen showed zero volume on every visible listing.
What this means
tZERO's 'leading ATS' language describes trades in its own stock. For any other token, the venue is a price display with no depth; exit should be assumed impossible at the quoted price.
TZROP never paid its dividend and was converted into Series B and common on the company's terms
Sold under Rule 506(c) in 2017 and 2018 ($75,905,562 from 920 investors) with a contingent 10% adjusted-gross-revenue dividend and a $10 redemption floor, TZROP never had a dividend declared. In April 2026 management proposed 3 Series B per token, enhanced to 3 Series B plus 8 common; Dahn Consulting's fair-value summary put the equivalence at 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common. Holders approved with 84.6% of 15.16 million tokens voted (72.2% turnout), giving up the floor, the dividend and continuous trading for a 1.25x preference on $0.5497 and semi-annual auctions.
What this means
The venue's only completed retail token outcome: eight years, no income, then an exchange on the issuer's terms. It is a case study in contingent revenue-share tokens, not a forecast for third-party issuers, whose economics tZERO does not control; price any such token on the cash the issuer has actually paid.
Both customer-facing broker-dealers are small, TZROP-dependent and reliant on a loss-making parent
At December 31, 2025 tZERO Securities had $521,737 of net capital ($271,737 excess) on $418,088 of revenue with TZROP at 40% and DASN at 21%, down from $1.14M of net capital a year earlier; tZERO Digital Asset Securities had $635,723 on $204,121 of revenue, 74% from TZROP. Both audits state economic dependence on the parent. tZERO Group's last public audit (FY2023) shows $1.63M of revenue, a $29.5M net loss, $43.2M of cash and a going-concern note; Beyond marks its 26% at $15.5M; the April 2026 financing is a non-binding $10M insider note, unfunded at June 30, 2026.
What this means
Regulatory capital rules are the protection and they are being met; the cushion is small and the parent's ability to refill it depends on financings that were unsigned or undisclosed at the review date. Hold tokens outside the affiliate custodian where the issuer permits.
The offerings shelf: sixteen cards, six with no filing, filed outcomes from $0 to $466,520
Current: BRYTR ($0 sold at its April 2026 Form D), Kondoo (no Form D), KNOWPIA ($0 sold since December 2023, going-concern PPM), C3 Bullion (inactive, going concern, control change). Prior and filed: Spirits Capital $0 of $35M qualified; Aurox $327,356; Overstock IP token $466,520 and buybuy BABY $395,920 (both Beyond subsidiaries); FINTECH.TV $10,000 target, no C-U; Invest Inc. no 1-K; Digital Prime's Form Ds all 506(b) against a 506(c) card. Prior and unfiled: Quarter Homes, RSRV Aspen, Park Street, McNeill, Emmis. Every deal's Financials tab reads 'coming soon'.
What this means
The placement business is not a curated shelf and its distribution reach outside the parent's affiliates is a few hundred thousand dollars per raise. Underwrite the issuer from EDGAR; if the issuer is not on EDGAR, that is the finding.
The 2022 SEC order went to the ATS's core function and is the only regulatory event on record
The Commission found tZERO ATS, LLC willfully violated Regulation ATS by sharing order-book information with two third parties without timely Form ATS disclosure and by operating without written fair-access standards: cease-and-desist, censure, $800,000 (File 3-20699, January 10, 2022). It is the sole BrokerCheck disclosure on CRD 123421 and the reason the tZERO Securities Form CRS answers 'Yes' to disciplinary history. The SEC's 2018 to 2021 investigations of the TZROP offering and Overstock's dividend ended without an order or a public closing letter.
What this means
Old, resolved and specific: the venue's fair-access and disclosure conduct was deficient and corrected under order. Weigh it as history, not as a live risk, and note that no FINRA action, state action or customer complaint appears in any record AltStreet searched.
Fees are published on both sides, and the issuer stack is heavy for small raises
Investors pay 1% per trade (or $0.03 a share under $3), up to 7% on primary commitments and no account fees. Issuers pay, per the BRYTR PPM, 4% plus 1% of gross, $25,000 advisory, $1,000 escrow, $10,000 setup, $2,000 a month, $20 per investor, 35 basis points of custody with a $1,500 monthly minimum and $7,500 per smart contract, capped at 10% of gross under FINRA Rule 5110; KNOWPIA pays 2% plus $25,000; Kondoo 2% plus 4% plus $20,000 plus $5,000 plus $25,000 tokenization and a 5% distribution to its own owners; the Reg CF raises paid 1% plus $25,000 plus $1,000.
What this means
On a $500,000 raise the fixed fees alone approach 10% before the percentage; the money comes out of the proceeds funding the business you are buying. Read the placement-fee section of every PPM and reduce the use of proceeds accordingly.
Data as of 2026-09-12 . AltStreet review evidence layer . Public-source analysis
Full datasetAltStreet Weekly
This analysis runs on AltStreet's filing database
Seventeen deal rows, fourteen filing snapshots, eight ingested offering documents, two broker-dealers' audited capital and the FINRA weekly series. The same data layer covers 100+ alternative investment platforms.
So What?
What to do differently because of this.
What this means
Liquidity is a claim on tzero.com and a number on FINRA's site
What to do
Before buying any token that 'may list on the tZERO ATS', look up MPID PROS in FINRA's OTC transparency data and read the weekly shares and notional for that symbol. If the symbol is not there, or prints hundreds of shares, size the position as if it cannot be sold.
What this means
The venue's own investors got restructured, not paid
What to do
Any token whose return depends on the issuer's future profits (BRYTR's 12% of net platform revenue, KNOWPIA's discretionary 10% of gross profit, TZROP's 10% of adjusted gross revenue) is a contingent claim the issuer controls. Ask what has been paid to date, in cash, to whom. For TZROP the answer over eight years was nothing.
What this means
The deal page is a brochure; the filing is the disclosure
What to do
Search EDGAR for the issuer's exact legal name. Six of tZERO's twelve prior cards return nothing. Where a filing exists, read the Form C-U or Form D/A for what actually sold: Aurox $327,356, Spirits Capital $0, Zion Peaks $395,920. Where the platform shows a 'valuation cap' equal to the raise goal, as on Quarter Homes ($147.2 million for both), treat the field as unpopulated.
What this means
Custody risk sits with two small affiliates
What to do
Read the tZERO Digital Asset Securities Form CRS sentence that SIPC protections may not apply to digital asset securities. Where the issuer allows it, hold tokens in a self-hosted or third-party wallet rather than at the affiliate, and keep independent records of the token contract and your address.
Decision Fit
Investor Fit
Who this works for, who it does not, and what level of patience and complexity tolerance the platform really demands.
Accredited Investors Who Have Underwritten a Specific tZERO-Placed Issuer
If the issuer's PPM and EDGAR record pass your own underwriting, tZERO is a compliant place to subscribe, custody and, in principle, trade. The fee stack (1% commission, up to 7% processing, the issuer's 5% plus fixed fees) and the illiquidity are the price. Nothing about the venue should enter the investment case.
Existing Holders of ATS-Listed Tokens
Aspen Digital, Curzio, EnergyFunders, the Overstock and buybuy BABY tokens and the former TZROP have no other regulated venue. Use limit orders, expect weeks or months to fill, and treat the semi-annual auction format as the realistic exit for the preferred.
Issuers Seeking a Compliant Token Raise
The bundled stack (placement, escrow, issuance platform, custody, transfer agent, ATS listing, accreditation verification) is the most complete in the US market and its fees are published. The caveats are the venue's distribution reach (filed raises of $0 to $466,520 outside the parent's affiliates) and the association with a platform whose own token history is now part of every diligence file.
Retail Investors Browsing for Yield or Tokenized Real Assets
The shelf is four current offerings, three of them accredited-only, describing pre-revenue or going-concern businesses; the listed tokens do not trade; and the venue's own retail token paid nothing for eight years. Tokenized Treasury and credit funds live at Securitize and elsewhere, not here.
Investors Requiring Track Records or Platform Curation
There is no curation, no published outcome data and no investor-return record in any public source; the filed history is unsold, sub-$500,000 and going-concern issuers. A process that needs demonstrated results cannot be satisfied here.
Tradeoffs
Key Tradeoffs
The attraction of pre-IPO access is real, but every benefit comes bundled with a corresponding liquidity, transparency, or pricing cost.
Licenses vs. Liquidity
tZERO's regulatory stack is the most complete in its category and is exactly what tokenized markets are supposed to require. Ten years in, FINRA's data shows the stack carrying $1.6 million of notional in seven months, and the venue's dominant listing was the operator's own token until it stopped trading.
Full Disclosure vs. Poor Content
tZERO publishes its fee schedules, keeps closed-deal documents online, files two audited FOCUS reports a year with revenue notes and ran a 163-page consent solicitation. The documents disclose a token that never paid, issuers that never sold and a parent that never earned. The candor is real and so is what it describes.
Integration vs. Conflict
One group performing every role from placement to custody to trading removes the coordination failures that plague tokenized issuance. It also removes every independent check: the same firm priced, placed, custodied, listed and then restructured its own token, and placed its largest shareholder's subsidiaries' raises.
Institutional Ambition vs. Retail Shelf
The ICE memorandum, corporate-debt approval, CFTC applications and IPO plan describe an infrastructure company selling to exchanges and banks. The retail product investors actually see is a shelf of small tokens from pre-revenue issuers. Whether the first succeeds has little to do with whether the second pays.
Avoid
Who This Is Not For
This section should be read as a filter, not an afterthought. If you need income, simplicity, or near-term access to capital, the structure is working against you.
Anyone Who Needs to Sell
The venue reported 32 shares in the week after its own token converted and has not exceeded a few thousand shares a week since. Every listing showed zero volume on the day AltStreet captured the screen.
Yield Seekers Reading 'Revenue Share' as Income
TZROP's 10% of adjusted gross revenue was never declared in eight years. BRYTR's 12% of net platform revenue comes from a marketplace with no material revenue. KNOWPIA's 10% of gross profit is discretionary and conditioned on net income the company has never had.
Investors Who Treat the License as the Diligence
tZERO's regulatory status is real and irrelevant to whether CarbonEnfo sells solar credits, Kondoo ships a game or KNOWPIA survives the quarter. The filings that matter are the issuers', and six of sixteen deals have none.
Anyone Uncomfortable Holding Assets at a Dependent Affiliate
The custodian has $635,723 of net capital, earns 74% of its revenue from the parent's token, states it depends on the parent for funding and warns that SIPC may not cover your digital securities.
Editorial View
AltStreet Perspective
The compressed version of the review: what matters, what marketing tends to obscure, and how we would frame the platform for a serious allocator.
Verdict
tZERO built the regulatory architecture that tokenized securities in the United States were supposed to need, and then spent a decade waiting for the securities. The architecture is genuine: an SEC-regulated ATS since 2019, a special purpose broker-dealer custodian (one of two, by the company's account), a transfer agent, corporate-debt approval, CFTC applications, a patent portfolio ICE now licenses. The market on top of it is not: FINRA's data shows notional falling 95% since 2022 to a venue that, once its own token stopped trading in May 2026, moves tens to a few thousand shares a week. The company's treatment of its own investors is the record that matters most. TZROP holders were sold a contingent revenue dividend and a $10 floor in 2017 and 2018, received no dividend in eight years, and in April 2026 approved an exchange of both, and of continuous trading, for 3 Series B plus 8 common per token; the company's consultant separately put one token at 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common. The placement shelf tZERO fills is small, and its filed outcomes run from zero sold to a few hundred thousand dollars, mostly for the parent's affiliates. The broker-dealers investors deal with are small in absolute terms, above their regulatory minimums, and dependent on the parent. None of this makes tZERO unsafe to transact through; the 2022 SEC order is old and resolved, the audits are unqualified, the fee schedules are published. It makes tZERO plumbing. Use it when an issuer you have underwritten requires it, expect to hold what you buy, and keep what you can outside the affiliate custodian.
Positioning
AltStreet reviews tZERO as infrastructure, on the same path as DealMaker, North Capital and Securitize: investors rarely choose it, but tokens they buy pass through it. The seventeen deal rows (sixteen offering cards plus Zion Peaks), fourteen filing snapshots, eight ingested offering documents, both broker-dealers' FOCUS data and the FINRA volume series now sit in AltStreet's data layer. The events to watch are the FY2026 FOCUS reports (the first year without TZROP trading revenue), Beyond's 10-Qs for the carrying value and the convertible note, any Form D for the ICE round, the Securitize patent case, and whether any current offering reports a sale.
The Bottom Line
The most licensed tokenized-securities venue in America, and one of the least traded; read the issuer's filing and the FINRA print, not the platform.
Action
Next Steps
If you still want to engage after reading the review, these are the practical next moves that reduce avoidable mistakes.
Before subscribing to any tZERO-placed offering, find the issuer on EDGAR by exact legal name; if there is no Form D, Form C or 1-A, ask the issuer why in writing.
Read the PPM's financial statements and the placement-fee section; deduct the 5% plus fixed fees from the use of proceeds before judging the raise.
For revenue-share tokens, ask for the cash distributions paid per token to date; if none, underwrite as venture equity with a capped upside.
Look up MPID PROS in FINRA's OTC transparency weekly ATS data and read the symbol's weekly shares and notional before assuming any exit.
Read the tZERO Digital Asset Securities Form CRS and, where the issuer allows, hold tokens in a self-hosted or third-party wallet.
Each March, pull the X-17A-5 for CIK 1193821 and CIK 1909301 and check net capital, the concentration note and the economic-dependence statement.
Watch Beyond's 10-Qs for tZERO's carrying value and the $10M convertible note, and EDGAR for a tZERO Group Form D covering the ICE round.
If you hold former TZROP, read the Series B certificate of designation and the semi-annual auction terms; the $10 floor no longer exists.
Final Answer
What this means for your decision.
Finding
The secondary market exists on paper and barely in practice
Meaning
FINRA's data for the tZERO ATS shows $28.9 million of notional traded in 2022, $9.5 million in 2023, $6.0 million in 2024 and $5.9 million in 2025, of which 96% was tZERO's own TZROP token. TZROP stopped trading in May 2026 when it converted. Since then the venue reports between 32 and 3,917 shares a week across the five remaining listings, and the logged-out secondary screen on September 12, 2026 showed zero volume on every row.
Action
Do not buy a tokenized security through tZERO on the assumption you can sell it. Treat every position as locked until you have watched the FINRA weekly print for that symbol yourself, and price the bid-ask gaps you see on the screen ($1.10 bid against $2.40 ask on Aspen Digital that morning) as the real cost of exit.
Finding
tZERO's own token never paid its dividend, and holders just voted away the $10 floor
Meaning
TZROP, sold to 920 investors for $75.9 million in 2017 and 2018, carried a noncumulative dividend of 10% of adjusted gross revenue, conditioned on a profitability test, and a redemption right at not less than $10.00 per token. The April 2026 consent statement says no dividend was ever declared. Management offered 3 Series B plus 8 common shares per token; Dahn Consulting separately estimated one TZROP as equivalent to 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common. Holders approved with 84.6% of votes cast, and the token became Series B preferred with a 1.25x preference on a $0.55 issue price, plus common, with semi-annual auctions instead of continuous trading.
Action
Read TZROP as a case study in revenue-linked token risk, not as a template for third-party offerings: tZERO controlled its own token's economics, and CarbonEnfo or KNOWPIA control theirs. Contingent economics that depend on profitability the issuer never reaches pay nothing, and the restructuring that follows is on the issuer's terms. Underwrite each token on the issuer's filed cash flows, never on tZERO's brand.
Finding
The offerings shelf is thin, and the filings behind it are mostly small, unsold or silent
Meaning
Sixteen cards sit on tzero.com/trade: four current, twelve prior. AltStreet found the outcome for the ones that filed: Aurox raised $327,356 of a $5 million maximum; the two Beyond, Inc. brand tokens raised $466,520 and $395,920; Spirits Capital's qualified $35 million Reg A+ sold zero shares; FINTECH.TV targeted $10,000; KNOWPIA's Form D has reported nothing sold since December 2023 and its PPM warns it may go out of business without the raise; BRYTR had no sales at its April 2026 Form D. Six of the sixteen cards (five prior, plus the current Kondoo offering) have no SEC filing under their card names at all, and every deal's Financials tab on the platform reads 'coming soon'.
Action
Pull the issuer's own EDGAR file before the tZERO deal page. If there is no Form D, Form C or offering statement under the issuer's name, ask the issuer why before wiring anything, and treat the platform's 'valuation cap' and 'funded' fields as display values, not disclosures.
Finding
Your money passes through two small affiliates that depend on the parent
Meaning
tZERO Securities ended 2025 with $521,737 of net capital ($271,737 above its minimum) on $418,088 of revenue, 40% of it from the parent's TZROP; the custodian, tZERO Digital Asset Securities, had $635,723 of net capital ($385,723 above its minimum) on $204,121 of revenue, 74% from TZROP. Both audited statements say the firm is economically dependent on the parent for funding. The parent's last public audit (FY2023) shows $1.6 million of revenue, a $29.5 million net loss and a going-concern note; it has raised about $200 million to date, is unprofitable, and in April 2026 signed a non-binding letter for up to $10 million of convertible notes from its largest shareholder.
Action
Keep primary-offering subscriptions in escrow as briefly as the closing schedule allows, keep your own records of every token you hold and its on-chain position, and read the SIPC caveat in the custodian's Form CRS: protections for digital asset securities may not apply.
If you read nothing else
tZERO has the regulatory stack its marketing describes: a decade of licenses, an SEC-regulated ATS, a special purpose broker-dealer custodian approved in 2024 (one of two in the United States, by the company's account), a transfer agent, FINRA approval to trade corporate debt, and a 2026 memorandum with Intercontinental Exchange, its largest outside investor. What it does not have is a market. The venue's own numbers, read from FINRA rather than from tzero.com, show a secondary book that has shrunk by 95% since 2022 and was almost entirely tZERO's own token until that token stopped trading in May 2026. The offerings shelf it fills as placement agent is small, and where filings exist they show zero-sale, sub-$500,000 or going-concern issuers. The one enforcement action on record, a willful Regulation ATS violation settled for $800,000 in 2022, is old and resolved; the live governance question is the April 2026 TZROP conversion, in which holders surrendered the original dividend right, the $10 redemption provision and continuous trading for 3 Series B plus 8 common shares per token; Dahn Consulting separately estimated one TZROP as equivalent to 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common. For an investor, tZERO is a set of rails, not a product: legitimate regulated rails through which to hold a position, but no guarantee of issuer quality, liquidity or custody protection, and no substitute for reading the issuer's filing.
AltStreet Research Desk
About to invest in tZERO, or in an offering we haven't covered?
Commission an independent diligence report: the same filing-based analysis behind this review, applied to the specific investment in front of you before you wire the money.
- Built from primary sources: SEC filings, court records, capital structure, and marketing-versus-filings comparison.
- From $750; full reports from $1,495. Fixed price confirmed up front, delivery in 3-5 business days.
- Independent by design: we work for investors and accept no compensation from the companies we cover.
Want this on every new deal, not one? Deal Intelligence sends the alert the day a new offering appears on a covered platform and follows with an analyst-approved investment committee memo.
Deal Intelligence →Appendix
Sources, Disclosures, and Supporting Context
The lower section is structured like a report appendix: relationship context first, adjacent reading second, and evidence last.
Report Appendix
Disclosure
Relationship and compensation context
+
Report Appendix
Disclosure
Relationship and compensation context
Report Appendix
Comparison Guides
Head-to-head guides featuring tZERO
+
Report Appendix
Comparison Guides
Head-to-head guides featuring tZERO
Report Appendix
Related Resources
Adjacent platform comparisons, frameworks, and category links
+
Report Appendix
Related Resources
Adjacent platform comparisons, frameworks, and category links
Further Reading
Related Resources
Adjacent frameworks and reviews that help place the platform in a broader allocation or due-diligence context.
Frameworks
- ->Tokenholder Voting and Distributions
- ->Smart Contract Risk
- ->Delivery vs Payment
- ->Settlement Finality
- ->Self-Custody vs Custodial Wallets
- ->Private-Key Recovery
- ->tZERO vs Securitize: which tokenized securities platform actually trades
- ->tZERO vs North Capital: which regulated venue actually trades private securities
- ->Three-Pillar Evaluation Framework
- ->Real Asset Due Diligence Guide
Similar Platform Reviews
- Securitize
The tokenized-fund counterpart: transfer agent, broker-dealer and ATS behind BlackRock, Hamilton Lane and Apollo feeders, with institutional product and a clean record where tZERO has licenses and a thin shelf.
- North Capital
Conventional alt-platform plumbing: carrying broker-dealer, escrow and the PPEX ATS, with a customer-money balance sheet an order of magnitude larger than tZERO's affiliates.
- DealMaker
Issuer-side raise infrastructure without a venue: the comparison for tZERO's placement-agent business and its fee stack.
Report Appendix
Evidence & Methodology
515 cited passages on file; sources, scope, and how the review was assembled
+
Report Appendix
Evidence & Methodology
515 cited passages on file; sources, scope, and how the review was assembled
Evidence on file
515 supporting passages on file for tZERO and its offerings from 9 source documents, 20 discrepancies flagged. Each passage records the metric it supports, the value read from the document, the page, and the verbatim text where the document has it. Terminal subscribers read the passages; open them in the terminal.
- Cited passages
- 515
- Source documents
- 9
- Analyst verified
- 0
- Discrepancies flagged
- 20
ASReview Evidence
Methodology
Seven primary sources. (1) FINRA OTC Transparency weekly ATS data for MPID PROS (tZERO ATS, LLC), 2022 through the week of August 3, 2026, firm-level and by symbol. (2) Audited X-17A-5 statements of financial condition: tZERO Securities, LLC FY2024 (filed March 4, 2025) and FY2025 (filed March 2, 2026), tZERO Digital Asset Securities, LLC FY2024 (March 6, 2025) and FY2025 (March 4, 2026), auditor Haynie & Co; income statements not public. (3) The TZROP Consent Solicitation Statement (April 7, 2026), conversion FAQ (April 16), Dahn Consulting summary (April 14), pro forma capitalization table, BBBY letter of intent, the April 29 results release, the May 4, 2026 stockholder notices and the March 2025 full-tokenization FAQ. (4) Beyond, Inc. 10-K FY2022, FY2024 and FY2025, the Q2 2026 10-Q, and tZERO Group's audited FY2022 and FY2023 statements filed as Rule 3-09 exhibits. (5) SEC File 3-20699 (Release 34-93938), FINRA BrokerCheck for CRD 123421, 304537 and 316189, Form ATS-N filings for CIK 1193821, In re Overstock Securities Litigation (D. Utah, Tenth Circuit) and Securitize v. tZERO (D. Del.). (6) Offering documents ingested into AltStreet's data layer: BRYTR PPM (117 pp) and white paper, KNOWPIA PPM with two amendments (56 pp), Kondoo Digital PPM (53 pp), C3 Bullion post-qualification amendment No. 4 (100 pp), Aurox Form C/A (109 pp), Commercial Strategies Form C/A (98 pp), Zion Peaks Form C (81 pp), plus every Form D, D/A, C-U, C-AR, 1-K, 1-SA, 1-U and 1-Z on EDGAR for the sixteen listed issuers and their affiliates. (7) A 122-page Firecrawl capture of tzero.com (September 12, 2026), the customer agreement, both Forms CRS and the fee schedule effective September 4, 2026, the offerings page source (sixteen cards in the React payload, four visible in the DOM), and screenshots of the logged-out secondary screen and three deal pages.
Scope
Broker-dealer capital and revenue: complete for FY2025 from public notes; FY2024 revenue and all net income not public. ATS volume: complete from FINRA at weekly resolution under the legacy MPID; tzero.com publishes none. Parent financials: public through FY2023 only. Offerings: all sixteen cards read; six cards (five prior, plus current Kondoo) have no EDGAR filing under their card names and are recorded from platform screens or their PPM only. Issuer outcomes: limited to Form C-U, D/A, 1-Z and 1-K disclosures; no investor-return data exists in any public source. Company-reported figures ('leading ATS', $200M raised, 50+ employees) are labeled as such.
Key Findings
- *FINRA weekly ATS data, MPID PROS, firm-level: 2022 4,764,148 shares / 33,429 trades / $28,938,866 · 2023 3,306,456 / 11,065 / $9,450,255 · 2024 2,530,400 / 7,136 / $5,982,150 · 2025 1,886,624 / 6,891 / $5,851,828 · 2026 through August 3: 917,009 / 2,605 / $1,605,480. TZROP: 2025 1,635,266 shares / $5,608,845 (96% of notional); 2026 782,782 / $1,516,476, last week May 4, 2026. Other 2025 symbols: XYLB $71,301, ASPD $126,646, CURZ $23,446, ENFD $21,594. Week of May 11, 2026: 32 shares, 7 trades, $20.40. Weeks May 25 to August 3, 2026: 63 to 3,917 shares; OTKNP 5,339 shares / 210 trades / $32,583 across 2026.
- *tZERO Securities X-17A-5 FY2025: net capital $521,737, excess $271,737, ratio 2.50 to 1; total assets $5,307,173; due to customers $3,407,563; member's equity $671,418; revenue from contracts with customers $418,088 plus interest $202,666; commissions $133,059; concentration TZROP 40%, DASN 21%; affiliate expense share $1,486,873; 'economically dependent on the Parent for funding'; ATS symbols listed as TZROP, ASPD, CURZ, XYLB, ENFD. FY2024: net capital $1,142,541, excess $890,771, total assets $8,803,412, equity $1,207,828. FY2023 filing flagged materialWeakness=Y.
- *tZERO Digital Asset Securities X-17A-5 FY2025: net capital $635,723, excess $385,723; total assets $963,881; equity $745,505; custodial services $152,010 + advisory $52,111 = $204,121; TZROP 74%, DASN 26%. FY2024: net capital $790,367, excess $540,367. FINRA approval September 12, 2024; no disclosures.
- *TZROP consent solicitation: record date March 24, 2026; 243,918,748 common, 140,929,078 Series B, 21,152,297 TZROP outstanding; original proposal 3 Series B per TZROP (April 7), enhanced to 3 Series B + 8 common (April 16); Dahn Consulting: 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common fair-value equivalence; result April 29: 1,594 holders, 15,164,076 tokens voted (72.2%), 12,841,906 for (84.6%), 2,322,170 against; rights surrendered: redemption at not less than $10.00, dividend 'when and if declared' (none ever declared), continuous ATS liquidity; Series B preference 1.25x $0.5497; post-conversion TZROP holders 30.6% fully diluted (26.3% excluding Beyond); BBBY LOI up to $10,000,000 convertible notes at 80% of the qualified-financing price, $3.5M initial closing targeted Q3 2026, unfunded at June 30, 2026; Bill Fleckenstein expected to join the board for Series B.
- *Beyond, Inc. filings: deconsolidation April 23, 2021 ($243.5M gain; retained interests $288.8M fair value); $15.0M into the ICE-led Series B (2022); direct ownership 28% (FY2024), 26% (FY2025), 22% (June 30, 2026); combined 49.4% to 38.7% after the conversion; carrying value $17,720K (FY2024) to $15,503K (FY2025), Level 3, term to liquidity 5.0 years; SEC-investigation risk factor present FY2021 to FY2023, absent FY2024 and FY2025. tZERO Group FY2023 audited (Rule 3-09): revenue $1,633K (FY2022 $2,488K), employee compensation $11,796K, net loss $29,484K (FY2022 $38,642K), cash $43,240K (FY2022 $58,260K), Note 16 going concern; FY2022 auditor emphasis of matter on going concern; Series B net proceeds $70,624K; 140.9M Series B shares.
- *SEC File 3-20699 (January 10, 2022): tZERO ATS, LLC 'did not make timely disclosures on Form ATS before it shared information about the ATS's order book with two different third parties' and 'failed to establish written standards for granting access to the ATS'; willful violation of Rules 301(b)(2) and (5); cease-and-desist, censure, $800,000. BrokerCheck CRD 123421: one regulatory event. CRD 304537 (tZERO Markets): no events, ceased business October 31, 2023, terminated December 20, 2024. CRD 316189 (tZERO DAS): no events.
- *Offerings shelf, current: BRYTR, LLC (CIK 2122407; Form D April 17, 2026: $4.5M offered, $0 sold, min $50,000 on the form vs $10,000 on the platform, $250,000 estimated commissions to tZERO Securities; PPM April 21, 2026: $1.00 tokens, 12% of net platform revenue, $3.00 cap, Cardano, K-1; CarbonEnfo FY2025 SSARS review: assets $693,617, liabilities $2,116,160, deficit $(1,422,543), net loss $598,534; Cox note $1,570,100 at 10% due Sept 6, 2027; Empower Energy Technology 63% owner controlled by CEO Mark Bell). Kondoo Digital GmbH (Zug; PPM March 9, 2026; 400M of 1B Amana tokens, $1.44 to $1.56 tiers, $100,000 min, 70M pre-issued, 5% of gross to owners, EUR 200,000 founder loan repaid; no Form D). KNOWPIA Inc. (CIK 2003048; Form D December 22, 2023: $3M offered, $0 sold, never amended; PPM August 26, 2025 with amendments January 5 and April 10, 2026 extending the close to June 30, 2026; cash $52,376.64 at March 31, 2026; unaudited non-GAAP statements: assets $1,929,353 at Sept 30, 2025, intangible $1,834,961, nine-month net loss $231,008; 18.31B shares authorized). C3 Bullion, Inc. (CIK 1981779; Reg A+ file 024-12367 qualified January 22, 2025 and PQA May 29, 2025; $40M at $5.00, $500 min; FY2024 audited net loss $821,257, cash $235,030, going concern; 1-U October 8, 2025 CEO change; 1-U August 11, 2026 surrender of 4,950,000 shares, 5,464,050 outstanding, Solomon Capital Management 64.05%; listed 'Inactive - pending updated offering documentation').
- *Offerings shelf, prior, filed: Spirits Capital Corp (CIK 1881767; Reg A+ $35M at $1.75 qualified November 30, 2023, tZERO ATS escrow agent; 1-Z June 24, 2024: 0 sold, 0 net proceeds, fees $150,000, 151 record holders). Aurox Holdings Inc. (CIK 1905443; Form C January 20, 2023, C/A February 16, intermediary tZERO Markets at 1% + $40,000 + $10,000; C-U March 22, 2023: $327,356 commitments against $250,000 target / $5M max at $6.00; prior 506(b) $5M at $2.00; no C-AR). Commercial Strategies, Inc. (CIK 2061269; Form C April 24, 2025, tZERO Securities at 1% + $25,000 + $1,000; $5.00 Beyond holders / $10.00 others; C-U May 23, 2025: $466,520; C-AR FY2025 revenue $1,180,494). Zion Peaks, Inc. (CIK 2067205; Form C May 8, 2025; C-U August 8, 2025: $395,920; C-AR revenue $15,471). Digital Prime Technologies (CIK 1790567; Form Ds 2019 to 2025 all 506(b): $325,000 / 3 (2022), $1,025,000 / 3 (2023), $5,000,000 / 1 (Dec 2025); platform: $5M cap, closed August 15, 2025, $25,004 min). FINTECH.TV, PBC (CIK 1870100; Form C October 18, 2023, $10,000 target at $4.00, tZERO Securities at 3% + $15,000 + $5,000; no C-U; C-AR FY2023 revenue $137,680). Invest Inc. (CIK 1908239; Reg A+ qualified May 22, 2023; 253G2 August 2023; 1-U October 27, 2023 officer resignations; no 1-K). tZERO Group (TZROP; above).
- *Offerings shelf, prior, unfiled under the card name: Quarter Homes (platform: $147.2M valuation cap and $147.2M goal at 100% funded, closed April 20, 2026, $50,000 / $1,000,000), RSRV Aspen, LLC ($16M cap, closed November 21, 2024, $25,000 / $1,600,000; distinct from Aspen Digital, Inc. CIK 1694997, Form D 2019 $125,000 / 125 investors), Park Street Development Group (Tuscany National Resort & Club, Cortona), McNeill Investment Group ($500M AUM claim), Emmis Capital. Every deal page's Financials tab: 'coming soon'.
- *Investor fees (September 4, 2026): 1% per execution at or above $3.00 a share, $0.03 a share below; no other trading fees; up to 7% non-refundable processing fee per primary commitment; no account, maintenance or inactivity fees; institutional custody fee by separate agreement; debit balances Fed Funds + 125 bps; returned items and domestic wires $25, international wires $50, paper statements $5; ACH held 15 business days; no proprietary trading ('We act as an agent'); no payment-for-order-flow disclosure found; Form CRS disciplinary history: Yes (tZERO Securities), No (tZERO DAS).
- *Secondary screen, September 12, 2026, 7:22 AM (logged out): ASPD 2.50 / 1.10 / 2.40 / vol 0; OTKNP 6.50 / 5.50 / 7.49 / 0; CURZ 0.75 / 0.01 / 0.75 / 0; ENFD 1.75 / 1.30 / 1.75 / 0; GLDX greyed; NXHBP 9.15 / 7.00 / 9.15 / 0; footnote: price is the later of last trade or issuer-struck NAV.
- *Corporate events: SPBD approval September 10 to 12, 2024; Konevsky CEO September 4, 2025; CFTC DCO/DCM applications September 19, 2025 (undecided); FINRA corporate-debt approval September 2025; 24/7 order entry December 15, 2025; Sui integration and Siebert partnership August 2026; ICE memorandum August 31, 2026; Securitize v. tZERO (D. Del. 1:26-cv-00722) filed June 22, 2026, counterclaims July 17, 2026, pending; authorized shares to 1.1B by 90.8% written consent effective May 1, 2026.
AltStreet Data Layer
AltStreet offerings census + FOCUS ingestion + FINRA volume series (September 2026)
AltStreet's tZERO dataset is an infrastructure census, not an investor-returns ledger: seventeen deal rows (sixteen offering cards plus Zion Peaks), fourteen Form D, Form C-U and 1-Z filing snapshots, eight ingested offering documents, ten linked CIKs (the parent, three broker-dealers and six issuers), both broker-dealers' FOCUS figures and the FINRA weekly series. No investor-level return exists in any public source for any tZERO-placed token; TZROP's eight-year zero-dividend record is the only completed retail outcome.
- Offerings: 16 cards on tzero.com/trade (4 current, 12 prior) + Zion Peaks = 17 deal rows · 8 offering documents ingested (BRYTR PPM and white paper, KNOWPIA, Kondoo, C3 Bullion, Aurox, Commercial Strategies, Zion Peaks)
- Filed outcomes: Commercial Strategies $466,520 · Zion Peaks $395,920 · Aurox $327,356 · Spirits Capital $0 of $35M qualified · FINTECH.TV no C-U · Invest Inc. no 1-K · KNOWPIA $0 since 2023 · BRYTR $0 at April 2026 · 6 of 16 cards with no EDGAR filing (5 prior + Kondoo)
- ATS volume (FINRA, MPID PROS): $28.9M (2022) · $9.5M (2023) · $6.0M (2024) · $5.9M (2025, TZROP 96%) · $1.6M (2026 to Aug 3) · post-TZROP weeks 32 to 3,917 shares
- Broker-dealers (Dec 31, 2025): tZERO Securities net capital $521,737, revenue $418,088, TZROP 40% · tZERO DAS net capital $635,723, revenue $204,121, TZROP 74% · both economically dependent on parent
- Parent (last public, FY2023): revenue $1.63M · net loss $29.5M · cash $43.2M · going concern · Beyond carrying value $15.5M for 26% (FY2025), 22% direct at June 2026
- TZROP: $75.9M / 920 investors (2018) · 0 dividends declared · converted May 2026 at 3 Series B + 8 common (Dahn equivalence 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common) · 84.6% of votes cast in favor · 21,152,297 tokens at record date
- Regulatory: SEC 3-20699 (2022) $800K willful Reg ATS order, sole BrokerCheck disclosure · FY2023 FOCUS material-weakness flag · tZERO Markets terminated Dec 2024 · Securitize patent suit pending
- Fees: investor 1% per trade / $0.03 under $3, up to 7% primary processing, no account fees · issuer 4% + 1% + $25,000 + $1,000 + $10,000 + $2,000/mo + $20/investor + 35 bps custody + $7,500 smart contract (BRYTR PPM)
- Secondary screen Sept 12, 2026: 6 listings, volume 0 on every row, bid/ask gaps 5% to 118% of bid; every deal page Financials tab 'coming soon'
Source: FINRA OTC Transparency + SEC EDGAR (CIKs 1193821, 1909301, 1779408, 1726726, 1130713 and the issuers) + tZERO public disclosures + tzero.com capture (2026-09-12) + platform screenshots + AltStreet platform database, September 2026
Primary Source Pages
Comparable Platforms
- Securitize
Institutional tokenized funds (BUIDL, Hamilton Lane, Apollo, KKR) on a transfer-agent-first stack with a clean record; product where tZERO has licenses.
- North Capital
Carrying broker-dealer, escrow and the PPEX ATS behind conventional alt platforms, with customer-money capital an order of magnitude above tZERO's affiliates and one resolved $40K AWC.
- DealMaker
Issuer-side raise technology and broker of record with no venue: the comparison for tZERO's placement business, at higher fees and far larger raise volumes.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
High-intent search questions answered directly, without making users hunt through the full review.
What is tZERO and how does it work?
tZERO is regulated infrastructure for tokenized securities, born inside Overstock.com in 2014 and now part-owned by Beyond, Inc. (22% direct) and Intercontinental Exchange. Its subsidiaries hold the licenses: tZERO Securities, LLC is a FINRA broker-dealer that operates an SEC-regulated alternative trading system for digital asset securities (since 2019) and acts as placement agent, broker of record and escrow agent on token offerings; tZERO Digital Asset Securities, LLC is a special purpose broker-dealer approved in September 2024 to custody digital securities; the group also runs an SEC-registered transfer agent, an issuance platform, an exempt reporting adviser and a CFTC introducing broker. Issuers pay tZERO to tokenize and sell their securities under Reg D, Reg A+ or Reg CF; investors open a brokerage account on platform.tzero.com, subscribe, hold the token at the affiliate custodian or in a permitted wallet, and can trade it on the ATS if a counterparty appears.
Is tZERO legit and safe?
The licenses are real and current: SEC-regulated ATS, FINRA member broker-dealer, special purpose broker-dealer custodian, SEC transfer agent, with audited annual filings for both broker-dealers. The regulatory record has one event: the SEC's January 2022 order finding tZERO ATS willfully violated Regulation ATS by sharing order-book data with two third parties without timely disclosure and lacking fair-access standards, settled for $800,000 and censure. Three cautions matter more than that history. The two broker-dealers investors deal with ended 2025 with $521,737 and $635,723 of net capital, earned 40% and 74% of their revenue from the parent's own token, and state that they depend on the parent for funding; the parent's last public audit (FY2023) carried a going-concern note. The custodian's Form CRS says SIPC protections may not apply to digital asset securities. And tZERO's own TZROP token, sold to 920 retail investors for $75.9 million, never had its contingent dividend declared and was converted in 2026 into 3 Series B plus 8 common per token, with the $10 floor and continuous trading surrendered. Legitimate, licensed, thin, and no substitute for underwriting the issuer.
What fees does tZERO charge investors?
Per the fee schedule effective September 4, 2026: 1% commission on each buy or sell of securities priced at $3.00 a share or more, or $0.03 a share on securities under $3.00; a non-refundable processing fee of up to 7% per primary-offering investment commitment; no account opening, maintenance, inactivity or retail custody fees; $25 for domestic wires and returned items, $50 for international wires, $5 for paper statements; debit balances at Fed Funds plus 125 basis points; ACH deposits held 15 business days before withdrawal. Issuers separately pay a placement stack (in the BRYTR PPM: 4% plus 1% of gross, $25,000 advisory, $1,000 escrow, $10,000 setup, $2,000 a month, $20 per investor, 35 basis points of custody with a $1,500 monthly minimum, $7,500 per smart contract) that comes out of the proceeds funding the business.
Can I actually sell tokens on the tZERO ATS?
In principle yes, in practice rarely. FINRA's weekly transparency data for the venue (MPID PROS) shows notional traded falling from $28.9 million in 2022 to $5.9 million in 2025, of which 96% was tZERO's own TZROP token. TZROP converted into ordinary stock and stopped trading in May 2026; the week after, the entire ATS reported 32 shares, and the weeks through early August 2026 ranged from 63 to 3,917 shares across five listings. On September 12, 2026 the logged-out secondary screen showed six listings with zero volume on every row and quoted gaps such as $1.10 bid against $2.40 ask on Aspen Digital. tZERO now runs semi-annual auctions for its own former token because continuous trading had no depth. Assume any tZERO-listed token is illiquid.
What happened to the TZROP token?
TZROP was tZERO's Series A preferred security token, sold under Rule 506(c) in 2017 and 2018: $250 million offered, $75,905,562 sold to 920 investors. It carried a noncumulative dividend of 10% of adjusted gross revenue, conditioned on GAAP net income exceeding 10% of gross profit, and a redemption right at not less than $10.00 per token. The April 2026 consent solicitation states that no dividend was ever declared. Management proposed converting each TZROP into 3 Series B preferred shares (April 7, 2026), enhanced the offer to 3 Series B plus 8 common (April 16), and published a Dahn Consulting summary putting one TZROP's fair-value equivalence at 1.13 Series B or 2.76 common. On April 29, 1,594 holders voted 15,164,076 tokens (72.2% turnout), 84.6% in favor. Holders received Series B preferred with a 1.25x preference on a $0.5497 issue price, plus common, and semi-annual ATS auctions, and gave up the $10 floor, the dividend right and continuous trading. TZROP last traded the week of May 4, 2026.
What offerings are on tZERO right now?
Four cards were current on September 12, 2026. CarbonEnfo's $BRYTR token (BRYTR, LLC): $4.5 million at $1.00, a 12% share of net platform revenue from a solar-credit marketplace capped at $3.00 per token, Rule 506(c), $10,000 minimum; the Form D of April 17, 2026 reports nothing sold and CarbonEnfo had no material revenue at December 31, 2025. Kondoo Digital GmbH's Amana token: 400 million gaming tokens at $1.44 to $1.56, $100,000 minimum, no equity or dividend rights, sold by a Swiss company with no Form D on EDGAR. KNOWPIA's KNOWP preferred: up to 300 million shares at $0.01, $3 million maximum, $1 million minimum extended twice to June 30, 2026, with a PPM that says the company may go out of business without the raise and a Form D showing nothing sold since December 2023. C3 Bullion's $40 million Reg A+ at $5.00, listed as inactive pending updated documents after a CEO change and a share-surrender settlement. Twelve prior cards include tZERO's own TZROP, two Beyond, Inc. brand tokens, Aurox, Spirits Capital and six deals with no SEC filing under their names.
How much money have tZERO offerings raised?
Outside tZERO's own TZROP ($75.9 million in 2018) and its parent's affiliates, very little that filings can verify. Commercial Strategies' Overstock IP token raised $466,520 and Zion Peaks' buybuy BABY token $395,920 in 2025; both are Beyond, Inc. subsidiaries placed by tZERO Securities. Aurox Holdings reported $327,356 of Reg CF commitments in March 2023 through tZERO Markets, an intermediary since terminated. Spirits Capital qualified a $35 million Reg A+ with tZERO ATS as escrow agent in November 2023 and reported zero shares sold on its June 2024 Form 1-Z. FINTECH.TV targeted $10,000 and filed no completion report; Invest Inc. qualified a Reg A+ in 2023 and has filed no annual report since; KNOWPIA's Form D has shown nothing sold for 33 months; BRYTR reported nothing sold at its April 2026 Form D. Quarter Homes' page shows a $147.2 million goal at 100% funded, but the same figure sits in the valuation-cap field and no Form D exists under that name, so AltStreet does not treat it as verified.
Who owns tZERO?
Beyond, Inc. (formerly Overstock.com, renamed on EDGAR to Bed Bath & Beyond, Inc. in 2025 and Neighborhood Intelligence, Inc. in August 2026) held 22% directly at June 30, 2026 and 38.7% combined with its indirect stake through Medici Ventures, L.P., down from 49.4% before the TZROP conversion; it carries the direct stake at $15.5 million. Intercontinental Exchange led the February 2022 Series B (about $70.6 million net raised that year, 140.9 million Series B shares) and describes itself as a significant minority shareholder; its exact stake is undisclosed. Former TZROP holders own about 30.6% on a fully diluted basis after the May 2026 conversion. Beyond offered up to $10 million of convertible notes in April 2026 and ICE announced a further investment of undisclosed size in August 2026. Alan Konevsky is CEO and chairman; Matt Mosman chaired the board at the September 2025 leadership change.
Has tZERO been in trouble with regulators?
Once, on the record. In January 2022 the SEC found that tZERO ATS, LLC had shared information about its order book with two third parties without making timely Form ATS disclosures and had operated without written fair-access standards when Regulation ATS required them, a willful violation of Rules 301(b)(2) and (5); the firm was censured, ordered to cease and desist, and paid $800,000. That is the only disclosure on FINRA BrokerCheck for the broker-dealer, and the reason its Form CRS answers 'Yes' to disciplinary history. The SEC's Division of Enforcement also investigated the 2017 to 2018 TZROP offering and Overstock's 2019 digital dividend from 2018 through at least 2021; Overstock disclosed the investigations through its FY2023 10-K and dropped the disclosure afterward with no order and no public closing letter. Securities class actions against Overstock over the dividend were dismissed and affirmed by the Tenth Circuit in October 2024. A patent dispute with Securitize (filed June 2026) is pending and is a commercial matter. AltStreet found no FINRA fines, state actions or customer complaints in any record it searched.
Who should use tZERO, and who should not?
Use it if you are an accredited investor who has already underwritten a specific tZERO-placed issuer from its PPM and EDGAR record and needs a licensed US venue to subscribe and custody through, if you already hold a token that trades nowhere else, or if you are an issuer who wants the most complete bundled compliance stack in the US market and can afford its fees. Do not use it if you expect to be able to sell (the venue trades tens to a few thousand shares a week), if you are reading 'revenue share' as income (the venue's own token paid nothing in eight years), if you treat a license as diligence (six of the sixteen deals have no SEC filing, and the current ones describe pre-revenue or going-concern businesses), or if you are uncomfortable holding assets at an affiliate custodian with $635,723 of net capital and an SIPC caveat. Tokenized Treasury and credit funds live at Securitize; conventional alt-platform plumbing lives at North Capital; tZERO is the licenses with a thin shelf behind them.
