Lofty vs Arrived: Returns, Fees and How You Sell Your Investment
Both sell fractions of single U.S. rental houses to small investors. Lofty (Lofty AI, Inc.) sells tokens in member-run LLCs and lets you trade them at any hour; Arrived (formerly Arrived Homes) sells shares in manager-run series under Regulation A and opens a trading window once a month. This guide compares them on Lofty's own trade and yield data, Arrived's help center and SEC filings, and a worked example of what you keep after you sell.
Guide Thesis
The exit price matters more than the payout schedule.
Lofty: 2.5% to buy, 3% to sell, orders any time, 63 of 81 tokens last traded below original listing price (October 5, 2026). Arrived: $100 minimum, monthly one-week windows after a six-month hold, up to 2.5% per side, 6% to 7% when the house is sold.
Most comparisons stop at daily rent against monthly dividends. In AltStreet's $1,000 worked example, daily rather than monthly payout is worth only cents a year; a 10% change in exit price changes the result by roughly $100.
Lofty lets you place an order any time and publishes what its tokens trade at; Arrived opens a window each month. Neither guarantees a buyer at your price.

The Core Decision
More exit access, or more formal disclosure.
Lofty offers continuous order entry, public trade prices and a vote on every major property decision; AltStreet located no SEC filings or audited financial statements for its current property LLCs, and the operating agreements reviewed disclaim fiduciary duties among members. Arrived offers audited Regulation A issuers and a manager that runs every house, with exits limited to monthly windows and less public price evidence. The individual-property products sell very similar exposure; what differs is how you get out and who stands behind the numbers.
When You Can Sell
Lofty: any time
Lofty accepts orders around the clock with no holding period. Arrived opens one-week windows each month for individual properties held at least six months. A sale on either still needs a buyer at your price.
Public Trade Prices
Lofty
Lofty's trade records are public: 63 of 81 property tokens last traded below original listing price on October 5, 2026. Arrived shows trades inside its platform; AltStreet located no public trade-level data.
SEC Filings
Arrived
Arrived's issuers file under Regulation A Tier 2 with audited annual reports (issuer-level going-concern paragraphs at eight of nine in FY2025). AltStreet located no SEC filing for Lofty or its current property LLCs.
TL;DR
The difference in two sentences
Lofty sells tokens of about $50 in member-run Wyoming LLCs, pays rent daily in USDC when a property produces it, charges 2.5% to buy and 3% to sell, and lets you trade at any hour on a secondary marketplace where 63 of 81 tokens last traded below original listing price on October 5, 2026; AltStreet located no SEC filing for it. Arrived sells $100 minimum interests in manager-run Regulation A series with audited annual reports, pays monthly dividends after expenses and reserves, and lets eligible shares trade for one week a month at up to 2.5% per side, with a 6% to 7% disposition fee when the house itself is sold.
If you read nothing else: scroll to the head-to-head comparison sections →
Lofty is structurally oriented toward
- → Access for investors outside the United States, which Arrived does not accept
- → Property data rooms, yield histories and public trade records
- → Order entry on any day, with no holding period
- → USDC settlement and token-holder votes on property decisions
Arrived is structurally oriented toward
- → Centralized management of every property, for U.S. investors
- → Filed offering circulars and audited issuer statements
- → Checkbook IRA and Solo 401(k) access
- → Exits through monthly windows or the eventual property sale
63 of 81
Lofty tokens last traded below original listing price
Median 29% below, 26 at half or less (Lofty trade data, October 5, 2026). Original listing price is not any holder's cost basis; later buyers paid other prices.
1 week a month
Arrived secondary-market trading window
Limit orders only, after a six-month hold on a fully funded property; unmatched orders are canceled when the window closes (Arrived help center, 2026 calendar).
5.4% vs 4.9%
Round-trip trading fees at an unchanged price
Lofty limit orders (2.5% in, 3% out) against Arrived's ceiling of 2.5% per side. AltStreet arithmetic on cash paid; Lofty market orders add a 2.5% market-maker fee.
Bottom Line Up Front
The two platforms sell very similar exposure, a fraction of one rental house, and finance and govern it very differently. Arrived puts each house in a series of a Regulation A issuer, has a manager run it, files audited annual reports and carries issuer-level going-concern paragraphs at eight of its nine issuers in FY2025. Lofty puts each house in a member-run Wyoming DAO LLC, publishes rich property data and trade records, and has no SEC filings that AltStreet could locate.
The comparison investors usually run, daily rent against monthly dividends, barely matters. What matters is net rent after every cost plus what you receive when you leave. On stated trading fees the two are within about half a percentage point of each other. The larger variable is the sale price: Lofty's public record shows most tokens trading below their original listing price, and Arrived publishes no comparable record.
The mistake to avoid is specific to each. On Lofty, do not read the 9.2% headline or a property page's all-time average as what you will earn; look at the last twelve months and the last trades. On Arrived, do not read a monthly window as an exit you control; it is an opportunity to meet a buyer, and the house itself is sold on the manager's timeline with a 6% to 7% fee.
Head to Head
Lofty vs Arrived, section by section
A token in a member-run LLC vs a share in a manager-run series
Lofty vs Arrived: Ownership and Structure
Both platforms sell fractional interests in single U.S. rental houses, and on both the investor owns an interest in a company that owns the house rather than title to it. The difference is who runs that company. Each Lofty property sits in its own Wyoming DAO LLC whose membership interests are issued as Algorand tokens; token holders vote on managers, repairs, loans and sales, most major decisions need a 60% supermajority, and the operating agreements AltStreet read state that no member owes a fiduciary duty and that the smart contract governs if it conflicts with the agreement. Each Arrived property is a separate series of a Delaware series LLC, offered under Regulation A Tier 2, and Arrived Fund Manager LLC makes the decisions: leasing, property managers, reserves, refinancing and the eventual sale. This is the tokenized real estate vs fractional real estate question in practice: the token changes how the interest is recorded and traded, while governance and disclosure come from the legal structure around it.
| What you hold | Lofty: a membership interest in one property's Wyoming DAO LLC, issued as an Algorand token. Arrived: shares in one series of a Delaware series LLC (for example Arrived Homes LLC), recorded on Arrived's ledger. |
|---|---|
| Who decides | Lofty: token holders by vote (60% supermajority for major decisions); managers chosen and paid by that vote, at 5% to 30% of collected rent in the agreements AltStreet read. Arrived: Arrived Fund Manager LLC; property management of 6% of rents with an $84 monthly minimum (Mynd) or $70 a month flat (Marketplace Homes) on Core single-family series, per the FY2025 Form 1-K. |
| SEC status | Lofty: no SEC registration statement, Regulation A or crowdfunding filing, or Form D located for Lofty or its current property LLCs (October 5, 2026); California's DFPI entered a consent order in November 2022 over interests in at least 75 earlier Lofty-managed LLCs. Arrived: nine Regulation A Tier 2 issuers filing Forms 1-K, 1-SA and 1-U, audited by Stephano Slack LLC. |
| Ownership caps | Lofty: 15% of a property's tokens per investor. Arrived: 9.8% of a property's equity per investor, to protect REIT qualification. |
Verdict
Lofty gives holders direct governance rights, while the operating agreements AltStreet reviewed disclaim fiduciary duties among members. Arrived places the decisions with a single manager operating under a filed offering circular and audited issuer statements. Neither gives you title to the house.
Two published figures built two different ways
Lofty vs Arrived: Returns and Rental Income
Neither platform publishes a realized total return that can be set beside the other's. Lofty publishes, for every property, a monthly rental yield: that month's rent, annualized, over the value of the rent-earning tokens at the month's lowest traded price. Its marketing cites a 9.2% marketplace average rental yield for May 2026 without publishing a method; AltStreet could reproduce it, at 9.19%, only as aggregate rent over aggregate token value across the 46 of 76 listings that reported May rent, and the same calculation over all 76 gives 6.80% (4.90% on original listing prices). Arrived's help center gives an estimated 6% to 10% annual total return and a 3% to 5% income portion for single-family properties, built from 20-year Zillow appreciation and Arrived dividend yields through Q1 2023, and it states that the income range excludes properties not receiving a monthly dividend. Both headline income figures therefore leave out non-paying properties: Arrived says so; for Lofty it is AltStreet's reproduction of an unpublished method. Rental yield is not return in either case; total return is rent plus or minus the change in price.
| Published yield | Lofty: 9.2% marketplace average for May 2026 (method not published); property pages show an all-time average, median 7.56%. Arrived: estimated 3% to 5% income portion and 6% to 10% total for single-family, a hypothetical construction dated to Q1 2023 inputs. |
|---|---|
| AltStreet measurement | Lofty: median trailing-twelve-month rental income 3.47% of original listing price and 5.02% on Lofty's basis; 11 properties reported no rent in any of those twelve months (October 5, 2026). Arrived: no public per-series yield series was compiled for this guide; the FY2025 filings report issuer-level results, not per-house yields. |
| Payout timing | Lofty: daily, around midnight UTC, in USDC, when the property produces rent. Arrived: monthly, typically around the 25th for the prior month, after expenses and reserves; new properties may take 30 to 90 days to start. |
| What stops income | Both: vacancy, eviction, repairs and reserve rebuilding. Lofty: 34 of 74 properties with a September 2026 record reported no rent that month. Arrived: its help center says vacancy 'typically suspends dividends'. |
Verdict
Both headline income measures can look better because non-paying properties are not in them: Arrived says its income range excludes them, and AltStreet could reproduce Lofty's 9.2% only by leaving them out. Do not rank the two on their headline yields; compare a property's net rent after every cost with what you could realistically sell it for, which is what the worked example below does.
The full cost of getting in, holding and getting out
Lofty vs Arrived: Fees
Fractional real estate investing fees come in three layers on both platforms: what you pay to get in, what the property pays every year before you see rent, and what you pay to get out. Lofty charges investors 2.5% on share purchases and 3% on share sales and no annual management fee; its properties pay their managers 5% to 30% of collected rent and, on most listings, LLC administration of about $550 to $650 upfront and $750 a year. Lofty's market orders add a 2.5% market-maker fee on top, paid to the users who supply its liquidity pool (help center, archived May 9, 2026); limit orders do not carry it. Arrived charges no separate buyer fee on new offerings, but its $10 offering price already includes closing costs, escrow fees and a one-time sourcing fee; each single-family property pays an asset management fee of 0.15% of the purchase price per quarter (0.6% a year) and property management; the secondary market carries up to 2.5% per side to its executing broker; and a property sale carries a 6% to 7% disposition fee. Arrived's own help center says it receives agent rebates from sellers when it buys a property.
| Getting in | Lofty: listing or market price plus a 2.5% purchase fee; in 25 of 38 listings from 2024 or 2025 with an appraisal in the data room, the offering price was 105% of that appraisal's as-is value. Arrived: $10 a share on new offerings with acquisition costs and sourcing fee built into the price; secondary purchases at your limit price plus up to 2.5%. |
|---|---|
| Holding | Lofty: no investor management fee; property-paid managers (5% to 30% of collected rent) and LLC administration. Arrived: 0.6% a year of purchase price on single-family series, plus property management; Arrived's help center says the asset management fee ranges from 0.1% to 0.30% per quarter by product. |
| Selling one position | Lofty: 3% sale fee on limit orders; market orders fill at the best available bid and add a 2.5% market-maker fee paid to liquidity-pool lenders. Arrived: up to 2.5% on the sell side (help center, March 20, 2026); an October 2, 2025 article describes a 1% broker-dealer fee and a 1% ATS fee per transaction paid to third parties. |
| Whole-property sale | Lofty: by member vote; costs set per sale, not by a platform schedule (one July 2026 governance proposal priced a sale coordinated by ECO Systems at 1.5% of the gross price). Arrived: 6% to 7% disposition fee of the gross sale price, covering brokerage, title, escrow and closing costs. |
| Dollar conversion | Lofty: trades settle in USDC; Lofty's disclaimer says proceeds can be converted to USD through third-party cryptocurrency exchanges, which may carry their own costs. Arrived: proceeds go to the Arrived Cash Balance; Arrived says withdrawing it carries no fee. |
Verdict
On stated trading fees the two are close: about 5.4% round trip on Lofty limit orders at an unchanged price, against up to about 4.9% on Arrived's secondary market. Lofty's market orders add a 2.5% market-maker fee, and Arrived's property sale costs 6% to 7%. The spread between what you pay and what you can sell for is usually the larger cost on both.
Continuous orders vs monthly windows, both buyer-dependent
Lofty vs Arrived: Liquidity and the Secondary Market
This is the strongest practical difference between the two platforms, and neither design on its own establishes that you can exit at a price you would accept. Lofty lets you place a market or limit order at any hour, with no holding period, and uses market makers to fill market orders. In the 30 days to October 5, 2026, 78 of 81 Lofty property tokens recorded at least one completed trade, and the median property traded about 0.95% of its tokens in that period (AltStreet arithmetic on Lofty's public trade records); 63 of 81 last traded below original listing price, the median 29% below and 26 at half or less. Arrived opens its secondary market for one week a month (October 9 to 16, November 6 to 13 and December 4 to 11 on its 2026 calendar, which it says may change), accepts only limit orders, cancels unmatched orders when the window closes, and limits each buyer to $1,000 or twice their Arrived holdings per month, which caps how much demand can arrive in any one window. Sellers may list at up to twice the current Arrived Valuation; Arrived says most trades are 'anticipated' near that valuation and that it does not set prices.
| When orders can trade | Lofty: any time, no holding period. Arrived: one-week windows monthly, Monday to Friday 9:30 AM to 5:00 PM ET; the order book opens the Friday before matching begins. |
|---|---|
| Eligibility | Lofty: any verified account. Arrived: property fully funded and shares held at least six months; the investor's first Arrived investment at least 60 days before the window; shares bought in a window must be held until the next one. |
| Order types | Lofty: market orders (instant, best available price, market makers) and limit orders. Arrived: limit orders only, matched on price then time priority; execution price is set by whichever order was placed first. |
| Settlement | Lofty: USDC on fill. Arrived: typically 7 to 10 business days into the Arrived Cash Balance; Arrived says sellers are paid even if a buyer's payment fails. |
| Price evidence | Lofty: public trade records; 63 of 81 tokens last traded below original listing (October 5, 2026). Arrived: open orders and recent trades shown in-platform; AltStreet located no public trade-level data. Arrived Valuation, updated quarterly from 12 months after an offering, now excludes sales costs (help center, April 28, 2026). |
| Funds | Lofty: no fund product. Arrived: its pooled funds use a quarterly redemption program at NAV after six months, subject to approval and capacity, with a 1% fee for shares held six months to three years. |
Verdict
Lofty gives you more chances to sell and shows you what tokens actually trade at; that record shows most trading below original listing price. Arrived gives you twelve windows a year and less public price evidence. A conservative liquidity assumption is that a secondary-market exit may not be available at an acceptable price, so investors should understand the eventual property-sale mechanics as well.
Who can invest, what arrives in January, and what can go wrong
Lofty vs Arrived: Eligibility, Taxes and Risk
Arrived is open only to U.S. citizens and green card holders who live in the 50 states; Lofty accepts international investors except residents of sanctioned countries, applies U.S. withholding to non-U.S. investors and asks treaty-country investors for a W-8BEN. Both issue a 1099-DIV rather than a K-1. Lofty says it consolidates every property onto one 1099-DIV plus one 1099-B for sales; Arrived describes a 'summarized' 1099-DIV and consolidated 1099-Bs, with single-family series intending to elect REIT status and vacation rentals taxed as corporations. The risk profiles differ in kind. Lofty's are disclosure and governance risks: no SEC filings or audited statements located for its current property LLCs, member fiduciary duties disclaimed in the agreements reviewed, offerings priced above appraisal, and 2026 proposals for related-party credit at cash-short properties. Arrived's are sponsor and fee risks: issuer-level going-concern paragraphs at eight non-Debt-Fund issuers in FY2025, a manager-calculated valuation that is not GAAP fair value, affiliate fees, and a parent company that does not file public financials.
| Eligibility | Lofty: U.S. and international investors except residents of sanctioned countries, 18 or older, identity verified. Arrived: U.S. citizens or green card holders residing in the 50 states, 18 or older; non-accredited investors subject to the Regulation A Tier 2 10% limit. |
|---|---|
| Tax forms | Lofty: one consolidated 1099-DIV, one 1099-B if you sold (per Lofty); property LLC tax classification not established by AltStreet. Arrived: 1099-DIV by end of January; one or two consolidated 1099-Bs for secondary sales, reported as non-covered securities. |
| Retirement accounts | Lofty: not offered. Arrived: checkbook IRAs and Solo 401(k)s accepted; Arrived says REIT-taxed investments are exempt from UBIT. |
| Audit and filings | Lofty: no audited financial statements or SEC filing located for the current property LLCs; public per-property data rooms. Arrived: audited Form 1-K per issuer, semiannual 1-SA, current 1-U reports. |
Verdict
Non-U.S. investors have only one of these two options. U.S. investors choosing between them are choosing between more data with fewer formal protections (Lofty) and more formal disclosure with less control (Arrived).
Hypothetical worked example
$1,000 in, five years, three ways out
This example is hypothetical. It does not describe any real property or predict any result. It holds the property economics identical on both platforms so that only the platform mechanics differ. Assumptions: you buy $1,000 of interests at the offering price ($10 a share on Arrived, the listing price on Lofty) in one unlevered single-family rental worth $250,000; rent left after taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancy and property management equals 4.0% of the offering value a year on both; Arrived then charges its 0.6% a year asset management fee on purchase price, and the Lofty LLC pays $750 a year of administration (0.3% of $250,000); you hold five years, the property's value does not change, rent is not reinvested and taxes are ignored. Each fee is applied as a percentage of the trade value. Both offering prices already embed acquisition costs (Arrived's closing costs and sourcing fee; on Lofty, for 25 of 38 recent listings with an appraisal, a price 5% above the appraisal's as-is value), which the example does not separate.
| Arrived | Lofty | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash paid for $1,000 of interests | $1,000 (no separate buyer fee on a new offering) | $1,025 ($1,000 plus the 2.5% purchase fee) |
| Net rent over five years | $170 ($40 a year less $6 asset management) | $185 ($40 a year less $3 LLC administration) |
| Exit 1: secondary sale at the offering price | $975 after up to 2.5%; total $1,145, gain $145 | $970 after 3% (limit order); total $1,155, gain $130 |
| Exit 2: secondary sale 10% below the offering price | $877.50 after up to 2.5%; total $1,047.50, gain $47.50 | $873 after 3% (limit order); total $1,058, gain $33 |
| Exit 2 as a Lofty market order (2.5% market-maker fee on top of the 3%) | Not applicable (limit orders only) | $850.50; total $1,035.50, gain $10.50. The market-maker fee is charged on top of the platform fee, per Lofty's help center (archived May 9, 2026). |
| Exit 3: the house is sold at its original value | $940 after a 6% disposition fee (low end of 6% to 7%); total $1,110, gain $110 | Unknown: Lofty has no platform-wide sale-cost schedule (one July 2026 governance proposal priced sale coordination at 1.5%, which is not a platform norm). For illustration only, applying the same 6% assumption would leave $940; total $1,125, gain $100 |
| Value of daily vs monthly payout | Paying the same rent daily instead of monthly around the 25th of the following month is worth roughly 15 to 20 cents a year here, at a 4% reinvestment rate. | |
| What the example leaves out | Leverage, vacancies, price changes in the house, taxes, USDC conversion costs on Lofty, and the chance that no buyer appears in a window or at your limit price. Lofty's public record puts the median last trade 29% below original listing price, far beyond the 10% discount assumed in Exit 2; Arrived publishes no comparable figure. | |
Read across a row and, on limit orders, the two platforms land within about $15 of each other. Read down a column and the exit moves the result by about $100 on the same platform. Under these assumptions, the price you can sell at decides more than any fee line or payout schedule.
AltStreet Terminal
Do this comparison before you invest.
The figures above come from filings, a platform's own published data and its help center, each dated. AltStreet Terminal tracks the filings, fee structures, redemption terms, trade records and related-party disclosures behind 100+ alternative-investment platforms, property by property, so the next comparison you run starts from the record.
Which costs less to get in and out of, Lofty or Arrived?
Short answer
On stated fees, Lofty costs about 5.4% of the cash you put in to buy and sell with limit orders at an unchanged price (2.5% in, 3% out), and Arrived up to about 4.9% to buy and sell on its secondary market (up to 2.5% per side), or up to 2.5% if you bought in the original offering. Lofty's current page does not explicitly reconcile its 2.5% market-maker charge with the 2.5% purchase and 3% sale fees, but an archived Lofty help-center article states that market orders incur additional fees paid to liquidity providers. A sale of the whole house costs 6% to 7% on Arrived. The sale price, not the fee, is usually the larger cost.
Lofty's how-it-works page, read on October 5 and again on October 6, 2026, states the fees two ways. The fee summary says "2.5% on purchases, 3% on sales." The trading section describes two order types: market orders, which "Buy or sell right away at the best available price" and "Include a 2.5% fee paid to market makers for instant execution", and limit orders, which fill "when another investor matches it." The page does not say how the two fit together, but Lofty's own help center did: its lending article (archived May 9, 2026) says users trading with market orders "end up paying more fees than with Limit orders. The extra fees are given directly to users who loaned out assets to the liquidity pool." So the market-maker fee is an addition, paid to liquidity providers rather than to Lofty. A limit buy costs your price plus 2.5%, a limit sell your price less 3%, and a market order adds the 2.5% market-maker fee plus the gap between the best available price and the last trade. The purchase fee itself has changed: the help center's "How Lofty Makes Money" article (archived December 8, 2025) listed a 3% marketplace fee on buy orders as well as sell orders; the page now says 2.5% on purchases. Lofty's terms also make users responsible for blockchain network fees unless an offer says otherwise, and sale proceeds arrive in USDC.
Arrived states its secondary-market fee two ways as well. An article dated March 20, 2026 says its executing broker "may receive up to 2.5% on the buy side and 2.5% on the sell side of each transaction", with specific fees shown in the platform during each window. An article dated October 2, 2025 describes "a 1% Broker Dealer Fee and a 1% Alternative Trading System (ATS) Fee" per transaction, paid to third parties, with no revenue to Arrived. AltStreet uses the 2.5% ceiling in this guide; at 2% per side the round trip at an unchanged price would be about 3.9%. Original-offering buyers pay no separate buyer fee, because sourcing, closing and escrow costs are built into the $10 share price.
Fees are only the visible part of the exit cost. On Lofty, 63 of 81 property tokens last traded below their original listing price on October 5, 2026, and an original buyer selling at those prices would realize a price loss before counting rent received and fees; buyers who came in later on the secondary marketplace have their own cost basis. On Arrived, sellers may list at up to twice the current Arrived Valuation and Arrived says most trades are "anticipated" near that valuation, but it publishes no trade-level record that would show where trades actually cleared.
Lofty vs Arrived returns: what do the published figures measure?
Short answer
Neither platform's headline income figure measures what a typical holder earned. Lofty's 9.2% May 2026 marketplace yield could be reproduced only by leaving out the 30 listings that paid no rent that month; the median property's trailing-twelve-month rental income was 3.47% of its original listing price. Arrived's 3% to 5% income range is an estimate built from Q1 2023 inputs and excludes properties not paying a monthly dividend. Neither is a total return, and the two cannot be ranked.
Lofty publishes more raw income data than Arrived: a monthly rent figure for every property and the token price used to compute its yield. AltStreet's Lofty review recomputed it with one method held constant and one input changed at a time. For May 2026, aggregate annualized rent over aggregate token value at each month's lowest traded price was 9.19% across the 46 listings that paid rent, 6.80% across all 76, and 4.90% against original listing prices. Lofty does not publish its method; that the headline matches the paying-only version is AltStreet's inference. Because the denominator is the month's lowest traded price, a falling token price raises the published yield even when rent is unchanged.
Arrived's help center frames returns as dividends plus appreciation, and its estimated 6% to 10% total for single-family properties assumes a seven-year hold, 6% disposition costs and 3% annual growth in net operating income, combined with 20-year Zillow home-price appreciation. It is useful as a description of what Arrived models, not as a record of what investors received. The income portion carries Arrived's own footnote: it "does not include properties that do not receive a monthly dividend" because of vacancies, evictions or major repairs. Arrived's per-property historical returns page was not compiled for this guide.
The AltStreet Take
Lofty and Arrived sell similar economic exposure, a small interest in one rental property, but package it very differently. Lofty gives holders continuous order entry, public trading data and direct governance, while Arrived provides Regulation A offering documents, audited issuer financials and centralized management. Neither structure guarantees liquidity. Lofty's own trade history shows why: most tokens in AltStreet's October snapshot last traded below their original listing price. Arrived offers only monthly trading windows and does not publish comparable trade-level data. The practical question is therefore not whether rent arrives daily or monthly; it is how much net income the property produces and what price a buyer will actually pay when you want out.
Lofty's answer is visible, and it is mostly below the original listing price. That is a finding about its market, and also a credit to its transparency: Arrived publishes nothing comparable, so the absence of a similar figure there is an absence of evidence, not evidence of better prices. Arrived's structure gives investors audited issuer statements and a manager accountable under filed offering circulars; it also brings issuer-level going-concern paragraphs, a manager-calculated valuation and a 6% to 7% fee when the house is sold.
The research-oriented reading of either platform is the same: each position is a single private rental house whose outcome depends on one tenant, one manager and one local market; the property's documents are the place to start; and the secondary market is an option with an unknown price rather than a dependable exit.
Lofty vs Arrived ownership and risks: what do you actually hold?
Short answer
On both platforms you own an interest in a company that owns the house. A Lofty token represents a membership interest in a Wyoming DAO LLC whose major decisions are governed by token-holder votes; the agreements reviewed disclaim member fiduciary duties, and AltStreet located no audited financial statements for the current property LLCs. An Arrived share is an interest in a series of a Delaware series LLC run by Arrived's manager and reported in audited Regulation A filings. The structures emphasize different risks: Lofty adds token-holder governance, thinner formal disclosure and blockchain and USDC mechanics; Arrived adds centralized sponsor control, manager-calculated valuations, affiliated fees and constrained trading windows. Both carry the property, liquidity and valuation risks of a single rental house.
Lofty's operating agreements, as AltStreet read them in the property data rooms, state that no member owes a fiduciary duty to the LLC or to other members, that the LLC will not indemnify anyone, and that the smart contract governs in a conflict with the agreement. Sellers often keep a stake, keep managing the property or commission the appraisal used to price it. In July 2026, draft governance packages proposed revolving credit at 12% simple interest plus a 2% origination fee from EARLDAO to property LLCs reporting negative cash positions; EARLDAO's authorized representative, ECO Systems, is named as manager in 10 of the 15 affected properties' data rooms. AltStreet located no SEC filing for Lofty or its current property LLCs, and California's 2022 consent order addressed interests in earlier Lofty-managed Delaware LLCs; the order does not settle the legal status of the current interests, and unregistered offerings can remain subject to anti-fraud rules.
Arrived's nine Regulation A issuers file audited annual reports. In FY2025, the eight issuers other than the Debt Fund carried going-concern explanatory paragraphs from their auditor, Stephano Slack LLC; the paragraphs concern each issuer's liquidity, with disclosed plans relying on operating cash flow, offering proceeds and financing from the manager, and they are not findings about property values. Arrived's valuation is calculated by its manager and is expressly not GAAP fair value, the sourcing, management and disposition fees flow to Arrived affiliates, and Arrived Holdings, the parent, does not file public financial statements. Arrived says that if it stopped operating, a new custodian would be assigned to make major decisions for each series.
Lofty vs Arrived taxes: which forms arrive, and how many?
Short answer
Both issue a 1099-DIV rather than a K-1. Lofty's tax documentation deserves clarification: its site says investors receive one consolidated 1099-DIV plus one 1099-B if they sold, while the operating agreements AltStreet reviewed contain partnership-style profit, loss and capital-account provisions; AltStreet did not establish the tax election of each property LLC. Arrived sends a summarized 1099-DIV by the end of January, says its single-family series intend to elect and qualify for REIT treatment while vacation-rental series are taxed as corporations, and consolidates secondary-market sales onto one or two 1099-Bs.
Lofty's pages describe one pre-filled 1099-DIV covering every property and, for investors who sold, a single 1099-B. Lofty's page also says investors benefit from depreciation and that rental income is taxed as ordinary income. AltStreet's review found operating agreements that allocate profits and losses under partnership capital-account rules alongside 1099-DIV reporting, and did not establish each LLC's federal tax classification; investors should confirm the treatment with a tax adviser rather than infer it from the form. Non-U.S. investors face U.S. withholding on gains and rent withdrawals.
Arrived's help center says each single-family property and the Single Family Residential Fund intend to elect REIT status, that depreciation is reflected in the net taxable amount on the 1099-DIV rather than broken out, and that vacation rentals are not REIT-eligible and are taxed as corporations. Secondary-market sales are reported as non-covered securities, so cost basis is not sent to the IRS; Arrived supplies it in a supplemental statement, computed as the original price less non-dividend distributions. For IRA investors, Arrived accepts checkbook IRAs and says REIT-taxed investments are exempt from UBIT; Lofty does not offer retirement accounts.
Frequently asked questions
Is Lofty or Arrived better for passive rental income?+
Neither platform pays steady income by design; on both, a property pays only when it has rent left after expenses. Arrived is the more hands-off of the two: its manager leases, manages and reserves for each house, and dividends are paid monthly after expenses and reserves, with vacancy typically suspending them (Arrived help center, 2025 and 2026 articles). On Lofty, token holders vote on managers, repairs, loans and sales, and rent is paid daily when the property produces it; in September 2026, 34 of 74 Lofty properties with a September record reported no rent, and the median property's rental income over the twelve months to October 5, 2026 equaled 3.47% of its original listing price. Arrived asks less of the investor; Lofty shows the investor more property-level data to check. Neither fact establishes which pays more.
Which platform delivers higher returns after all fees?+
AltStreet cannot establish that, because no like-for-like realized total-return series exists for both. Lofty publishes a monthly rental-yield series per property: the median property's trailing-twelve-month rental income was 3.47% of its original listing price and 5.02% on Lofty's basis of each month's lowest traded price (rental income only, as of October 5, 2026), while 63 of 81 tokens last traded below their original listing price. Arrived's help center gives an estimated 6% to 10% annual total return and a 3% to 5% income portion for its single-family strategy, built by combining 20-year Zillow home-price appreciation with Arrived's average dividend yields through Q1 2023; it is a hypothetical construction, not a realized return, and its income range excludes properties not paying a monthly dividend. The two figures use different methods and cannot be ranked. What decides your result on either platform is net rent after costs plus what you receive when you exit, after selling costs.
Does receiving rent daily produce better returns than less frequent distributions?+
Not in any material amount. Payment frequency changes when cash arrives, not how much the property earns. In AltStreet's hypothetical worked example (about $37 a year of net rent on $1,000), moving from a monthly dividend paid around the 25th of the following month to a daily payout is worth roughly 15 to 20 cents a year if the cash is reinvested at 4%. The amount of rent the property produces and the price you exit at move the result by tens of dollars on the same $1,000. One factual note: Arrived's help center describes monthly dividends for individual properties (article dated May 27, 2026), while the comparison table on Lofty's own how-it-works page listed Arrived's payouts as quarterly when AltStreet read it on October 6, 2026.
Can I sell my Lofty or Arrived investment whenever I want?+
You can place a sell order on Lofty at any time, and on Arrived only during a monthly one-week trading window, but neither lets you sell whenever you want at the price you want. On Lofty there is no holding period and orders can be placed around the clock; a sale still needs a buyer at your price, or a market order that executes at the best available bid. On October 5, 2026, 63 of 81 Lofty property tokens last traded below their original listing price, the median 29% below. On Arrived, individual-property shares become eligible once the property is fully funded and the shares have been held six months; all orders are limit orders, matched Monday to Friday, 9:30 AM to 5:00 PM ET during the window, and unmatched orders are canceled when the window closes. Arrived's funds use a quarterly redemption program instead, subject to approval and capacity.
How does Arrived's secondary market compare with Lofty's exchange?+
Lofty calls its venue 'the world's first real estate exchange'; AltStreet's review calls it a secondary marketplace, because Lofty's terms say it is not registered with the SEC as a national securities exchange or in any other capacity. Arrived's secondary market runs on PPEX, an alternative trading system operated by North Capital Private Securities Corporation, a registered broker-dealer. The practical differences: Lofty accepts market and limit orders at any hour and uses market makers for instant execution; Arrived accepts only limit orders, during one-week windows each month, with matching in real time inside market hours. Lofty settles trades in USDC; Arrived settles sales into the investor's Arrived Cash Balance, typically within 7 to 10 business days. Lofty's trade records are public; Arrived shows open orders and recent trades inside its platform, and AltStreet located no public trade-level data for it.
What does it cost to buy and later sell shares on each platform?+
Lofty, per its how-it-works page (read October 5 and 6, 2026): 2.5% on share purchases and 3% on share sales, about 5.4% of the cash you put in if the token price is unchanged when you sell. Market orders 'include a 2.5% fee paid to market makers for instant execution', and that fee is an addition: Lofty's help center (archived May 9, 2026) says market-order users 'end up paying more fees than with Limit orders' and that 'the extra fees are given directly to users who loaned out assets to the liquidity pool'. Charged on both legs, the round trip at an unchanged price is about 10%; limit orders avoid it. Arrived: no separate buyer fee on new offerings at $10 a share (the offering price already includes closing costs, escrow fees and a one-time sourcing fee), then up to 2.5% on the buy side and 2.5% on the sell side to its executing broker on the secondary market (help center, March 20, 2026), or a 6% to 7% disposition fee of the gross price when Arrived sells the property. On either platform, the gap between the price you trade at and the price you paid is usually a larger cost than the fee.
Do I own part of the property or just a token representing it?+
On both platforms you own an interest in a company that owns the house, not title to the house itself. A Lofty token is the membership interest in the property's Wyoming DAO LLC, issued on the Algorand blockchain; the LLC holds the property, and the operating agreements AltStreet read say that in a conflict between the agreement and the smart contract, the smart contract governs. An Arrived share is an interest in one series of a Delaware series LLC that owns the property; Arrived's help center says buying shares is 'directly buying ownership in the individual Series LLC that owns that asset', and Arrived's manager makes the operating decisions. AltStreet did not assess title or creditor rights for either structure.
Do I need cryptocurrency or a crypto wallet to use Lofty?+
You do not need to own cryptocurrency before you start: Lofty accepts card, bank transfer or USDC. But every Lofty trade settles in USDC, a dollar stablecoin, on the Algorand blockchain; a card or bank payment is converted to USDC, tokens sit in a Lofty wallet, and Lofty's site disclaimer says a filled sell order is paid in USDC, which 'can be converted to USD via third party cryptocurrency exchanges'. Lofty's terms describe its products as non-custodial and make users responsible for blockchain network fees unless an offer says otherwise. AltStreet did not open an account and did not test what converting proceeds to dollars costs. Arrived uses ordinary ACH bank transfers and involves no cryptocurrency.
What tax forms does each platform issue, and how many will I receive?+
Lofty says investors receive one pre-filled 1099-DIV covering every property they own, plus a single 1099-B if they sold shares during the year. That deserves clarification, because the operating agreements AltStreet reviewed contain partnership-style profit, loss and capital-account provisions; AltStreet did not establish the federal tax election of each Lofty property LLC, so do not infer the treatment of rental income from the 1099-DIV alone. Arrived says it sends a 'summarized' 1099-DIV by the end of January; each single-family series is intended to elect REIT status, while vacation rentals are not REIT-eligible and are taxed as corporations. Arrived consolidates secondary-market sales into one or two 1099-B forms (short-term and long-term), reports them as non-covered securities and provides cost basis in a supplemental statement. Checkbook IRA accounts on Arrived do not receive a 1099-DIV.
What happens if a property loses money or the platform closes?+
On Arrived, the help center says each property keeps a cash reserve, and if expenses exceed it Arrived's corporate entity makes a short-term loan repaid from future rent, with no capital call to investors; its FY2025 filings carry issuer-level going-concern explanatory paragraphs at the eight non-Debt-Fund issuers, which concern each issuer's liquidity, not property values. If Arrived stops operating, its help center says a new custodian would be assigned. On Lofty, each property LLC is managed by its token holders; in July 2026 draft governance packages proposed 12% credit lines plus a 2% fee from EARLDAO, a lending pool whose authorized representative manages most of the affected properties, to LLCs reporting negative cash positions (nine reported a combined minus $113,304). Lofty's terms say 'No assets on Lofty are controlled by Lofty'; AltStreet located no published plan for how trading or rent distribution would continue if Lofty AI stopped operating.
Can investors outside the United States use either platform?+
Lofty says yes: 'Anyone, both US and international investors, except residents of sanctioned countries', 18 or older with identity verification; non-US investors face US withholding on gains and rent withdrawals and are asked to file a W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E. Arrived says no: its platform is open to US citizens and green card holders who reside within the 50 states and are 18 or older (help center, May 26, 2026). This guide does not determine whether Lofty's offering is lawful in any particular country; check your own jurisdiction's rules.
Is either platform better than a publicly traded REIT?+
They solve different problems. A listed REIT or REIT fund pools many properties, trades on a stock exchange during market hours and reprices every day, typically at a lower trading cost than the fees on either platform. Lofty and Arrived let you choose one specific house, which concentrates the outcome in one tenant, one manager and one local market, and their exits are thinner: Lofty through a secondary marketplace where most tokens last traded below original listing, Arrived through monthly windows that depend on matching buyers. Arrived's own help center notes that lower reported volatility from periodic valuations 'does not mean lower risk'. If what you want is diversified, liquid real estate exposure, a listed REIT is the more direct tool; if you want property-level selection and accept the exit constraints, these platforms offer it.
What is the minimum investment on Lofty vs Arrived?+
Lofty tokens are often about $50 or less, and Lofty says you can buy for less than $50; one investor may own at most 15% of a property. Arrived's minimum is $100 in every offering (help center, July 24, 2026), at $10 a share, and an investor may hold at most 9.8% of a property's equity to protect REIT qualification. Arrived's offerings are Regulation A Tier 2, so non-accredited investors are also subject to the 10% of income or net worth annual limit.
What are the main alternatives to Lofty and Arrived?+
For single-house exposure, Ark7 sells Regulation A series with an in-house order book; for pooled real estate, Fundrise runs registered interval funds and Arrived itself runs pooled funds with quarterly redemption programs; for daily liquidity and diversification, listed REITs and REIT funds trade on stock exchanges. AltStreet's Ark7 vs Arrived and Fundrise vs Arrived guides compare those trade-offs in detail.
Full Platform Analysis: Lofty and Arrived
Each review is built from primary sources: Lofty's public API, 80 property data rooms and a California consent order; Arrived's Regulation A offering circulars, Forms 1-K, 1-SA and 1-U, and its help center. No affiliate framing.
Lofty Full Review
The 9.2% headline reproduced three ways, 63 of 81 tokens below original listing, offerings at 105% of appraisal, and the 2026 EARLDAO credit proposals.
Arrived Full Review
Nine Regulation A issuers, issuer-level going-concern paragraphs, the Debt Fund's audited income, the fee schedule by product, and the secondary market and redemption programs.
