Dinari vs Backed: dShares vs xStocks
Dinari's dShares and Backed's xStocks are two of the tokenized-stock brands AltStreet covers. Both track listed US stocks, and both are backed by real shares held somewhere. This guide reads the governing documents for each, the dShares Terms and Conditions, Dinari's Form CRS and app disclosures, Backed's xStocks legal overview and FAQ, and Kraken's xStocks FAQ, to separate what each token gives the holder from what each brand promises.
Guide Thesis
Backed by a stock is not the same as owning one.
Dinari's US dShare records a share in your brokerage account. Dinari's international dShare and Backed's xStock are issuer claims backed by shares the issuer holds. Issuer rules, exchange rules and the US versus international split decide the rest.
Research by AltStreet · Primary-source review · Updated October 6, 2026 · Editorial policy
Most dShares vs xStocks comparisons line up two products. There are three: Dinari sells a different legal instrument in the US than it sells everywhere else.
Dinari US: a share in your brokerage account, recorded by a token. Dinari international and Backed: a token backed by a share the issuer holds, on terms that withhold title.

The Core Decision
Where you live picks the instrument.
A US investor has one of these products available: a Dinari Securities brokerage account, where the token records shares held for the customer. An investor outside the US chooses between two issuer claims, Dinari's international dShare and Backed's xStock, and then lives under the rules of whichever exchange or wallet holds the token. The useful comparison outside the US is about the security package behind each claim, the dividend form and the exit, not about ownership, which neither international token confers.
US Access
Dinari (US account)
Dinari Securities, an SEC-registered broker-dealer, opened to US customers on August 4, 2026, with a $5,000 daily purchase cap. xStocks are not offered to US persons, per Backed and Kraken.
Share Held for You
Dinari US only
The US dShare records shares in your brokerage account. Dinari's non-US token and the xStock are claims on an issuer that holds the shares.
Published Reserves
xStocks
Backed publishes per-asset reserve data. Dinari cites a Big Four reserve audit; AltStreet located no report.
TL;DR
The structural difference in two sentences
Dinari runs two products under the dShares name: in the US, shares held in a brokerage account at an SEC-registered broker-dealer clearing through Alpaca, with the token as a record, a $5,000 daily purchase cap and a commission schedule visible only in the app; outside the US, a contractual token whose terms confer no "equity, redemption, or ownership interest" and pay dividends in a stablecoin. Backed's xStocks are Jersey-issued tracker certificates for non-US investors, "not direct equity ownership", with segregated collateral, an independent Security Agent, published per-asset reserve data, dividends reinvested by rebasing, and an issuer redemption with a $5,000 minimum.
If you read nothing else: scroll to the head-to-head comparison sections →
Dinari is structurally oriented toward
- → US brokerage positions with an on-chain record
- → Dividends distributed in a stablecoin (USDC in the US, per its materials)
- → A licensed US distribution path with published partner pricing
- → Commission and transfer rules confirmed inside the app
Backed is structurally oriented toward
- → Transferable stock exposure for non-US investors across many chains
- → DeFi use through a wrapped, non-rebasing token
- → Published per-asset reserve data and a Security Agent structure
- → Reinvested dividends and venue-set trading hours
One Apple position, three ways to hold it
The same exposure to one listed stock, held through each of the three products. Each cell restates the governing document; venue terms can add to the xStock column.
| Dinari US account | Dinari international dShare | xStock (outside the US) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you hold | Shares in a brokerage account at Dinari Securities, carried by Alpaca; the token records the position. | A contractual token from Dinari, Inc.; title to the share stays with Dinari. | A bearer debt tracker certificate from Backed Assets (JE) Limited, collateralized by the share. |
| Apple pays a dividend | USDC, per Dinari's materials; Form 1099 reporting. | A stablecoin deposit, less any service deduction or withholding; nothing under $1.00 per event. | No distribution; the token balance rises by the net dividend through the multiplier. |
| Apple holds a vote | Proxy process not stated in the materials reviewed; confirm in the app. | No voting or proxy mechanism unless agreed in writing; Dinari is holder of record. | No shareholder vote; Kraken reports a proxy-preference program for eligible holders. |
| You want out | Sell order through the broker. | Sell on a venue, or ask Dinari to repurchase at the realized sale price less fees and costs. | Sell on a venue, or redeem with the issuer after KYC at a $5,000 minimum. |
| Saturday afternoon | Trading hours for the US account are set by the broker; AltStreet did not establish weekend availability. | Dinari's order book runs 24/7; the price may diverge from the last close. | 24/7 only on venues that list it so (ten tickers on Kraken Pro); issuer redemption waits for Monday. |
| If the issuer or broker fails | SIPC customer-property protection for eligible missing securities and cash in a member broker's liquidation, within limits; not insurance of value. | Bermuda segregated account and an Annex 5 claims procedure Dinari may modify. | Security Agent may take control of collateral and distribute proceeds under the prospectus. |
Section 6.8
Dinari's international terms on ownership
The repurchase "does not confer ... any equity, redemption, or ownership interest"; title "shall remain with the Company" (dShares Terms and Conditions, revised December 26, 2025).
$5,000
Minimum to redeem xStocks with the issuer
Retail users may redeem directly after KYC; most exit on secondary markets, where the issuer sets no minimum (xStocks FAQ, fetched October 6, 2026). Separately, Dinari caps US purchases at $5,000 a day.
30%
US withholding in Kraken's xStocks rebase
Kraken computes the balance increase on the "Net Dividend (after 30% US withholding tax)" (Kraken FAQ, updated September 18, 2026). Dinari's international terms also permit IRS withholding and a service deduction.
Bottom Line Up Front
For a US investor the decision is made before the comparison starts. Dinari Securities is the only one of these routes offered to US persons, and it delivers a conventional brokerage position with a blockchain record attached. The trade-offs are that the broker is small and newly operational, purchases are capped at $5,000 a day, the menu is limited to dShares, and the commission schedule is not public.
Outside the US, the comparison is between two claims on issuers, and the documents point the same way on ownership: neither Dinari's international token nor the xStock gives title to the share. They differ in what protects the claim. Backed documents a Security Agent with power over segregated collateral and publishes per-asset reserve data. Dinari documents a Bermuda segregated account and a claims process it may change without notice, and the reserve audit it cites was not located.
Tokenized stock is a technology label, not an ownership structure, and the mistake to avoid is treating a brand as a structure. "dShares" names two legally different instruments, and an xStock's hours, fees, withdrawal rights and voting arrangements depend partly on the exchange you hold it on. Read the issuer's terms for what you own and the venue's terms for what you can do with it.
Head to Head
dShares vs xStocks, section by section
Issuer rules, exchange rules, US products and international products
Dinari vs Backed: US Access and Who Sets the Rules
Three layers decide who can buy what. The issuer sets eligibility in its terms: Backed does not offer xStocks to US persons, and Dinari, Inc. sells its international tokens only outside the US under Regulation S. A venue adds its own rules on top: Kraken lists xStocks for eligible clients outside the US, Canada, the UK and Australia, sets which ten tickers trade 24/7, and runs its own proxy-preference program; Bybit announced xStocks spot trading in June 2025 under its own terms. And the US product is its own regime: Dinari Securities, LLC, registered with the SEC as an introducing broker-dealer on June 20, 2025 and a FINRA member, opened US accounts on August 4, 2026.
| US persons | Dinari: US citizens and residents through Dinari Securities, $5,000 of total purchases per account per day ('Limits may change at any time'), no account minimum. Backed: 'not marketed, offered, or solicited in the United States, to U.S. Persons'. Dinari international tokens: not for US persons; Regulation S resale restrictions. |
|---|---|
| Non-US investors | Dinari: international dShares through Dinari's app and distribution partners, subject to an excluded-jurisdiction list. Backed: xStocks through partner exchanges and DeFi venues; Kraken lists 110-plus eligible countries. |
| Issuer-level rules | Dinari: dShares Terms and Conditions (revised December 26, 2025) for international tokens; Form CRS and Customer Brokerage Agreement for US accounts. Backed: base prospectus and product terms; xStocks docs. |
| Venue-level rules | Kraken: eligibility list, 24/7 trading on ten tickers and 24/5 on the rest, fees, self-custody withdrawals, Broadridge proxy-preference program (reported August 5, 2026). Bybit and other venues: their own terms. Dinari's own order book (Dinari Financial Network) runs 24/7 for supported tokens. |
Verdict
For a US investor this is not a close comparison: Dinari's US account is the only one of these products offered to US persons. For an investor outside the US, the comparison is between two issuer claims, Dinari's international token and the xStock, each bought through a venue whose own rules on hours, fees, withdrawals and eligibility apply on top of the issuer's.
A repurchase, a redemption and a sell order
Dinari vs Backed: Fees, Redemption and Spreads
The exits are three different mechanisms. A Dinari US customer sells through the broker. A Dinari international holder asks Dinari to repurchase under section 6: Dinari sells the underlying shares in the market and pays the proceeds, less fees and costs, in a stablecoin, with room in the terms to set limits, defer and delay. A Backed xStock holder either sells on a venue, which is how Backed says most users exit, or redeems with the issuer after KYC at a $5,000 minimum, in stablecoins or in kind for onboarded direct clients. On cost, neither company publishes a complete retail fee table, which makes venue spreads and conversion fees the costs a buyer can most readily see.
| Trading fees | Dinari US: commission 'on a transaction basis that varies based on the notional valuation of your trade' (Form CRS); schedule 'available on the Platform', no public copy located. Kraken xStocks: no trading fee when buying with USD or USDG; 'a fixed 1% trading fee applies when converting xStocks' (Kraken FAQ). |
|---|---|
| Minting and redemption | Dinari international: repurchase price is the sale price of the underlying less 'customary, actually incurred, third-party transaction costs' and website-listed fees (section 6.2). Backed: issuer issuance and redemption 24/5, $5,000 minimum, retail permitted after KYC; no public fee table. |
| Spreads | Dinari partner OTC orders from $25,000 at a spread typically up to 10 basis points (docs). Dinari's own order book: 36 of 719 tickers and $6,471.79 of reported 24-hour volume in one Saturday window captured October 3, 2026, one venue only. xStocks: 'pricing is determined by supply and demand on each platform'; spreads vary by venue and hour. |
| Blockchain costs | Dinari partners: $0.20 network fee per order on most chains, Ethereum mainnet at gas. xStocks: gas on the chain you use; CCIP bridge between supported networks. |
Verdict
For a small holder outside the US, the realistic exit on either token is a venue sale, so the spread on that venue is the cost that matters most. Backed's $5,000 issuer minimum is published; Dinari's repurchase is available to KYC-verified holders without a published minimum but on terms Dinari can adjust. US buyers of Dinari face a commission they can see only inside the app.
What stands between the holder and the share
Dinari vs Backed: Custody, Reserves and Counterparty Risk
Counterparty risk lives in different places. The Dinari US customer's main exposure is the brokerage chain: a small, newly operational introducing broker (its audited statement at December 31, 2025, before launch, showed $251,516 of total assets, $80,187 of member's equity and no customer accounts) and Alpaca as carrying broker and custodian, under the Rule 15c3-3 and SIPC framework. The Dinari international holder's exposure is Dinari, Inc. itself, the Bermuda segregated account and a claims procedure Dinari may modify. The xStock holder's exposure is a Jersey issuer whose collateral is segregated product by product, pledged under a three-party agreement and watched by an independent Security Agent that can take control on default. Venue risk is separate again for anyone who leaves tokens on an exchange.
| Custodian | Dinari US: Alpaca Securities LLC carries accounts and holds customer securities and cash under Rule 15c3-3. Dinari international: accounts in Dinari's name 'for the benefit of the Token program', currently a Bermuda Registered Segregated Accounts Company (section 3.7). xStocks: regulated custodians in dedicated sub-accounts; Kraken's FAQ names Alpaca Securities LLC. |
|---|---|
| Reserve evidence | Dinari: 'Reserve audits are performed by an independent Big 4 accounting firm'; no report, auditor or total located; reserve link resolved to market data (October 3, 2026). Backed: per-asset reserve data it publishes at defi.xstocks.fi and through a public API endpoint, not an audited attestation. |
| Issuer failure | Dinari international: shares stay in the segregated account under an independent Segregated Account Representative; claims procedure in Annex 5, modifiable 'at any time by Dinari, in its sole and absolute discretion without advance notice'. xStocks: 'In the event of issuer default, the security agent may assume control of the collateral accounts and distribute proceeds to token holders in accordance with the prospectus terms' (xStocks FAQ). |
| Broker or custodian failure | Dinari US: SIPC can protect eligible customer securities and cash missing in a member broker's liquidation, up to $500,000 including $250,000 for cash; it does not insure market value, USDC, or dShares in self-custody, and the limit is not additive across Dinari Securities and Alpaca. Dinari international and xStocks: no SIPC for the token holder; the protection is the segregation and pledge structure described by each issuer. |
Verdict
Backed publishes per-asset reserve data that lets users check the collateral information it exposes publicly. That is more verifiable than Dinari's unpublished Big Four reserve-audit claim, but it is not an audited solvency statement or a guarantee of recovery. Dinari's US account is the only one of these held in a US brokerage custody chain where SIPC customer-property protection can apply. How either structure would perform in an insolvency depends on governing law, collateral perfection, custodian failure, competing claims and enforcement, which neither issuer's materials let a holder fully model.
dShares vs xStocks: which one is ownership of a stock?
Short answer
Only Dinari's US product puts the share in the investor's own brokerage account, and there the token is a record, 'not a separate investment'. Dinari's international token and Backed's xStock are both backed by shares the issuer holds, and both governing documents say the holder does not own them: Dinari's terms leave 'Title to, and all incidents of ownership in, the Underlying Assets' with the company, and Backed calls xStocks 'structured financial instruments, not direct equity ownership'.
Dinari's marketing describes dShares around economic equivalence, "the same economic rights you'd get holding the underlying stock", and "direct redemption". For the international product, the terms make that equivalence contractual. Section 4.5(a) gives the holder "a claim to the value of said underlying asset" while stating "you will not have any claim of right or title to the actual Underlying Asset". Section 6.8 describes the exit as "a contractual put right". Economic equivalence and the absence of title are not a contradiction; the point to press is the exit, which the page calls redemption and the terms call a repurchase that confers no redemption interest.
Backed is direct about the form: a bearer debt instrument classified as a tracker certificate, issued by a Jersey special purpose vehicle that holds Jersey Financial Services Commission consents, under a base prospectus approved by the Liechtenstein FMA. The holder's position is a creditor claim secured by collateral, not a shareholding. That is a different kind of claim from Dinari's international token, which rests on Dinari's contract and a Bermuda segregated account rather than a pledge to a Security Agent.
Gemini, which distributed Dinari-issued tokens in the EU until its February 2026 wind-down there, described them in its 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2026 as "tokenized tracker certificates" providing exposure "without conveying legal ownership or shareholder rights, such as voting rights". That is a distributor's description of the international product; it does not describe Dinari's US accounts, which did not exist until August 2026.
Can US investors use Dinari or Backed?
Short answer
A US investor can open a Dinari Securities account and buy dShares, up to $5,000 of purchases a day. xStocks are not offered to US persons under Backed's documentation, and Kraken lists them for eligible clients outside the US, Canada, the UK and Australia. Dinari's international tokens are also closed to US persons under Regulation S.
Dinari Securities, LLC registered with the SEC as an introducing broker-dealer on June 20, 2025 (CRD 329672) and became a FINRA member; it opened to US customers on August 4, 2026 with 724 symbols including the S&P 500, funding in USDC through Circle or by ACH. Its Form CRS says the menu is limited to dShares, which it calls "proprietary products", and that commissions vary with the trade. Its first audited statement, at December 31, 2025, predates the launch and shows no customer accounts.
Backed's restriction is an issuer rule, and venues apply their own lists on top of it. That is why a reader can see xStocks quoted on a site that also serves US users: listing on a venue does not change who the issuer offers the product to. AltStreet's Backed review found no US Form D for the tokenization issuer. Kraken announced on December 2, 2025 that it would acquire Backed Finance AG; AltStreet has not verified completion, and the Jersey issuer and prospectus structure are unchanged in the documents reviewed.
How do dividends and redemption compare?
Short answer
Dinari distributes dividends in a stablecoin, USDC on US accounts according to its materials and a US dollar stablecoin on international tokens, the latter subject to a possible service deduction and a $1.00 minimum. Backed reinvests dividends net of withholding and raises token balances through an on-chain multiplier. To exit, Dinari US customers sell through the broker, Dinari international holders can require a repurchase at the realized sale price less costs, and xStock holders can redeem with the issuer after KYC at a $5,000 minimum.
Dinari's international repurchase is defined in section 6. A Sell Order instructs Dinari to sell the underlying "on the first available date" it can; the price is the fair market value at the time of sale, less third-party transaction costs and fees listed on the website; settlement is in a US dollar stablecoin. Dinari may set minimum and maximum thresholds and frequency limits, may defer settlement pro rata where immediate settlement would breach law or transfer restrictions or impair orderly liquidation, and may delay for a market disruption event. Those are disclosed conditions, not a finding that they have been used.
Backed's FAQ says retail users are legally permitted to redeem with the issuer, subject to KYC and the $5,000 minimum, and that "In practice, most users access liquidity through secondary markets." Its docs describe stablecoin issuance and redemption in USDC, USDG or USDT and an in-kind flow, xPort, that converts between shares and tokens through a brokerage provider, Alpaca. Kraken's FAQ says xStocks held there cannot be moved to a traditional brokerage account, so the in-kind path is an issuer facility for onboarded clients, not a feature of every venue.
For fintech builders: a sidebar
Dinari API vs Backed: tokenized equities API in brief
The two integration models differ the way the products do. A dShares integration licenses Dinari's stack: an API from $2,000 a month, published per-order network, conversion, OTC and NBBO data fees, an embedded trading app first deployed by Bitcoin.com on September 15, 2026, and a US compliance playbook under which partners act "solely as introducing or referral platforms" and display Dinari's disclosures verbatim. An xStocks integration is closer to listing a token: a public API (asset metadata, prices, multipliers, published reserve data, oracle feeds) plus authenticated issuance and redemption flows for onboarded clients, wrapped ERC-4626 tokens for DeFi, and the requirement to apply the rebasing multiplier correctly so user balances are right.
AltStreet reviews investor outcomes, not developer tooling, so this section summarizes published documentation without scoring it. Integrators should read Dinari's partner terms and Backed's exchange-integration docs directly.
AltStreet Terminal
Do this comparison before you invest: find the clause that says who owns the share.
AltStreet holds the documents and verbatim passages behind both reviews, from the dShares terms, Dinari Securities' audited annual report and Form CRS to the xStocks terms and prospectus disclosures, with Dinari's SEC filings tracked as they arrive.
The AltStreet Take
Dinari and Backed both put US-stock exposure on-chain, but the words "tokenized stock" hide three different legal relationships. A Dinari US customer has a conventional brokerage position in the underlying security, with the dShare functioning as a blockchain record of that position. A Dinari international customer owns a contractual token whose governing terms expressly leave title to the underlying asset with Dinari. An xStock holder owns a Jersey-issued tracker certificate backed by segregated securities and a documented collateral and security-agent arrangement. For non-US investors, the comparison is not which token "owns the stock"; neither does. It is which contractual claim, custody chain, reserve disclosure, dividend mechanic and exit process the investor prefers. Tokenized stock is a technology label, not an ownership structure. On the documents, Dinari's US account is the only product here where the investor has the underlying stock position in a brokerage account. Everywhere else, including Dinari's own product outside the US, the investor holds a claim on an issuer that holds the share, and the quality of that claim is the thing to compare.
The two companies built different architectures. Dinari has built a US broker-dealer distribution structure: Dinari Securities introduces the customer account and Alpaca acts as carrying broker. Backed instead documents an international collateral-and-security-agent structure for xStocks, with product-by-product segregation and per-asset reserve data it publishes. The xStock's security package is the more fully documented of the two issuer claims; whether it would recover more in an insolvency depends on law and facts no document settles in advance. These are different structures aimed at different investors, and neither substitutes for the other.
The open items are specific. For Dinari: the US commission schedule, the reserve audit it cites, the US proxy process, and whether US tokens can leave the account. For Backed: a public fee table for issuance and redemption, and what Kraken's ownership means for the Jersey issuer and the Security Agent once documented. Investors relying on either token should read the governing terms for their jurisdiction and the venue's terms before treating the token as equivalent to the share.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Dinari dShares and Backed xStocks?+
Both are tokens that track listed US stocks, but they rest on different legal structures, and Dinari runs two of its own. A US dShare is the blockchain record of a position in a brokerage account at Dinari Securities, LLC, an SEC-registered broker-dealer that clears through Alpaca Securities; Dinari's app says the token is 'not a separate investment' and the account statement is 'the official record of your holdings'. A dShare sold outside the US is a separate contractual token that Dinari, Inc. offers and sells in reliance on Regulation S; its terms leave title to the shares with Dinari. An xStock is, in Backed's words, 'a bearer debt instrument classified as a tracker certificate' issued by Backed Assets (JE) Limited, a Jersey company, which Backed represents as fully collateralized by the corresponding underlying securities. Put simply, the US dShare records a stock position you have in a brokerage account, while the non-US dShare and the xStock are claims on an issuer that holds the share.
Does owning either token mean I legally own the underlying stock?+
Dinari's US product gives the customer a conventional brokerage position in the underlying stock; the dShare is the blockchain record of that position rather than a separate security. Dinari's app says stocks bought through Dinari Securities 'are held in your brokerage account' and that dShares 'are not a separate investment'. AltStreet did not determine whether shares are registered in the customer's own name or held through the broker's custody or nominee structure, as brokerage positions commonly are. Outside the US, section 6.8 of the dShares Terms and Conditions (revised December 26, 2025) says the repurchase right 'does not confer upon the Purchaser/Participant any equity, redemption, or ownership interest in the Company or in the Underlying Assets. Title to, and all incidents of ownership in, the Underlying Assets shall remain with the Company.' Backed's legal overview says 'xStocks are structured financial instruments, not direct equity ownership.' This guide describes what each document says; it does not determine how a regulator or court in any jurisdiction would characterize either instrument.
Can US investors buy dShares or xStocks?+
US investors can open an account with Dinari Securities, which began serving US customers on August 4, 2026, and buy dShares there, subject to a $5,000 daily purchase cap per account shown in the app on October 3, 2026. xStocks are a different case. Backed's documentation says xStocks 'are not marketed, offered, or solicited in the United States, to U.S. Persons, or in any other prohibited jurisdiction', and Kraken's xStocks FAQ (updated September 18, 2026) lists the product as available to eligible non-US clients and not in the US, Canada, the UK or Australia. Because xStocks are freely transferable tokens, one might be technically reachable on a permissionless venue, but that would sit outside the issuer's authorized US distribution and would not provide the US brokerage-account and SIPC framework described for Dinari's domestic product. Dinari's non-US dShares are also not for US persons: they are offered and sold in reliance on Regulation S with US resale restrictions.
Are Dinari's US and international products legally the same?+
No. They share a brand and a token format, not a legal structure. The US product is a self-directed brokerage account at Dinari Securities, LLC, carried by Alpaca Securities, with the token recording the position. The international product is a token issued by the parent, Dinari, Inc., offered and sold outside the US in reliance on Regulation S, with the underlying shares held in an account in Dinari's name, currently at a Bermuda segregated accounts company, and a repurchase right the terms call 'a contractual put right'. Different entity, different custody chain, different protections: SIPC customer-property protection can apply to the US account through its broker-dealer custody chain and does not apply to the international token.
Which product provides voting rights?+
Neither token carries shareholder voting rights under its issuer's documents. Dinari's international terms (section 4.5(d)) say Dinari 'does not support voting rights or proxy mechanisms for Token holders unless otherwise agreed in writing' and that 'Voting rights shall be retained by Dinari or the underlying custodian.' Backed says an xStock 'does not confer shareholder voting rights.' Two qualifications. First, a venue can add its own program: The Block reported on August 5, 2026 that Kraken's parent, working with Broadridge, will let eligible non-US xStocks holders submit proxy voting preferences; that is an exchange-level arrangement, and AltStreet has not reviewed how preferences are cast or whether they bind the record holder. Second, Dinari's US customers hold shares in a brokerage account, where proxy rights normally run through the broker; AltStreet did not locate a statement of Dinari's US proxy process in the materials it reviewed, so a US customer should confirm it in the app.
How are dividends paid or reflected in token balances?+
Three different ways. On Dinari's US account, Dinari's materials say dividends are paid in USDC, and they are reported as dividends on the broker's Form 1099. On Dinari's international tokens, section 4.5(c) of the terms says eligible dividends are deposited to the holder's wallet in a US dollar stablecoin of Dinari's choosing, that Dinari 'reserves the right to deduct a portion of your dividend for the services rendered', that dividends under $1.00 per customer per event 'will not be distributed', and that Dinari may withhold for the IRS. xStocks make no stablecoin or cash distribution: Backed's docs say dividends are 'reinvested net of applicable withholding taxes' through an on-chain multiplier that raises token balances, activated at 00:30 UTC the day after the ex-date, and Kraken's FAQ computes the adjustment on the dividend 'after 30% US withholding tax'.
Can I redeem tokens for cash or transfer the underlying shares to a broker?+
On Dinari's US account, you sell through the broker; there is no separate token redemption because the token is not a separate investment. On Dinari's international tokens, section 6 of the terms lets a KYC-verified holder require Dinari to repurchase at the price Dinari receives when it sells the underlying, less fees and transaction costs, paid in a US dollar stablecoin; Dinari may set minimums, maximums and frequency limits, defer settlement in defined cases, and delay for a market disruption event. The terms give no right to receive the shares. On xStocks, Backed's FAQ says retail users 'are legally permitted to redeem directly with the issuer, subject to KYC requirements and the $5,000 minimum transaction size', in stablecoins or, for onboarded direct clients, in kind through its xPort flow with Alpaca as brokerage provider. That is the issuer's rule; Kraken's FAQ says xStocks 'cannot be transferred to a traditional brokerage account'. Check which path your venue actually offers.
Who holds the backing securities?+
For Dinari's US accounts, Alpaca Securities LLC carries the accounts and holds customer securities and cash under Rule 15c3-3; Dinari Securities introduces and supervises them. For Dinari's international tokens, section 3.7 of the terms says the shares are credited to accounts 'maintained in the name of Dinari (or an affiliated company) for the benefit of the Token program' with a qualified custodian or broker-dealer, currently in a Bermuda Registered Segregated Accounts Company. For xStocks, Backed says the collateral sits with regulated custodians in dedicated, non-commingled accounts under a three-party Account Control Agreement with an independent Security Agent, and Kraken's FAQ says the underlying shares 'are held by Alpaca Securities LLC'. Alpaca therefore appears in both chains, in different roles: as carrying broker for a Dinari US customer's own account, and as custodian for the xStocks issuer's collateral.
What happens if the issuer, exchange or custodian fails?+
It depends on which party fails and which product you hold. For Dinari's US account, SIPC can protect eligible customer securities and cash that are missing in a member broker's liquidation, subject to the $500,000 limit, including $250,000 for cash; it does not insure the stock's value, USDC, or a token after it has left the brokerage custody environment, and having both Dinari Securities and Alpaca involved does not double the limit. If Dinari stops operating, the international terms say the shares remain in the Bermuda segregated account under an independent Segregated Account Representative and holders follow a claims procedure (Annex 5) that Dinari 'may' modify 'at any time ... without advance notice'. If Backed's issuer defaults, its FAQ says 'the security agent may assume control of the collateral accounts and distribute proceeds to token holders in accordance with the prospectus terms'. A failure of the exchange where you keep the token is a separate risk governed by that exchange's terms; tokens withdrawn to your own wallet remove that venue exposure but add key-management risk.
Can I keep the tokens in my own wallet and use them in DeFi?+
xStocks, yes, as a design feature: Backed's FAQ says they are freely transferable SPL Token-2022 or ERC-20 tokens, Kraken lets eligible clients withdraw them to Solana, Ethereum, TON or Ink, and Backed provides wrapped, non-rebasing ERC-4626 versions because rebasing balances do not work natively in lending markets or AMMs. Dinari's international tokens are on-chain tokens on networks including Arbitrum, Ethereum, Base and Avalanche, subject to the Regulation S transfer restrictions in the terms. Dinari's US product is unsettled in its own documents: the Form CRS effective August 31, 2026 says customers may transfer dShares to a self-custody wallet, the technical docs updated June 22, 2026 say US tokens are 'currently non-transferrable and are restricted from use in DeFi protocols', and the app says SIPC does not cover dShares moved to self-custody. Confirm the current rule in the app. Whether a given lending protocol accepts either token as collateral is that protocol's decision.
Can token prices diverge from the underlying stock outside market hours?+
Yes, and both issuers say so in their own way. Dinari's terms (section 3.6) state that token prices 'may diverge from the live market price of the corresponding underlying security due to FX movements, on-chain liquidity, trading fees, or other synthetic market inputs' and that Dinari 'does not guarantee parity'. Backed's FAQ says secondary pricing 'is determined by supply and demand on each platform' and 'The issuer does not control pricing on secondary markets.' The structural reason is the same for both: issuance and redemption track US market hours (24/5 for xStocks, normal or extended trading hours for Dinari's repurchase), while some venues trade the tokens around the clock, so a weekend or overnight price is a market print set while issuer issuance and redemption are unavailable to anchor it. Kraken's FAQ lists ten xStocks it trades 24/7 and says the rest trade 24/5.
What fees apply to trading, minting, redemption and blockchain transactions?+
Neither issuer publishes a complete retail fee schedule. Dinari's US Form CRS says commissions vary 'based on the notional valuation of your trade' and by security, with the schedule available on the platform; AltStreet located no public copy. Dinari's partner docs publish a $0.20 network fee per order on most chains, USDT conversion at oracle rate plus 3 basis points, and OTC spreads typically up to 10 basis points from $25,000; its international repurchase price is net of fees 'set out on the Dinari Website' and transaction costs, and its dividends may be reduced by a service deduction. Backed publishes no all-in fee table for issuance or redemption. On the venue side, Kraken's FAQ lists no trading fee on xStocks bought with USD or USDG and 'a fixed 1% trading fee' when converting xStocks. Spreads on other exchanges and DEX pools, and gas on each chain, come on top and vary by venue and time of day.
Who owns Backed now?+
Kraken announced on December 2, 2025 that it would acquire Backed Finance AG, the Swiss parent; terms were not disclosed. The xStocks issuer remains Backed Assets (JE) Limited in Jersey under a base prospectus approved by the Liechtenstein FMA, per Backed's documentation. AltStreet's Backed review records the acquisition's completion as unverified in its sources, and no change to the Jersey issuer or Security Agent arrangement has been documented in the materials reviewed.
Is there published proof of reserves for dShares or xStocks?+
For xStocks, Backed publishes per-asset reserve data through its xStocks DeFi portal and a public API endpoint. That lets users check the collateral information Backed exposes publicly; it is Backed-published data, not an audited solvency statement, and it does not by itself establish what a holder recovers in an insolvency. For dShares, Dinari's page says 'Reserve audits are performed by an independent Big 4 accounting firm to confirm 1:1 backing'; AltStreet located no published report, auditor identity or reserve total, and the page's 'latest reserve breakdown' link resolved to a market-data page when captured October 3, 2026. For Dinari's US accounts, the brokerage statement and Alpaca's custody are the record of holdings.
Full Platform Analysis: Dinari and Backed
Each review is built from the platform's own legal documents and the public record: terms and conditions, Form CRS, audited broker-dealer filings, prospectus-level product documentation and issuer data. No affiliate framing.
Dinari Full Review
Two products under one name, the broker-dealer's pre-launch audit, the $5,000 daily cap, the commission schedule and the reserve audit AltStreet could not locate.
Backed Full Review
The xStocks tracker-certificate structure, the Jersey issuer, custody and published reserve data, the full product catalog and on-chain pricing risk.
